Important that elected officials don’t jump to conclusions and act without hearing from all sides

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

Dana Grubb is a lifelong resident of the City of Bethlehem who worked 27 years for the City of Bethlehem in the department of community and economic development, as sealer of weights and measures, housing rehabilitation finance specialist, grants administrator, acting director of community and economic development, and deputy director of community development.

Gadfly,

I’ve been trying to keep up with all that is being written and said on this issue and how it relates to systemic racism in America. I’ve spoken with many people from a variety of backgrounds. My list of suggestions and observations is by no means complete. However, I believe there are some very fundamental steps that could be taken and explored. They are in no particular order.

Dana

Personally, I think there is too much rhetoric flying around and some people are not using common sense. Law enforcement is a necessity to maintain an orderly and safe society, period. So, calls to eliminate policing anywhere make no sense to me.

If I was the Mayor, I would be setting up community forums to receive commentary from all sides of the issue. I would make it as easy as possible for people to weigh in and would take steps to allow and encourage all voices to be heard so that the discourse is fair. Given the pandemic, these might need to be virtual meetings, but I think before anything is done we need to hear more from all corners of the city. Some residents and a business owner have expressed their concerns to me about retribution if they speak up in any way that might be construed as opposition to the current dialogue.

I don’t like the term defund because in my mind and for many others it has a negative connotation. I understand what is meant by it, but if this was a company trying to sell a product and they continually used terms that turned off their potential market and customers, their product wouldn’t sell. I think it frightens a lot of residents who recognize that we need law enforcement and that overall we have a pretty good PD in Bethlehem, but who also believe strongly in equal application of our laws.

That being said, I think we should always be looking for ways to improve the PD, especially in the area of relationships with all corners of our community.

More regular de-escalation training is a start. I don’t know the current frequency. I do believe that when any officer responds to a call their primary intent should be to maintain the peace. I also recognize that in some situations this may not be possible because of the heightened seriousness of a situation.

I think if there is a bad cop on the force, the process for removing them should be fair, yet swift.

If there is a way to mesh social services with law enforcement, I support that union in situations where it is applicable. Mental health issues have normally been the responsibility of state and county, so I’m not sure if cities have that capacity. I think it makes sense to hire police officers who also have a broader academic background such as in sociology as well as law enforcement. Perhaps degrees in criminal justice, of which I have no familiarity, need to incorporate a minor in sociology?

I think community policing has become a lost art in Bethlehem and would look to re-establish team policing and neighborhood bike patrols the way I remember and experienced them in the past. When the same officers worked in the same neighborhoods, they built relationships with residents and established a higher level of trust and respect between themselves and decent law-abiding citizens from all walks of life. A number of retired Bethlehem officers that I know feel those efforts achieved a great deal of success.

A former police officer has mentioned to me that the pressure-point training officers used to receive allowed them to better control a physical altercation. This would reduce the potential for the use of lethal force if that training was re-introduced and emphasized the way it apparently once was.

More minority hires would be helpful in law enforcement as I believe that a police force and the community are better served if they mirror each other in composition. From all I’ve read and been told law enforcement recruitment has become a challenge. What are those challenges, and how do you overcome them?

When I was hired by the city, all city employees including police had to be city residents. That was eliminated in 1988, so officers can now be hired from anywhere. Many new hires don’t have the in-place relationships with the community that generations of officers before them had. My personal preference would be to see some limits on where they must live, like in the city or in any municipality contiguous with the city as an example. This way they are more local and there’s a better chance for them to get to know the community than if they are living in the out-of-state or in the Poconos, as examples. I’m not sure how the FOP union feels about that, but I think it’s a discussion that should take place.

It’s my understanding that racial sensitivity training is already being done. Perhaps there can be more frequent or an updated method of training, if there are any alternative newer ways of looking at this. I feel very strongly as a lifetime resident of Bethlehem that my minority friends should be treated no differently than I would be, when interacting with a Bethlehem officer.

I’ve read that the school district and city are looking at whether school resource police officers are needed in our middle and high schools. The need for that has been raised by minority students. The data needs to be analyzed to see whether it’s effective or not

What I think is really important is that elected officials don’t jump to conclusions and act without hearing from all sides of the issue. Listening is critical.

We need to find the right balance between having effective law enforcement and meeting community needs and expectations. Knee-jerk reactions will not serve Bethlehem or any community well. The burden for achieving this doesn’t just fall on police; it falls on each of us because of the social contract we have in our free society.

 

Bad timing for Gadfly

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Yes, bad timing for Gadfly.

Tonight is the 3rd in the Bethlehem Area Public Library series “Dialogues on Racial Justice: An Introductory Workshop Series on Issues of Systemic Racism in the United States.“

Same time as the long awaited Public Safety Committee meeting on the Bethlehem police use of force.

And tonight’s workshop subject?

You guessed it, “”Police Brutality: A Historic Perspective.”

Damnation. The perfect subject to be thinking about.

But this gives Gadfly a great opportunity to say again that one has to really admire the relevant educational programming coming out of BAPL.

And to give you an idea of the substantial impact this “Dialogues” series is having, I’d recommend taking a look at Hannah Provost’s article — “The Construction of Race and How Racism is Maintained: A Conversation Facilitated by Linda Wiggins-Chavis” — in “Southsider.” Yep, that there’s “our” Southside they’re talkin’ about in the title.

And while at “Southsider” be sure to browse around.

The site is stunningly beautiful and intellectually substantial. You’ll find a lot to like.

Gadfly found himself intrigued by Danny Digitall’s “Photography of Living Six-Feet-Apart.”

Enjoy!

Ochs on Citizen Review Boards

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Ever wonder about citizens involved in police misconduct matters?

Gadfly believes Allentown may be voting on a CRB tomorrow night. Will be interesting to see what happens there.

Gadfly was struck by such info on different forms of CRBs in the Rushin article discussed earlier: “Communities could elect civilians to a commission tasked with the creation of police disciplinary procedures, with recommendations from police management and union leaders. Communities could establish notice-and-comment procedures, similar to those employed by many administrative agencies, to promulgate disciplinary policies. Conversely, states could require communities to establish police disciplinary procedures in the same manner that they establish municipal ordinances—presumably through a public hearing and vote by local elected officials.”

Here are some notes by Prof Holona Ochs.

Ochs, Citizen Review Boards

Clips:

CRBs are committees charged with providing oversight of police compliance with the law and potentially offering transparency, accountability, and input regarding the administrative processes.

Members of the public cite the following potential benefits of citizen oversight:
(1) satisfy public concerns about the accountability of the police;
(2) reassurance that the appropriate discipline is implemented for misconduct;
(3) discourage police misconduct; and
(4) improvement in the public understanding of police work.

[There are] four models of citizen review boards that fall within the reactive approach.

The Collaborative Audit model [is a proactive model].

Effective procedures for public review of citizen complaints against the police require a fundamental shift in the traditional handling of citizen complaints, and a complaint process that makes consistent efforts to inform citizens of the review process and receive all complaints, that provides thorough and unbiased evaluations, and that is likewise subject to review is extremely difficult to establish and maintain.

CRBs should be structured to facilitate cooperation, and the results of the independent investigations should produce findings and recommendations that require a formal response from political and administrative authorities.

In order for CRBs to function as either a specific or general deterrent, the disposition would have to lead to discipline consistently to impact policing outcomes, and the extent to which the mechanisms of internal and external oversight provide consistent sources of management information determine whether or not oversight is mutually reinforcing or simply inefficient.

Citizen Review Boards (CRBs) tend to be reactively rather than proactively designed, which can lead to a backlash by police over time.

“Freedom from hunger . . . so all families can thrive”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

A special tip o’ the hat to all the many organizations that our community has that are working to make sure everyone has access to healthy, abundant food.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

Ochs: highlights from the Police documents

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Public Safety Committee meeting Tuesday, August 11, 6PM: must register

Prof Holona Ochs:

Highlights from the BPD report (Mickel, Irons, & Strouse)

  • People of color make up 60-80% of incidents (compared to 44% of the city) and whites between 30-40% (compared to 60% of the city)
  • The single largest age range subject to use of force are 18-25 year-olds (an average of 37% of use of force incidents) . . . this range includes 18 and 19-year-old teenagers.
  • There are about 8-9 minors subject to force each year. In our view, subjecting minors to force is absolutely inexcusable.
  • BPD is quick to point out that incidents involving force are a small percentage of overall arrests. However, the majority of arrests in Bethlehem are for minor crimes like vandalism, drunkenness, and lesser offenses not even specifically named. Use of force in those incidents needs to be closely examined.
  • The Bethlehem Crime report revealed that 81% of Bethlehem cops are white men. (White men make up only about 30% of the Bethlehem population).
  • In addition, 70% of complaints to BPD are made by white people, which is again an overrepresentation. I recognize that it is less stark than the makeup of the police force, but it does speak to who feels that they have access to police as a safe service to call . . . and when viewed in combination with who is a police officer, this makes sense. ***
  • Bottom line: It’s white people calling a white police force, which overwhelmingly uses force on young brown and Black people.

*** Gadfly remembers a point made by Councilwoman Negron at last Council meeting, that the low number of Latinx complaints to the police department does not mean that all is good but that they are scared, do not trust the police. Real food for thought there.

Ochs graphs use of force incidents by reason

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Public Safety Committee meeting Tuesday, August 11, 6PM: must register

Prof Holona Ochs:

This graph shows the purpose of the uses of force. It destroys the fallacy that police have to be forceful because their lives are at risk; instead it is most often just to make a successful arrest. In a context where Bethlehem primarily experiences nonviolent crime, one should question why police are using violence to complete their arrests of primarily nonviolent offenders.

It is also worth noting that the BPD use of force policy allows for very loose definitions of “threat,” and so the increase of using force to “defend” may be more about shifting ideas of what constitutes threat than a threat that you or I would define with all the facts in hand.

Ochs 4

Ochs graphs use of force incidents by race

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Public Safety Committee meeting Tuesday, August 11, 6PM: must register

Gadfly’s been trying to cover a lot of context and background  for the meeting with the Police tomorrow night. Time, perhaps, to look at some of the documents provided for the meeting. Prof. Ochs is giving us some of her insights and that of her research team.


Prof Holona Ochs:

Ochs 1

Ochs 3

“We, as a community, need to imagine leadership differently”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

We, as a community, need to imagine leadership differently.

  • There is evidence that Black leadership can lead to more peaceful police-public relations.
  • There is also evidence demonstrating that women lead in the same ways and as well as men.
  • The inclusion of womxn in policing has a demonstrated effect on constructively addressing gender-based violence.
  • It is unconscionable that we do not have officers openly representing the LGBT+ community and no task force to assist officers as they try to improve their relations with the LGBT+ community as well.
  •  Addressing gender-based violence is inextricably linked to addressing white supremacy/misanthrophy.
  • Strong leadership is about active listening.

Prof Holona Ochs

“Scholars have noted that the doctrine of qualified immunity is not supported by the empirical evidence”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Scholars have noted that the doctrine of qualified immunity is not
supported by the empirical evidence.

Prof Holona Ochs

from Hailey Fuchs, “Qualified Immunity Protection for Police Emerges as Flash Point Amid Protests.” New York Times, June 23, 2020.

Mr. Jones’s brothers, Robert and Bruce, have tried for years to hold the police accountable for Wayne’s death but have repeatedly run into hurdles: Most recently, the officers claimed they could not be held liable under so-called qualified immunity, an esoteric legal doctrine invoked by police departments across the country for decades in response to allegations of excessive force. It provides legal protections for officers when they are accused of violating others’ constitutional rights.

Once a little-known rule, qualified immunity has emerged as a flash point in the protests spurred by Mr. Floyd’s killing and galvanized calls for police reform. In the vast majority of cases of police brutality, officers are never criminally prosecuted. For families of victims seeking some sort of relief through the justice system, qualified immunity presents another obstacle to obtaining financial or other damages. Even in the rare cases where the officers are charged, as in Mr. Floyd’s death, the police can still claim qualified immunity if relatives or victims sue them.

Activists have seized on qualified immunity as what they see as one of the biggest problems with policing and argued that it shields officers from being held accountable in cases of misconduct. Police leaders said it was essential for officers’ ability to respond to calls and to make split-second decisions.

Qualified immunity is a focal point of the new debate on Capitol Hill over how to address systemic racism in policing and use of excessive force. House Democrats unveiled a bill that would allow victims of police brutality to seek damages from their assailants. A competing Senate Republican bill made no mention of qualified immunity, and the White House press secretary, Kayleigh McEnany, called it a “total and complete nonstarter.”

Though the doctrine is intended to protect officers from paying for the damages they cause, he said the result is that officers are more likely to abuse their powers.

Advocates on behalf of the police insisted that qualified immunity was necessary for officers to protect the public. Its protections allow officers to make life-or-death decisions in a matter of seconds, they said, and without it, fewer people might be willing to join police forces.

The doctrine does not apply in criminal cases like those pending against the officers involved in the death of Mr. Floyd.

In the vast majority of cases where officers are not charged, victims can pursue justice only in the form of financial or other damages through lawsuits. Qualified immunity can block them from obtaining relief.

“Officer pay should reflect the level of expertise and difficulty of the task and importance of the purpose. Existing incentive structures should be re-examined”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Officer pay should reflect the level of expertise and difficulty of the
task and importance of the purpose. Existing incentive structures
should be re-examined.

This includes weapons training, mental health advocacy, and gaining literacy as a community on how we can better serve the diverse communities in Bethlehem.

Prof Holona Ochs

Gadfly takes advantage of a short post here to remind you what he’s been doing. He’s taking some action items provided by Prof Ochs and spinning them out one-by-one to encourage focus. There are a few more items on that list, and Prof Ochs has just provided Gadfly with some more info. So we’ll continue to flood you with information and things to think about before the Public Safety Committee meeting tomorrow night at 6PM.

Have you registered for tomorrow’s meeting yet?

“Recruitment and retention standards need to be evaluated and revised to prevent the infiltration of those with extremist/hateful/violent views”

logoLatest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Recruitment and retention standards need to be evaluated
and revised to prevent the infiltration of those with
extremist/hateful/violent views.

The culture of policing is often cast as “us against them” rather than dealing with the various communities as civic minded peace officers. This is also evident in the LV (LU Core Team). Officers in our study regularly describe their approach in adversarial terms rather than seeing themselves as a part of the communities they serve. This is not universally true. Many officers enjoy engaging with the public and are quite good at it. They should be rewarded and encouraged.

Council should demand a registry of officers fired for misconduct to prevent those who are not well-suited for policing from being re-hired by other departments.

Collective bargaining agreements often protect problematic officers. This should not be the case. Collective bargaining agreements should protect officers without endangering the public.

Prof Holona Ochs

Gadfly found the following article quite . . . illuminating.

What do we know about our police collective bargaining agreement and our disciplinary and misconduct procedures?

From Stephen Rushin, “Police Union Contracts.” Duke Law Journal, March 2017.

Police departments’ internal disciplinary procedures, often established through the
collective bargaining process, can serve as barriers to officer accountability.

Most states permit police officers to bargain collectively over the terms of their employment, including the content of internal disciplinary procedures. This means that police union contracts—largely negotiated outside of public view—shape the
content of disciplinary procedures used by American police departments.

A substantial number of these agreements limit officer interrogations after alleged misconduct, mandate the destruction of disciplinary records, ban civilian oversight, prevent anonymous civilian complaints, indemnify officers in the event of civil suits, and limit the length of internal investigations.

This lack of corrective action in cases of systemic officer misconduct is, in part, a consequence of public-employee labor law.

Chicago’s Independent Police Review Authority does not consider an officer’s history of complaints when examining a new complaint against the same officer. The Chicago union contract also delays interrogations of officers involved in alleged wrongdoing and prevents the investigation of most anonymous complaints. Perhaps it is no coincidence that less than 2 percent of all civilian complaints against Chicago police officers result in any sort of disciplinary action. Chicago is hardly alone.

The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) found it challenging to investigate the Cleveland Police Department in part because its collective bargaining contract mandated the removal of disciplinary records from department databases after two years.

These examples bolster the hypothesis that some union contract provisions may impede effective investigations of police misconduct and shield problematic officers from discipline.

This analysis reveals that a substantial number of these contracts unreasonably interfere with or otherwise limit the effectiveness of mechanisms designed to hold police officers accountable for their actions. For example, many of these contracts limit officer interrogations after alleged wrongdoing, mandate the destruction of officer disciplinary records, ban civilian oversight of police misconduct, prevent anonymous civilian complaints, indemnify officers in civil suits, or require arbitration in cases of disciplinary action.

But across many of the nation’s largest cities, supervisors cannot easily respond to external legal pressure by punishing problematic officers or implementing rigorous disciplinary procedures. Instead, many courts have held that internal-investigation and disciplinary procedures are appropriate subjects for collective bargaining under public-employee labor laws. This collective bargaining process happens largely outside of the public view and with minimal input from community stakeholders most at risk of experiencing police misconduct.

Municipalities ought to provide police officers with adequate due process protections  during internal investigations. It is also important for front line police officers to have a voice in the development of internal policies and procedures to reduce the probability of organizational resistance. However, these internal disciplinary protections should not be so burdensome as to thwart legitimate efforts to investigate or punish officers engaged in wrongdoing.

States could require municipalities and police unions to negotiate disciplinary procedures in public hearings rather than behind closed doors. Alternatively, states could require municipalities to establish notice-and-comment procedures, similar to those employed by administrative agencies, before agreeing to a package of disciplinary procedures via the collective bargaining process. Perhaps most radically, states could amend labor laws to remove police disciplinary procedures from the list of appropriate subjects for collective bargaining.

However, it appears that expansive readings of state labor laws by employee-relations boards and courts have opened the door for police unions to negotiate the inclusion of a range of questionable procedures that may “protect incompetent or abusive employees.” Excessively delaying interrogations of officers after alleged misconduct allows officers to coordinate stories in a way that deflects responsibility for wrongful behavior. The destruction of disciplinary records makes it more difficult for supervisors to identify officers engaged in a pattern of misconduct. The disqualification of entire classes of civilian complaints prevents supervisors from even investigating potentially abusive behavior. Limitations on civilian oversight and arbitration clauses rob the public of the opportunity to monitor police behavior.

In the past, participants in this conversation have not fully recognized the ways that police labor and employment law may contribute to questionable internal disciplinary measures. Even when faced with the sting of evidentiary exclusion or the heavy financial burden of civil suits, police union contracts can make it challenging for police chiefs to hold officers accountable for wrongdoing.

Police officers need reasonable procedural safeguards during disciplinary investigations. At the same time, these procedural protections should not go so far as to shield offending officers from accountability. Unfortunately, in many of the nation’s largest cities, it appears that the balance may have tipped too heavily in favor of protecting police officers while handcuffing internal investigations. In many localities across the country, police officers receive more procedural protections than other government employees during disciplinary investigations.

Communities could elect civilians to a commission tasked with the creation of police disciplinary procedures, with recommendations from police management and union leaders. Communities could establish notice-and-comment procedures, similar to those employed by many administrative agencies, to promulgate disciplinary policies. Conversely, states could require communities to establish police disciplinary procedures in the same manner that they establish municipal ordinances—presumably through a public hearing and vote by local elected officials.

Scholars have documented that police unions are a powerful political constituency. Police union support can be pivotal in local and state elections.280 Thus, there is legitimate concern that the collective bargaining process in police departments
“amount[s] to a division of spoils” rather than a thoughtful compromise. By opening up the negotiation process to the public, relevant stakeholders should, theoretically, be able to monitor the actions of municipal officials during the negotiation of police union contracts and prevent the kind of troubling disciplinary trade-offs that have happened in major cities like Chicago.

Some misconduct is an unavoidable part of having a police force.

There is a compelling public policy need for the public to have greater input in
the development of police disciplinary procedures.

Across America’s largest cities, many police officers receive excessive procedural protections during internal disciplinary investigations, effectively immunizing them from the consequences of misconduct.

The public should have more say in the development of police accountability mechanisms. For too long, the law has excluded the public from the development of these procedures. It is time to remove this process from the shadows and make the police more accountable to the communities they serve.

“Freedom from hatred . . . let’s cast our fears aside”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

“The council and community bear some responsibility as well”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

The council and community bear some responsibility as well. Quality
of life measures and similar policies that target low income
communities of color are fundamentally racist. The city should
re-evaluate policies that target others in our
community and make them vulnerable.

Prof Holona Ochs

Gadfly, thank you for your ongoing discussion of this topic.

I would like to make a comment on the 5th item on Professor Ochs’ helpful list of recommendations. This item refers to “qualify of life” policing, which is described in the attached info-graphic Quality of life policing as the “policing of a number of normally non-criminal activities such as standing, congregating, sleeping, eating and/or drinking in public spaces, as well as minor offenses such as graffiti, public urination, panhandling, littering, and unlicensed street vending.”

Since I know there are a number of people in our city who believe the Bethlehem police can do no wrong and who see no need for any efforts to reconsider how we address public safety, I thought it would be good to recall Mayor Donchez’s effort in 2016 to institute one such quality of life measure: a panhandling ordinance. Here is the link to some local press coverage on this effort: “Bethlehem City Council reviews anti panhandling ordinance.”

While the proposed ordinance was ultimately withdrawn from consideration, the fact that it was proposed reflects a general failure in city government to consider the disproportionate and draconian impact local policies have on poor and vulnerable citizens in our own community, and a tendency to approach those citizens as though they are a problem that needs to be removed from public sight, and even penalized for making others uncomfortable. You will see in the press coverage that, not surprisingly, the public discussion about the problem with this ordinance focused more on how it would impact local artists, who are deemed acceptable, and good for tourism, even when prompting loitering in public spaces around the wonderful music they play.

As a citizen witnessing this conversation, I was appalled by statements of support for the ordinance from the city and the police chief and the South Side Ambassadors that reflected their general interest in sanitizing the South Side of people who might make parents and tourists feel uncomfortable. Had some wiser voices from outside our city’s government not prevailed in this conversation, the ordinance would likely be in place now.

Efforts to pass such an ordinance demonstrate the propensity of our local government and police department — and presumably many citizens — to criminalize and penalize the behavior of vulnerable populations in order to create public spaces that make other populations feel more comfortable. They also reveal why we need to have a conversation about public safety in this city. Specifically, there is a need to understand why people become homeless, what is empirically effective in helping them and others so easily targeted as “criminals,” and why jailing and penalizing people who pose minimal threats to public safety is neither making us safer nor spending our tax dollars effectively. There are many other problems with quality of life policing, but if we could start with understanding these rather obvious problems, that would be progress.

The problems driving the recent social uprising are deep and systemic. I think there are a lot of citizens in this city who don’t really understand them at all. Thus it is no surprise why some think there is no need for reform. It would be very helpful if the city government could find ways to get us all on the same page and foster an understanding of the empirical evidence and personal anecdotes driving calls for systemic reform. This probably involves having some public forums, but I hope government officials realize it involves a lot more than that.

Sincerely, Breena Holland

See also: “Debtors’ Prisons: Life Inside America’s For-Profit Justice System.”

“Transparency and accountability must be structured into the system”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Transparency and accountability must be structured into the system.

Council has the power and should demand that all data that is not legally
protected personnel data should be publicly available. This should include
researchers who are experts in analyzing and interpreting the data so that
we can actually learn from the data available.

Prof Holona Ochs

For the August 11 Public Safety Committee meeting, we have the following documents online here:

1. Police Department Use of Force Directives (3.1.1)
2. Policing in the City of Bethlehem, 2019
3. A Report on the Use of Force by the Bethlehem Police

Plenty to go through.

These documents, as far as Gadfly knows, are not usually available to the public.

One would think they should be and be the subject of a Public Safety Committee meeting.

Gadfly likes the Prof’s idea of having someone expert in data analysis present when discussions occur.

Followers know that Gadfly has been thinking of other statistical info and reports that Council should have at review times:

  • the police section of the City budget
  • copies of the last two police accreditation reports
  • minority personnel statistics,
  • conduct/misconduct reports and statistics in as granular detail as possible

Gadfly recently noted that the Minnesota state legislature is considering a provision to provide incentives for police officers to live in the city.

What an interesting idea. Gadfly has heard that at one time there was such a requirement for police and perhaps for other city workers as well.

Would put the “community” in community policing.

So Gadfly would be curious to know how many of the 154 (?) police officers live in Bethlehem.

“Police should avoid situations that increase the likelihood of lethal force and should work alongside mental health professionals in de-escalating conflict.”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

 

Police should avoid situations that increase the likelihood of lethal force and should work alongside mental health professionals in de-escalating conflict.
Prof Holona Ochs

from Curtis Gilbert, “Not Trained to Not Kill: Most states neglect ordering police to learn de-escalation tactics to avoid shootings.” APM Reports, May 5, 2017.

“Did you see him comin’ at me?”
“I seen him comin’ at you.”
min. 3:02
“What he’d do to ya?”
I taz’d him. He just stood there. Busted everything loose,
and he come at me swingin’.”
min. 6:01
“He hit me a couple times, I’m alright, he hit me
a couple times here and here . . . come at me swingin’.
min. 11:28
“I just don’t want her hearing this on the news or anything.”
min. 13:22
“I holstered my pistol, and I got my taser out . . .
and I kept telling him . . . I’m going to taze you . . .
and I drew and I shot him . . . I’m fine.”
min. 14:07
“I’m not second-guessing myself.”
min. 20:25
“You know the bad thing about it, Brent? I could’ve fought him.”
 “Don’t second guess yourself. You did what Mickey had to do.”
not captured on this video
(full story at beginning of article)

selections:

Whether White did what he had to do remains a question. What’s certain is that he did what he was trained to do.

During White’s 13 years working for the Early County Sheriff’s Department, according to records kept by the state of Georgia, he’d received more than 600 hours of training on a range of subjects, including use of firearms, “vehicle pullovers,” “active shooter response,” “marijuana investigations,” and even “courtroom demeanor and testimony.”

In fact, on the day White shot Touchtone, he had completed a five-hour training session that included an annual briefing on the use of deadly force.

Yet he’d never received even an hour of instruction in the type of training that might have equipped him to better handle his encounter with Touchtone, who had a history of mental illness.

There are no unassailable, scientific studies showing that de-escalation training leads to fewer police shootings. But anecdotal evidence abounds.

Those who haven’t implemented the training are sending a message that curbing use of force isn’t a high priority, said Frank Zimring, a law professor at University of California-Berkeley who studies police shootings. “De-escalation is going to work only when saving civilian lives becomes an important objective of police administration and training,” he said.

“We never blame individual police officers for actions that they take, because when we look at the training that they receive, they’re simply doing what their training told them,” he said.

Officers need to “practice patience,” he said, adding that it appears White tried to resolve the situation too quickly, especially given that Touchtone was unarmed. “Things don’t have to be resolved within the first 30 seconds …. Let him sing all day. Let him stand outside his car and sing until backup comes.”

It’s not the first time White shot an unarmed man. In 2009, he tried to arrest a man after responding to a family dispute. The man resisted and began fighting White, who shot him, but not fatally.

Police shootings tend to unfold quickly. The shots that killed Touchtone were fired just 35 seconds after White’s arrival. De-escalation training is designed to help officers slow the action down, in order to afford them more than a few seconds in which to make a decision.

Evidence suggests that officers who go through de-escalation training come away with more sympathetic attitudes toward people with mental illness.

De-escalation training is controversial in the policing world.

The Fraternal Order of Police, which calls itself the world’s largest organization of sworn law enforcement, and the International Association of Chiefs of Police issued a joint statement in early 2016 that read, “We cannot reasonably expect law enforcement officers to walk away from potentially dangerous situations and individuals in the hope that those situations resolve themselves without further harm being done. Reasonable use of force in any given situation must be at the discretion of a fully sworn and trained officer.”

Some view mandated de-escalation training as a criticism of policing itself.

“Nothing is significantly broken in law enforcement right now,” he said. “We are better trained, better selected, better educated, held to more standards, higher accountability, with better policies than ever before in the United States of America’s history. Yet we’re in the toilet right now.”

In reality, an officer is unlikely to shoot anyone ever. But, there is plenty of anecdotal evidence showing that de-escalation training can save lives under the right circumstances.

“Intuitively, we know it will work,” said Wexler of the Police Executive Research Forum. “But I think for the short term, we’re going to have to be comfortable with anecdotal information.”

A handful of police departments have taken de-escalation to a new level and are honoring dangerous situations handled without bloodshed.

Today, in addition to medals for valor, heroism, bravery, and honor, Philadelphia gives out an official commendation for de-escalation.

Murphy recalled that the man “actually was thanking us for not shooting him. During the car ride back to our district, he was thanking us. He knew his actions were wrong.”

McAdams remembered saying in response, “Well, thank you for not making us shoot you.”

 

“The entire community should have the opportunity to address our own racial biases”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

“Not enough White Americans understand that racism is much more destructive
when it infects an institution like the criminal justice system.”
Michael Reed

The entire community should have the opportunity to address our
own racial biases (this includes the police).
Prof Holona Ochs

from John Blake, “ ‘Am I racist?’ You may not like the answer.” CNN, June 20, 2020.

[Racism is] a system of advantage based on race, scholars say. It’s a collection of stereotypes, prejudices and discriminatory behavior. It’s overt and covert. And it operates across an individual, group and societal level.

It’s almost impossible not to be a racist growing up in the US. If you think you’re immune from it, that denial itself is part of how racism perpetuates. . . . “You start off with the assumption that you are, because everybody living in the United States has internalized stereotypes about Black people,” says Mark Naison.

“One of the things I learned very early in my development is that everyone in American society internalized anti-Black attitudes because they are so ingrained in our culture,” he says.

 People can act and think in racist ways without knowing it.

“The term racial bias perpetuates the notion that racism is beyond your control, and that’s often not the case,” says Bell, the psychology professor. “People might not think that they have control over racism, and they can’t ever get rid of it. It’s absolutely within their control.”

It can be fiendishly difficult, though, for people to see racism in themselves, says Bell, who studies how people fail to recognize their own racism.

Some of that is because of what psychologists call “moral licensing and credentialing.” Translation: A White liberal who brags, “I would have voted for Obama a third time if I could,” may be trying to signal that he or she is beyond racism.

Individual racism isn’t as harmful as institutional racism.

People have different ideas about how to get rid of racism. Some say the focus should be on institutional racism — in schools, policing, the workplace — and not on people’s feelings.

Reed says too many White Americans see “racism as psychology” — a naval-gazing definition that focuses on what people feel inside and personal displays of racial hostility, like racial slurs.

Reed says the goal of the civil rights movement was not to make White people better. It was to purge institutions of racism so that Blacks could have equal access to jobs, housing and education.

Not enough White Americans understand that racism is much more destructive when it infects an institution like the criminal justice system, he says.

Black people who come in contact with you will probably know you’re a racist before you do. Blacks can often read White people’s body language when they’re experiencing these racist thoughts, he says. It could be something as simple as speeding up your walk when a Black man approaches on the street or hesitating to open your door when a Black man is ringing the bell. Naison says a majority of Whites practice what he calls “aversive racism,” or engaging in behavior — some of it unconscious — “which lets Black people know they are uncomfortable around them.”

One of the biggest obstacles to fighting racism is despair. There’s a belief that racism will never be eliminated because it always adapts to survive, and humans are too tribal to look past superficial differences in others.

But the modern framework of racism — a racial hierarchy with White on top and Black on bottom — is a relatively recent fabrication. The notion that people with darker skin are inherently inferior was contrived around 500 years ago by Europeans to justify slavery and colonial conquest, scholars say.

History lessons won’t prevent someone from being a racist. But something else can: genuine, sustained personal relationships with people of color.

Instead of “Am I racist?” ask yourself: What am I doing to stop the racism I see in the world?

“Police must acknowledge and apologize for the historical patterns of abuse”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Police organizations are highly resistant to public “interference”
(Human Rights Watch, 1998)

Police must acknowledge and apologize for the historical patterns of abuse that have roots in the origins of the profession and continue to impact the patterns and practices of the police.
Prof Holona Ochs

The Ochs’ to-do list starts with a bang for your Gadfly.

Something Gadfly never thought about, never knew.

The history of police departments.

Police departments owe their origin to 1) slave patrols and 2) 19th century big city municipal police forces formed to control the “dangerous underclasses” (African American, yes, but Italians and Irish too).

Police departments were born in racism.

Gadfly tried to imagine Chief Diluzio acknowledging and apologizing for the history of police abuse.

Stop icon

But maybe, just maybe that was unfair on Gadfly’s part. For every time the Chief has spoken he has acknowledged the police are human, have bias like everybody else, make mistakes.

What does such acknowledgment and apology look like?

Maybe here’s an example. Wellesley, Massachusetts, Chief Terence Cunningham, President of the International Association of Chiefs of Police, in 2016.

from Tom Jackman, “U.S. police chiefs group apologizes for ‘historical mistreatment’
of minorities.” Washington Post, October 17, 2016.

Cunningham’s comments are an acknowledgement of police departments’ past role in exacerbating tensions and a way to move forward and improve community relations nationwide.

“Events over the past several years,” Cunningham said, “have caused many to question the actions of our officers and has tragically undermined the trust that the public must and should have in their police departments…The history of the law enforcement profession is replete with examples of bravery, self-sacrifice, and service to the community. At its core, policing is a noble profession.”

But Cunningham added, “At the same time, it is also clear that the history of policing has also had darker periods.” He cited laws enacted by state and federal governments which “have required police officers to perform many unpalatable tasks…While this is no longer the case, this dark side of our shared history has created a multigenerational — almost inherited — mistrust between many communities of color and their law enforcement agencies.”

Cunningham continued, “While we obviously cannot change the past, it is clear that we must change the future…For our part, the first step is for law enforcement and the IACP to acknowledge and apologize for the actions of the past and the role that our profession has played in society’s historical mistreatment of communities of color.”

He concluded, “It is my hope that, by working together, we can break this historic cycle of mistrust and build a better and safer future for us all.”

Robinson said, “and a very significant acknowledgement of what much of America has known for some time about the historical relationship between police and communities of color. The fact someone high in the law enforcement community has said this is significant and I applaud it because it is long overdue. And I think it’s a necessary first step to them trying to change these relationships.”

After his comments, Cunningham told The Post in an e-mail that, “We have 16,000 police chiefs and law enforcement officials gathered here in San Diego and it is an important message to spread. Communities and law enforcement need to begin a healing process and this is a bridge to begin that dialogue. If we are brave enough to collectively deliver this message, we will build a better and safer future for our communities and our law enforcement officers. Too many lives have been lost already, and this must end. It is my hope that many other law enforcement executives will deliver this same message to their local communities, particularly those segments of their communities that lack trust and feel disenfranchised.”

Civil rights activist Al Sharpton welcomed the apology by Cunningham, but also said he “wants his words backed by action.” Sharpton said in a statement he hoped that Cunningham would “urge officers around the United States to back his words up with action and legislation to protect communities of color from the onslaught of police misconduct that has disturbed the country…words are important but action is integral.”

Here’s a sober bottom line: “The persistence of racially biased policing means that unless American policing reckons with its racist roots, it is likely to keep repeating mistakes of the past. This will hinder police from fully protecting and serving the entire public.

You must know your history.

Your thoughts?

A “to-do” list from Prof Ochs

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

We have introduced you to Lehigh University professor Holona Ochs, whose team has done a study of Lehigh Valley Police Departments (124 interviews) entitled “Democratic Policing: Bias Reduction and Police-Public Interactions.” (See Ochs, Holona under Topics on the right-hand side-bar.)

Completion and publication of the report on the study were delayed when school activities were interrupted by the pandemic, but we hope to have the report later in the fall.

The Reynolds/Crampsie Smith resolution that is the basis for the August 11 Public Safety Committee meeting was amended at the July 7 City Council meeting specifically to include this research on local policing: ““The Administration should work with and incorporate recommendations by research experts including Lehigh University’s Core Grant team who recently conducted a large research project on policing in the Lehigh Valley.”

Happy serendipity! Gadfly’s mouth waters at the thought of this report. How fortunate to have this window on local policing at the precise time the whole country is examining the way it does Public Safety.

In preparation for that July 7 meeting at which the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith resolution passed, Ochs circulated the following list of action items.

Gadfly has been doing a crash course with you in preparation for the August 11 meeting. We’ll get more out of that meeting if we’ve done some thinking beforehand.

Therefore, take a look now at the Ochs’ list, and then we’ll take each point one at a time to see what we can see, to think what we can think.

  • Police must acknowledge and apologize for the historical patterns of abuse that have roots in the origins of the profession and continue to impact the patterns and practices of the police.
  • The entire community should have the opportunity to address our own racial biases (this includes the police).
  • Police should avoid situations that increase the likelihood of lethal force and should work alongside mental health professionals in de-escalating conflict.
  • Transparency and accountability must be structured into the system.
  • The council and community bear some responsibility as well. Quality of life measures and similar policies that target low income communities of color are fundamentally racist. The city should re-evaluate policies that target others in our community and make them vulnerable.
  • Officer pay should reflect the level of expertise and difficulty of the task and importance of the purpose. Existing incentive structures should be re-examined.
  • Recruitment and retention standards need to be evaluated and revised to prevent the infiltration of those with extremist/hateful/violent views.
  • Scholars have noted that the doctrine of qualified immunity is not supported by the empirical evidence.
  • We, as a community, need to imagine leadership differently.

“Freedom from ignorance . . . as we learn to change our fate”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

Olympia has “crisis responders” and a “Familiar Faces” program

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Denver has a STAR program like CAHOOTS, so here Olympia, a town smaller than Bethlehem.

Gadfly is at the end of his leads for cities to look at for reforms of Pubic Safety. Other references much appreciated.

Are you getting any ideas that we might use? The “Familiar Faces”?

And maybe a better notion of what “defunding the police” means?

One would hope somebody is putting together a portfolio of such models for the Police, Council, and a Community Engagement Initiative to explore for possible ideas applicable to Bethlehem.

from Christie Thompson, “This City Stopped Sending Police to Every 911 Call.” The Marshall Project, July 24, 2020.

But over a year ago, Olympia started taking a different approach to nonviolent incidents caused by someone experiencing mental illness, addiction, or homelessness. Instead of sending armed officers to respond, the city dispatches “crisis responders” to diffuse the situation and connect the individual with services—a model now being considered by a growing number of cities across the U.S.

That day, instead of a police officer, the woman had two “crisis responders” knocking on her door, carrying only a radio and a backpack of clean clothes.

Police respond to a wide range of problems, many of them relatively minor or involving someone having a psychotic episode or sleeping on the streets. Using civilian first responders instead, advocates of this approach say, keeps interactions from escalating into violence, and diverts people from jail and toward social services. It also frees up police resources to focus on more serious crime.

Those encounters can also be deadly: An analysis by the Washington Post found roughly 1 in 4 fatal police shootings involved someone with mental illness. Recent shootings have left many asking what would have happened had police never been involved. Would Rayshard Brooks—shot by the Atlanta police officer who found him sleeping in his car—still be alive if an unarmed social worker had instead knocked on his window and asked if he had somewhere safe to sleep?

Handling violent crime accounts for as little as 4 percent of an officer’s time at work. And delegating other crises—such as mental health or addiction issues—to non-law enforcement is an idea gaining traction. A recent survey found 68 percent of voters supported the creation of a “new agency of first responders.” (However, just a quarter of Americans say they support “reducing funding” for police departments.)

The idea took off in Olympia thanks to a former police chief who had worked in Eugene [where the CAHOOTS program is]. The crisis team’s roughly $550,000 budget is funded through a public safety levy, which was passed by voters in 2017. Now, the Crisis Response Unit is contracted by the police department, on call daily from 7 a.m. to 9 p.m. From April through June of this year, the team made over 500 contacts with community members.

Here’s no strict protocol for when the unit gets called instead of police. Only a fraction of the calls it receives come directly from 911 operators. Instead, the team is often contacted by social service providers, or is sent by police who recognize a situation is better suited for the team’s skills. Most often, they provide services while doing outreach with those sleeping in homeless encampments or downtown Olympia, or following up from previous calls.

In a small city like Olympia, with roughly 52,000 residents, team members say they know half the people they come into contact with—a helpful familiarity that will be harder for bigger cities to establish. Most of their job is problem-solving for people with few good options: the elderly woman with dementia who keeps trying to hitch-hike away from her shelter; the woman with mental illness convinced a motel manager has stolen her luggage; the kid who keeps getting kicked out of treatment; the older man who won’t stop calling 911.

One of the biggest challenges, team members say, is a lack of long-term services in the Olympia area, especially for mental health care. They often get called to assist the same people over and over again. Olympia runs a “familiar faces” program to help fill this gap, which pairs peer navigators with people who have frequent run-ins with law enforcement, to connect them with housing, addiction treatment and other resources. That program served 26 people last year; they recently received funding to serve up to 100 clients

Because they work closely with the Olympia Police Department and are dispatched through 911, Larsen said the program had to build community trust to prove they were “collaborative but separate” from law enforcement. “One of the biggest things we had to overcome is the idea that we would be snitches,” she said. “It’s about reassuring folks that we don’t run [their names] for warrants or anything like that.” Larsen noted that working with police makes it easier to access some services, like getting people identification.

Allowing crisis responders to take the lead will take time. In the past year, the Olympia team says police officers are already deferring more calls to them and trusting them in a wider range of circumstances. But police still respond to most suicide calls, for example, out of fear that there might be a weapon.

“I think they’re hesitant to let us just show up,” said Aana Sundling, a crisis team member, walking into the encampment, where most of the residents seem to know her. “They’re worried about our safety. But the cops are becoming more aware. We’ve been out here for over a year and none of us have been assaulted.”

A county-level Use of Deadly Force Investigative Task Force

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

We saw in the last post that St. Petersburg plans to add a civilian to a police review board, but here investigations of city incidents will stay, in a sense, “in house” but handled at the county level.

from Kavitha Surana and Rose Wong, “‘It’s time to change:’ Police in Pinellas to partner on use-of-force investigations.” Tampa Bay Times, July 21, 2020.

For as long as anyone in Pinellas County can remember, lethal interactions between law enforcement officers and the public were dealt with in the same way: The agency conducted a criminal investigation of their own employee’s actions. “It’s time to change,” said Pinellas Sheriff Bob Gualtieri in an interview with the Tampa Bay Times.

In an effort to root out a perceived conflict of interest, major Pinellas law enforcement agencies will no longer investigate their own officers after use-of-force incidents. Instead, they will hand those cases over to partner departments, Gualtieri announced Tuesday.

The new Pinellas County Use of Deadly Force Investigative Task Force will include three homicide detectives each from the Pinellas County Sheriff’s Office, the St. Petersburg Police Department and the Clearwater Police Department.

Previously, agencies were investigating their own officers.

“An outside agency should take over the investigation, both for the integrity of the process and for community trust that the ultimate decision reached is just and without bias,” Hillsborough County Sheriff Chad Chronister said.

“In the current situation we are in, it’s important we have public confidence,” he said. “No matter how well we have done it or how right we’ve done it, that may not sit right with people moving forward — knowing the agency conducting the investigation of an officer is the employer of that officer.”

“It’s not just important that these investigations be done fairly and objectively and thoroughly — but they have to be perceived by the public and known by the public to be conducted in that manner,” Gualtieri said.

Some expressed skepticism of the new arrangement and called for a non-law enforcement body to review deadly use-of-force incidents.

“That’s not truly independent — it’s police investigating other police,” said Haydee Oropesa, a defense attorney who runs the commentary site FloridaYouJudge.com. “That’s not going to placate the public.”

Community Assistance Liaison program in St. Petersburg

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Gadfly continues his attempt to look at some Public Safety “reform” measures as we approach our Public Safety Committee meeting with our Police Department August 11.

Have you signed up to participate yet?

St. Petersburg turned down a multi-million dollar grant to hire 25 police officers and instead hired social workers, creating a new social services division between the City and the Police department.

Floyd 27

Beau Zimmer and Madison Alworth, “Change is coming to the St. Petersburg Police Department.” Tampa Bay10, July 9, 2020. video

Skyla Luckey, “St. Pete Police Add Community Program To Handle Non-Violent Calls.” Patch, July 13, 2020.

Margie Manning, “St. Pete police chief defends Community Liaison program, says department hopes to keep federal grant.” Catalyst. July 24, 2020.

Clips from the news articles:

“The city announced it would divert funds away from hiring new officers and instead bring on unarmed social workers to handle non-violent calls.”

“Among the biggest announcements, reallocating over $3 million set aside for hiring 25 new police officers and instead using that money to create a new team of non-armed social workers that will deploy across the city to handle many of  St. Pete’s non-violent calls involving homelessness, mental illness, and truancy. “They will be in plain clothes, maybe a polo shirt and jeans or something like that,” said Holloway.  “They are a social worker to go out there and handle that call.”

“The chief  . . . added it would also reduce pressure on patrol officers who respond to between 12,000 and 14,000 non-violent calls a year. “They’ll be under Chief Gilliam, but they will not have a radio, they won’t have guns,” said Holloway. The Chief says an outside firm that specializes in mental health will be hired to run the unit under the police department’s lead.  The unit will be nick named “CAL” for Community Assistance Liaison and will be made up of 18-20 members spread out across the city responding to calls between 6 a.m. and 2 a.m., 20 hours a day.”

Planned change includes:

  • Increase de-escalation training from the current one time a year, to two times a year formal training and informal training with simulator
  • Increase self-defense tactics training from the current one time a year to two times a year so that officers have more options than reaching for weapons
  • Fair & impartial policing training for civilian employees of the police department (sworn officers already receive this training annually.)
  • Additional training for recruits. Recruits already receive cultural competency training with community members. They will also have to return after a year for additional training on cultural competency.
  • Add a civilian to their hiring board. The civilian will come from NAACP, Urban League, Faith Leaders and Leadership St. Petersburg.
  • Park, Walk, and Talks (when officers park their patrol cars and walk the areas they patrol to get to know the people they serve) will go from 1 hour per week, to 2 hours per.
  • Comprehensive review to look for ways to improve: Use of Force policy, how complaints are processed, who they are arresting and why and monitor calls that are based on race only.
“Questions remain as this program moves from theory to practice. Holloway said that social workers would be responding to nonviolent calls, but what happens when a seemingly innocuous call turns violent? How will social workers call for back-up? Will the fact that they are unarmed serve as more of a weakness than a strength?”

“Freedom from poverty . . . We know it’s not too late”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

Students of color again tell it like it is

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

You might remember that we spent several posts 2-3 weeks ago on the first part of this series of student commentary organized by Ce-Ce Gerlach.

It was powerful, often heart-wrenching.

Here’s a second student gathering August 10, 6-7PM.

You can register at the Facebook link below.

Straight talk.

Floyd 24

https://www.facebook.com/events/s/our-voices-matter-2/3205471372839745/?ti=as

Minneapolis Announces Plan To Replace Police Officers With Thousands Of Heavily Armed Social Workers

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Protesters Call For Cancellations Of Rents And Mortgages In Minneapolis

“Minneapolis Announces Plan To Replace Police Officers
With Thousands Of Heavily Armed Social Workers.
The Onion, August 6, 2020.