CAHOOTS: symbiotic relationship with the police better serves some residents

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Racism is a public health issue.
CAHOOTS

Short CBS News video on how CAHOOTS works

“This Oregon town of 170,000 replaced some cops with medics and mental health workers. It’s worked for over 30 years.” CNN, July 5, 2020.

Around 30 years ago, a town in Oregon retrofitted an old van, staffed it with young medics and mental health counselors and sent them out to respond to the kinds of 911 calls that wouldn’t necessarily require police intervention.

In the town of 172,000, they were the first responders for mental health crises, homelessness, substance abuse, threats of suicide — the problems for which there are no easy fixes. The problems that, in the hands of police, have often turned violent.

Today, the program, called CAHOOTS, has three vans, more than double the number of staffers and the attention of a country in crisis.

CAHOOTS is already doing what police reform advocates say is necessary to fundamentally change the US criminal justice system — pass off some responsibilities to unarmed civilians.

Cahoots 1

CAHOOTS comes from White Bird Clinic, a social services center that’s operated in Eugene since the late 1960s. It was the brainchild of some counterculture activists who’d felt the hole where a community health center should be. And in 1989, after 20 years of earning the community’s trust, CAHOOTS was created

It works this way: 911 dispatchers filter calls they receive — if they’re violent or criminal, they’re sent to police. If they’re within CAHOOTS’ purview, the van-bound staff will take the call. They prep what equipment they’ll need, drive to the scene and go from there.

The program started small, with a van Zeiss called a “junker,” some passionate paraprofessionals and just enough funding to staff CAHOOTS 40 hours a week.

It always paired one medic, usually a nurse or EMT, with a crisis responder trained in behavioral health. That holistic approach is core to its model.

White Bird’s counterculture roots ran deep — the clinic used to fundraise at Grateful Dead concerts in the West, where volunteer medics would treat Deadheads — so the pairing between police and the clinic wasn’t an immediately fruitful one.

There was “mutual mistrust” between them, said Zeiss, who retired in 2014.

“It’s true there was a tendency to be mistrustful of the police in our agency and our culture,” he said. “It was an obstacle we had to overcome.”

And for the most part, both groups have: Eugene Police Chief Chris Skinner called theirs a “symbiotic relationship” that better serves some residents of Eugene.

“When they show up, they have better success than police officers do,” he said. “We’re wearing a uniform, a gun, a badge — it feels very demonstrative for someone in crisis.”

CAHOOTS was created in part because of another disturbing statistic — around 25% of people killed by police show signs of mental illness.

“I believe it’s time for law enforcement to quit being a catch-base for everything our community and society needs,” Skinner said. “We need to get law enforcement professionals back to doing the core mission of protecting communities and enforcing the law, and then match resources with other services like behavioral health — all those things we tend to lump on the plate of law enforcement.”

Staffers respond to substance addiction crises, psychotic episodes, homeless residents and threats of suicide. They make house calls to counsel depressed children at their parents’ request, and they’re contacted by public onlookers when someone isn’t in a position to call CAHOOTS themselves.

Unlike police, CAHOOTS responders can’t force anyone to accept their aid, and they can’t arrest anyone. They’re not armed, and their uniform usually consists of a White Bird T-shirt and jeans — the goal is that the more “civilian-like” they look, the less threatened their clients will feel.

Their approach is different, too. They’re taught in training to abandon the “pseudo-professional” affect that staffers inadvertently take on in talks with clients. And aside from an extensive background in medical care or mental health, all CAHOOTS employees are judged by their “lived experiences,” Brubaker said — people who’ve dealt with many of the situations CAHOOTS clients find themselves in are better able to empathize and serve those people, he said.

Cahoots 2

Building that rapport and trust with clients is part and parcel with their clinical work.

Advocates for limiting the role of police have pointed to Eugene as an example of social service providers and law enforcement working in harmony.

But a growing group of dissenters feel there’s little room for police in the movement to fundamentally change the American criminal justice system. Services like CAHOOTS, they say, may function better and more broadly without the assistance of police.

Zeiss isn’t sure he agrees. “Partnership with police has always been essential to our model,” he said. “A CAHOOTS-like program without a close relationship with police would be very different from anything we’ve done. I don’t have a coherent vision of a society that has no police force.”

Coulibaly said community leaders are in talks over what to do about police — should their funding go to CAHOOTS, or should more funding be directed toward better educating police about deescalation techniques? They haven’t reached a consensus, he said.

The idea of a separate entity in charge of alternative care is more enticing than ever as cities mull over the efficacy of their police departments.

Breaking news about the Minneapolis program that we wrote about yesterday. Stay tuned for the next post.

“CAHOOTS” program in Eugene, Oregon, sends medic and crisis worker on non-emergency calls

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Are you with the Gadfly?

As we approach our August 11 Public Safety Committee meeting with the Police Department, we are trying to wrap our arms around what “defund the police” means by looking at how some cities have revisioned public safety.

For 30 years a program called CAHOOTS (CRISIS ASSISTANCE HELPING OUT ON THE STREETS) has operated in Eugene, Oregon. CAHOOTS works through public safety dispatch, sending a 2-person team of a medic and a crisis worker on non-emergency calls. CAHOOTS responds to about 20% of calls to the Eugene Police Department and takes up little more than 1% of the budget. CAHOOTS estimated last fall its response saved $6 million in medical services costs alone.

Gadfly will cherry-pick some clips from the reading around he’s been doing on CAHOOTS and will probably spend another post on it to encourage you to take a deeper dive.

The value of CAHOOTS:

“Programs such as CAHOOTS . . . reduce the likelihood that citizens in distress will fall into deeper holes at the hands of persons not trained to deal with their problems, or bear the additional burden of having their distress criminalized.”

  • Mental health workers, rather than police, respond to non-criminal emergency 911 calls.
  • The CAHOOTS programme reduces confrontations involving police officers, saves money, and allows police to concentrate on law enforcement.
  • The programme could be an alternative model for policing in the wake of the Black Lives Matter protests and calls to defund the police.

The problem, addressing the problem:

“For many Americans experiencing a mental health crisis, the first professional they encounter will be a police officer. It isn’t an ideal combination. Often, someone acting irrationally, erratically or aggressively is confronted by an armed officer trained in the use of force if they feel the public – or themselves – are in danger.

Tragically, the results can be fatal. An analysis of police shootings reported by the Washington Post in 2015/16 suggests a quarter of those killed displayed signs of mental illness. In countless more cases, someone in need of medical or psychological care ends up in a cell, rather than getting the treatment they need. With mental illness affecting as many as a quarter of young Americans, the need for an alternative solution is clear.

The city of Eugene, Oregon, takes a different approach. For 30 years, the CAHOOTS (Crisis Assistance Helping Out On The Streets) programme has been sending teams of unarmed civilians to deal with 911 calls that elsewhere are dealt with by police.

Each team consists of a mental health crisis worker and an EMT (emergency medical technician, or paramedic). Between them, they have the skills and training to deal with mental health issues, homelessness, intoxication, substance abuse, disorientation and dispute resolution.”

Services provided:

CAHOOTS provides immediate stabilization in case of urgent medical need or psychological crisis, assessment, information, referral, advocacy & (in some cases) transportation to the next step in treatment. CAHOOTS offers a broad range of services, including but not limited to:

  • Crisis Counseling
  • Suicide Prevention, Assessment, and Intervention
  • Conflict Resolution and Mediation
  • Grief and loss
  • Substance Abuse
  • Housing Crisis
  • First Aid and Non-Emergency Medical Care
  • Resource Connection and Referrals
  • Transportation to Services

What CAHOOTS isn’t:

“CAHOOTS workers are not trained in law enforcement and do not have the same authority as police. We are a mobile crisis intervention team, designed as an alternative to police response for non-violent crises.”

“CAHOOTS is not, and never could be, a replacement for police altogether.”

“Partnership with police has always been essential to our model . . . A CAHOOTS-like program without a close relationship with police would be very different from anything we’ve done.”

“I don’t have a coherent vision of a society that has no police force.”

Gadfly wishes the people on the Next Door blog he reported on a week or so ago, people who had a knee-jerk negative response to “defund the police,” would consider a program like CAHOOTS. It’s widely referred to now as a model program. Let’s do another post on it, ok?

“Freedom from violence from those who intimidate . . . Everybody needs FREE-DOM”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

Police model: embedded community liaison and monthly meeting with a Multicultural Advisory Committee

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

The information gathering continues.

Gadfly is no expert. He knows of models in Eugene and St. Petersburg and will go there next. Let him know what you know about interesting programs so that he can share.

Here’s an embedded community liaison and a Multicultural Advisory Committee.

Multicultural–

You’ve seen Gadfly wonder about the Mayor jumping to participation with the NAACP Community Advisory Board (working details still not thoroughly explained to the public) when 30% of the City is Latinx. Odd?

from Mara Klecker and Kim Hyatt, “Brooklyn Park and Brooklyn Center now stand as police reform model.” Star Tribune, August 3, 2020.

As Twin Cities suburbs look for ways to foster trust between law enforcement officers and communities of color in the wake of George Floyd’s death, some are looking to a long-standing model that began years ago in the north metro.

Formed with new immigrants in mind, the Joint Community Police Partnership began in 2005 in Brooklyn Center and Brooklyn Park, two of the most diverse cities in the state. Since then the partnership has gained national recognition and grown into a collaboration with Bloomington, Crystal, Hopkins, Richfield and St. Louis Park, as well as Hennepin County.

The goal remains the same: develop communication and understanding between officers and diverse residents. Each police department has an embedded community liaison, and police officials meet monthly with a Multicultural Advisory Committee (MAC) made up of residents.

The committees of volunteers have advised police on body camera policies and helped them understand consulate ID cards carried by immigrants. They’ve helped inform hiring practices and crafted more inclusive interview questions. And they’ve organized community events to bring officers into diverse spaces.

The members have also advised on ways to educate immigrants about local law enforcement and helped resolve cultural misunderstandings as simple as staying in the vehicle when pulled over by an officer — something that many Liberian immigrants, for example, had thought was disrespectful.

“This work has to involve both sides,” said Elba Guille Garza, a Latina real estate agent who has served on Bloomington’s MAC for three years. “We need to know how the police department works and they need to understand how our community works.”

Many issues addressed by the partnership’s community liaisons fall somewhere between police work and social work, said Hennepin County Commissioner Mike Opat, who Drier credits for championing the partnership since its start.

“This has created different venues for interactions between the police and various communities that aren’t just always on the street,” Opat said.

Brooklyn Center Police Cmdr. Rick Gabler said those relationships and the work of the committees have become especially critical amid the calls for police reform.

Revering said the Crystal MAC is continuing to talk about police reform. The department is looking to make its use-of-force data more transparent to residents, as well as making the department’s policy manual easier to find on the city’s website.

Brooklyn Park Deputy Police Chief Mark Bruley said his city’s MAC group “really take[s] the temperature of the community” while allowing residents to see behind the curtain of police work.

Brooklyn Park’s MAC, in partnership with the city’s Human Rights Commission, has recently started looking at police reform recommendations. Proposals include the creation of a civilian oversight board and hiring nonwhite officers who live in the city.

“There’s always room for improvement,” Issahak said. “[The committee] is so important because if we don’t have this, then it would be like a black hole: no communication, no flow of information.”

Garza is one of two Latinos on the Bloomington MAC. While the MAC model is a good one, she said, it’s dependent on involvement and hinges on trust and awareness that builds over time.

“We are that community connection, the bridge of trust,” Garza said. “But improving that trust is difficult. I now see how the police do want to listen and learn, but they need that input.”

What’s happening in Minneapolis? A plan to disband the police in favor of a Department of Safety and Violence Prevention

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

As our August 11 Public Safety Committee meeting approaches, Gadfly’s going to look around at what’s going on in other cities. Join him.

Minneapolis, site of the George Floyd killing, is ground zero in the debate about police reform.

What’s happening in Minneapolis?

Floyd 25

Mpls. City Council To Take 1st Step In Ending MPD

The Minneapolis City Council is pursuing a city charter change to disband the Police Department as it is now constituted and establish a Department of Safety and Violence Prevention that will take “a holistic public-health-oriented approach” and, apparently, be largely controlled by Council. This new department has not been described in detail, but the director would have “non-law-enforcement experience in community safety services, including but not limited to public health and/or restorative justice approaches.”

The measure would:
  1. Eliminate charter provisions concerning the city’s police department.
  2. Establish the Department of Community Safety and Violence Prevention and the director of the new department.
  3. The director of the department would be nominated by the mayor and confirmed by the city council.
  4. Allow a Division of Law Enforcement Services within the new department;
  5. The division would be made up of licensed peace officers.
  6. Its director would be appointed by the director of the Department of Community Safety and Violence Prevention.
  7. Give the city council authority to establish the Division of Law Enforcement Services.

The Minneapolis Mayor is opposed to eliminating the Police Department and has instituted an interesting policy forcing officers to document their efforts at mitigation.

from “Minneapolis Mayor announces de-escalation standards, police use of force reporting requirements.” KSTP Eyewitness News, July 14, 2020.

The new policies places a stronger emphasis on de-escalation and expands the range of force reporting, which means police must describe in print what kind of mitigation they tried, plus a supervisor must be told. The policy also requires documentation of attempts to diffuse all possible situations.  Mayor Frey acknowledged these steps have never been must-haves before.

“This change will instill a stronger emphasis on de-escalation and help effectively curb excessive use of force by ensuring our officers center de-escalation in any-and-all interactions between officers and the community,” Frey said. “These comprehensive reporting requirements will help reinforce de-escalation as the first resort, increase accountability where de-escalation is an after-thought, and provide improved data to head off problematic interactions before they happen.”

“As the MPD continues to professionalize our service and make necessary reforms, these new changes in policy, strengthening de-escalation and Use Of Force reporting will play a key role in our efforts in building trust and legitimacy with all those we serve,” [Police Chief] Arradondo added.

The move to establish this new department is now stalled, as you can see from the following article. The article has an excellent video interview with the Mayor who points to problems with the police union in effecting the kind of “culture shift” in the department necessary for beneficent change. The Mayor calls the police union “the elephant in the room” in regard to reform. Please check out the video.

from “Commission stalls on amendment to dismantle Minneapolis Police Department, keeping it off the ballot in November.” CBS News, August 5, 2020.

A Minneapolis commission decided Wednesday to take more time to review a City Council amendment to dismantle the police department in the wake of George Floyd’s death, ending the possibility of voters deciding the issue in November.

The Charter Commission had expressed concern that the process to change the city’s charter was being rushed after Floyd died following an encounter with a Minneapolis police officer. Some commissioners said they were more concerned with making the right changes rather than making them fast.

The proposed amendment followed widespread criticism of law enforcement over Floyd’s death. It would have replaced the police department with a “Department of Community Safety and Violence Prevention” that backers said would take a more “holistic” approach. That approach wasn’t fully defined.

The proposal would have allowed for some armed police officers. It called for a division of licensed peace officers, who would have answered to the new department’s director.

“The council says ‘Trust us. We’ll figure it out after this is approved. Trust us.’ Well I don’t, and we shouldn’t,” said Barry Clegg, chairman of the Charter Commission. “Charter change is too important.”

Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey told The Associated Press on Tuesday that he remains opposed to eliminating the department.

“We should not go down the route of simply abolishing the police department,” Frey said. “What we need to see within this department, and within many departments throughout the country, is a full-on culture shift.”

The mayor and Chief Medaria Arradondo have moved ahead with their own changes since Floyd’s death, including requiring officers to document attempts to de-escalate situations whether or not force is used. They also have expanded requirements for reporting use-of-force incidents, ordering officers to provide more detail.

Arradondo also pulled the department out of negotiations for a union contract, saying he wanted a review designed to change the grievance and arbitration process, which he said makes it hard to get rid of problematic officers.

According to draft language of the amendment posted online, the new department proposed by the City Council “will have responsibility for public safety services prioritizing a holistic, public health-oriented approach.” The director of the new agency would have “non-law-enforcement experience in community safety services, including but not limited to public health and/or restorative justice approaches.”

“Where believers of many nations came to worship free . . . Let’s live out the best part of our legacy”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

No censure vote in Allentown

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

This withdrawal of the censure resolution against Gerlach and Siegel is a shame in a way. Would have been one helluva discussion.

But the citizen censure is still on the agenda? There may be still hope for drama.

from Andrew Wagaman, “Resolution withdrawn: Allentown City Council won’t vote Wednesday to censure Siegel, Gerlach.” Morning Call, August 4, 2020.

Allentown City Council has decided not to consider a resolution demanding a censure and no-confidence vote against council members Joshua Siegel and Ce-Ce Gerlach.

The resolution, which was to be introduced at Wednesday’s meeting, claimed Gerlach and Siegel betrayed the oath of office and “are unfit and not worthy to hold the position of councilperson” because of alleged actions taken and remarks made in the aftermath of an incident outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart in which a police officer used his knee to restrain Edward Borrero Jr.

Councilman Ed Zucal drafted the resolution against Siegel and Gerlach, and council President Daryl Hendicks and councilwoman Candida Affa initially supported it.

When City Clerk Mike Hanlon published Wednesday’s meeting agenda Monday afternoon, however, the resolution was not included. He confirmed that it was withdrawn.

On Tuesday, Hendricks said in a statement that it was removed “due to the press treating the resolution as a statement against Black Lives Matter and not as a statement relating to behavior.”

“We have no concerns with peaceful protests by Black Lives Matter or any other group,” Hendricks said. “We are concerned about certain behavior that creates the potential for litigation and increased costs for insurance.”

Their actions, the resolution alleged, placed the city in “a position of future litigation” and showed they can no longer be objective about the police department or trusted by citizens.

The resolution will most likely not be revisited, Hendricks said. Instead, council members will propose amendments to the city’s ethics code to “cover this kind of activity.”

Affa said Monday that while she still had concerns about her colleagues’ behavior, she no longer supported the censure resolution because she believes it’s poorly timed and distracting the legislative body from focusing on more important issues, such as a proposed $16 million bond issue intended to weather pandemic-related financial issues.

“I apologize for my role in the distraction,” she said.

Allentown citizens who are part of the Black Lives Matter movement countered Saturday with their own petition, calling on Hendricks, Zucal and Affa to resign over their alleged lack of support of Black and brown citizens, who make up the majority of Allentown’s population, and to apologize to them “for denying their democratic voice, safety, well-being.”

The petition was signed by about 100 people and appears on Wednesday’s agenda.

Peter reflects on Gadfly’s reflections

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Peter Crownfield is officially retired but spends most of his time working with students in his role as internship coordinator for the Alliance for Sustainable Communities–Lehigh Valley.

ref: Reflecting on the discussion at Allentown City Council July 29

Gadfly,

I agree with many of the points you make in this post, but in almost every case, something niggles at me. Here is a copy with replies inserted after each numbered paragraph.

1) We don’t want to see the breakdown that yesterday’s posts show within the Allentown City Council. Difference of opinion, yes, ok, but not a breakdown in civility or respect or cooperation. Please.

•  Sometimes it’s better if we know what people really think.

2) We have not had a recent police incident like the Allentown Sacred Heart incident to flare passions and to foster stand-taking. Gadfly wonders if our Bethlehem discussion of police policy and practice therefore will have only an “academic” feel to it. Where will deep motivation for change in Bethlehem — if, in fact, change is desired — come from? Can tragic cases elsewhere — nationally — do that? Can fear of tragic cases here do that? Or is there a history of troublesome incidents in Bethlehem of which the public is not generally aware?

•  We should be just as able to learn from the experience of others and incidents in other places & other times.  We don’t have to directly experience something to learn from it — if we did, that would prove that the entire education system, from pre-K to PhD is deeply flawed. (Of course, it may be flawed for unrelated reasons.)

3) Bethlehem proponents of specific changes in police policies and practices are liable to find, as Allentown did, that either what they want is already “on the books” or is controlled by state law or Human Resources/personnel policies or Union collective bargaining contracts. Quick change in specific policies and practices — maybe even any change — in many cases is not possible. Gadfly felt that such reality severely deflated the Allentown reform position as parts of the resolution were taken up by the Allentown Council and dismissed. It almost felt sometimes that not enough homework was done.

•  Telling citizens that something is already taken care of or can’t be changed is standard operating procedure whenever the status quo is challenged, and that’s just more proof of  how deeply embedded the problems are. Never accept such statements at face value.

4) We need someone to compare the “8 Can’t Wait” list with our police department regs. A match or not?

•  As I mentioned on another post, 8Can’tWait has some very solid points, but it also misses some things [tear gas & other ‘crowd control’ methods, for example]  Anyway, it seems to be morphing into 8toAbolition.

5) The Allentown Chief entertained the possibility of a citizen “advisory” group — interestingly, we may have just gotten one in the Community Advisory Board in which we participate with the NAACP. Its specific role still needs more explanation. Gadfly is not sure that reform voices from such groups as Black Lives Matter or Lehigh Valley Stands Up are on that Board, though. And, if not, how useful will that Board be? That Board has to hear challenging views.

•  Most citizen advisory groups have little power to actually do something about problems in enforcement, but they’re a great way to defuse an angry public. And the NAACP group should not be co-opted into focusing on only limited concerns with limited options for action.

6) For Big Picture discussion, “defunding the police” is an unfortunate phrase for the general public. Gadfly, of course, is not the first to say that.

• It’s much better than the phrase it has largely displaced [abolish the police], and even if it is incomplete, it certainly conveys the message about removing funds from policing to build more programs for prevention. (In general, such programs save far more than they cost.)

7) For Big Picture discussion, “systemic racism” is an unfortunately vague term for the general public. Gadfly, of course, is not the first to say that either.

•  It’s not at all ‘vague’; it’s just dealing with a large, many-faceted topic — clearly a Big Picture topic

8) But it’s easy to see the result of that lack of understanding in the incredulity about both terms by many voices on the Next Door blog, using that blog as a snapshot of mainstream resident thinking.

•  Yes, there’s a huge lack of understanding!

9) Proponents of change in Bethlehem such as the ones who personally attended our July 7 Council meeting and who probably will be present August 11 assume an understanding of “defunding the police” and “systemic racism” that the voices on the Next Door blog, for instance, pretty much totally lack — and the proponents of change sometimes unfortunately if understandably speak in terms of “demands.” Which feels rhetorically and strategically unwise to Gadfly.

•  The lack of understanding is a huge problem.  After hundreds of thousands of people took to the streets in cities across the country, though, perhaps the blissfully ignorant could take it upon themselves to learn what these terms really mean.

10) Proponents of change in Bethlehem who want (need) general public support have a big hill to climb, much groundwork to lay, a significant good-faith educational task to perform. Again, representative mainstream resident voices on the Next Door blog either didn’t understand what defunding the police means or immediately saw it as disastrous. They could not “picture” it.

11) It’s up to the proponents of change in Bethlehem to patiently help mainstream residents “picture” it.

•  About #10 and #11 — Again, after hundreds of thousands of people took to the streets in cities across the country, it seems inappropriate to suggest that it is on the victims to educate the people who keep the system the way it is.

12) 2/3’s or more of the Allentown population are People of Color. They don’t need the terms explained. Systemic racism is their felt reality. They were pounding on the outside walls of Council chambers while inside the Allentown Council deflated the resolution as if they and that practice didn’t exist. We don’t have the pressure from those numbers here. In Bethlehem, less than 10% of the population is Black (for historical reasons as Councilman Reynolds has interestingly explained) and the roughly 30% Latino population (as suggested by Councilwoman Negron last Council meeting) are quiet (silenced?) perhaps because they fear reprisal. The 60% white population has no felt reality to associate with the terms and thus needs to be educated.

•  Again, this seems to imply that we can’t learn from incidents in other places or other times to inform our own actions.

13) When it came to the major, overarching issue of defunding or divesting the police, Gadfly feels the Allentown proponents of change got completely steamrolled. They did not even try to respond (maybe they were consciously being quiet??? Gadfly is no strategist). They did not have an answer for basic objections to defunding/divestment and for commonsense questions about defunding/divestment. Gadfly himself could not have voted to further examine the possibility of defunding the police on the basis of anything they said. No case was made.

•  I suspect that the two members under attack did not see any point in trying to respond to the hostility displayed by Council President Hendricks and that crew.

14) Who will write the answer to the Allentown Chief who says his budget has been cut, but he is still operating underbudget, in a fiscally responsible way; who says his force is down 20% or whatever from a few years ago, yet they are out there 24/7 during a pandemic risking their lives for us; who says that to cut the force even more at this moment would negate recent hard-gotten gains in minority recruiting; who says that domestic violence calls are among the most dangerous of all and no place for a social worker; and who says that it would make no sense to sacrifice training to the budget knife. Who does the math and tells the Chief what we’re going to cut from his budget and then where we’re putting that money — and, most importantly, how public safety will be thereby improved? Nobody has yet shown that defunding is, indeed, reasonably possible. Needs to happen.

•  It would help people assess the possibilities if the police [in Allentown and Bethlehem] presented a clear picture of costs. One big factor is actual pay earned by police officers, including overtime, so that should be made clear. (In some cases, cities have spent so much on overtime that they could easily have hired additional personnel.)

15) Gadfly knows many of you follow Bernie O’Hare’s Lehigh Valley Ramblings blog, and Bernie had an “Allentown’s Real Heroes” post there yesterday morning that’s on point here. Nobody yet that Gadfly sees is writing the response to the kind of tack Bernie takes there. And that is what’s needed if the defunding reform gains any traction.

•  The blog post in question qualifies as a rant.  While Borrero was no upstanding citizen, that didn’t mean the policeman had to kneel on his neck, a method that I understand is specifically prohibited by APD policy. The officers present could have handled the situation better.

16) Gadfly perked up at this statement by the Allentown Chief. He said, if we are going to make changes, let’s do it right, let’s take time, let’s partner with somebody to do research, let’s find a model plan right for Allentown. Plans specifically at Eugene, Oregon, and St. Petersburg, Florida, were mentioned, but perhaps as inapplicable to Allentown. But if one is trying to gain support for defunding, for shaping new visions of public safety, why are some concrete examples of explorations and experiments elsewhere not brought forward to help break the death grip of the status quo. People on and off the Head Table need a “picture” . . . need a vision. Leadership creates visions. (The pending research report on local policing by Lehigh’s Prof Holona Ochs promises to be relevant here.)

•  I welcome the Chief’s statement.

17) Gadfly still doesn’t have a good answer to such questions he has been posing lately like do “we” have a beef with the department? Has trust between police and community broken down in Bethlehem or in some parts of Bethlehem? Is reform urgently needed here? It seems like the Minneapolis police department of the Floyd case has a history of trouble and controversy. That department needs to be fixed. Allentown may have that kind of history too. Are we in that position? Or are we thinking that this cultural moment of national conversation presents us with a valuable opportunity to rethink how we do the public safety business and explore other options?

•  There are still many unanswered questions about policing in Bethlehem and other cities and towns in the Lehigh Valley.  There are clear cases of racial bias and of excessive force. There are cases, here and elsewhere, where police officers do not follow the rules. (As in Minneapolis, where the man who killed George Floyd was not only violating department policy, he was violating the law when he murdered Floyd.)

Councilwoman Crampsie Smith: “I applaud all the sides”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Councilwoman Crampsie Smith, co-sponsor with Councilman Reynolds of the resolution that will be discussed at the August 11 Public Safety Committee meeting, spoke last night at City Council, explaining the term “defund the police,” her support for the police, and her anticipation of hearing ideas for the structure of the Community Engagement Initiative.

  • There’s confusion regarding this term “defund the police.”
  • The term “defund the police” does not mean by any means to eliminate the police or take all their funds away.
  • It just means possibly to reallocate resources especially so that we have more resources in the areas of mental health and drugs and alcohol and training.
  • I have never myself meant taking funds away  or eliminating police nor will I.
  • I have recommended looking for grants . . . for additional mental health specialists . .  .  look at the training.
  • I’m a mental health professional with a master’s degree. and I do counseling every Grace Crampsie Smith 2day, but I still need to be trained on a very frequent basis.
  • I think there’s a lot of confusion since the “8 to Abolition” group condones eliminating the police. I don’t support that.
  •  I have supported the “8 Can’t Wait,” and we talked about it.
  • And our Police Chief and department and our administration have been gracious to assure that we change some of the language in our use of force policy so that we are in compliance with “8 Can’t Wait,” and I applaud them for that.
  • I want it to be known as I’ve said multiple times . . . confused by people trying to paint me as anti-police . . . I grew up with a police chief . . . [my father] was a police chief . . . my nephew . . .
  • So how anybody can say that I am anti-police just boggles my mind.
  • I have a personal investment in police, and I know personally the struggle that they endure every day.
  • I also want it noted that I proposed a resolution months ago to insure that our police and emergency responders are covered for PTSD . . .
  • [Community Engagement Initiative] is a way to engage the community, so the community has a voice . . . we have not framed that . . . we have not sat down with the Mayor and said this is what it’s going to look like.
  • We’re going to see in what direction the community wants us to go as far as enhancing the relationship between the community and the police.
  • Certainly we have some ideas . . . in my mind . . . look at the type and frequency of training.
  • I applaud all the sides . . . pro-police, Black Lives Matter . . . that’s what democracy is, everybody having a voice
  • I think it’s unfortunate that there appears to be a scare type campaign that paints some individuals or groups as wanting to get rid of the police just to scare certain populations . . . It does nothing to help us as a community, as a country, and conversely I think it’s doing nothing but dividing us further.

“Where the Lenape lived by the Bending Creek . . . Let’s live out the best part of our legacy”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

More thoughts on the August 11 Public Safety meeting

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Gadfly, you know, is a “good conversation” junkie.

So, he’s excited.

The online Public Safety Committee meeting is now only a week away: Tuesday, August 11, 6PM.

Counting down.

Have you signed up yet?

Obsessed as he is with the great potential for change opening up to us, Gadfly has a few other comments to make:

Publicity: Gadfly hopes that there is a plan aworkin’ to turn out big numbers of the public. Gadfly, who’s been living and breathing this police/race issue for weeks, was taken aback that the resident who initiated that discussion on the Next Door blog a few days ago had only recently caught up to the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith resolution. We get no substantial media coverage; posts on the City web site are passive in nature. We’re gonna be talking about major issues, and Gadfly hopes there’s a plan to drive a big turnout. For people without internet access, for instance, he wonders if screens could be set up in certain schools or in the Hispanic Center where people could socially distance congregate and be encouraged to call in.

Scope of discussion: The meeting is billed as a discussion of use of force. There are several documents relevant to use of force linked on the registration page. Gadfly wishes the meeting was not trying to handle two big topics, the use of force and the Community Engagement Initiative. Gadfly is a divide and conquer kind of guy. Gadfly is a focus kind of guy. And these topics seem both big and, given the wide range in the way the CEI has been talked about, perhaps not all that related in the long-term. Gadfly would rather a focus on the police department here but widening the scope beyond use of force. We have linked three documents relating to use of force on the registration page. Gadfly would like to see the City budget, copies of the last two police accreditation reports, minority personnel statistics, discipline statistics, and so forth linked there as well. And you saw some of Gadfly’s other topics of interest in his last post on this topic. There’s a lot we could talk about. This is our chance to take a broad look at the department. Those chances don’t come too often. Let’s use it. Now the Chief may cover such things in the presentation, and there may be PowerPoint slides of interest, and so forth, but Gadfly would like to encourage the broadest look possible at the department and as much relevant info out front of the meeting as possible.

Format of the meeting: Gadfly has already mentioned a worry about trying to cover the two big topics at once. He knows permitting public comment at the beginning and at the end of the meeting is probably a bridge too far, but Gadfly hopes Chair Colon will have the public comment at the end of the meeting as he did in the last Public Safety meeting in March on the marijuana issue. Gadfly felt public comments could be more informed after hearing presentations and Council discussion.

What are you thinking about in regard to the operation of the meeting?

Post reprinted from July 7: Gadfly with questions for the police department

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

Gadfly posted the following July 7, the day City Council passed the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith resolution. He reprints it here as the Public Safety Committee meeting to discuss the Police use of force directives and the Community Engagement Initiative approaches.

The Police Department has made a presentation to the new NAACP Community Advisory Board, and he assumes that will be repeated or be the basis for a presentation at Public Safety. Gadfly wonders whether any of his topics are included.

That online Public Safety Committee meeting is one week from tonight, August 11, 6PM.

Be sure to sign up.

———–

Originally published July 7, 2020:

Gadfly understood there was to be a Public Safety Committee meeting to discuss the two prongs of the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith memo to the Mayor: the use of force directives and a Community Engagement Initiative.

He is not sure of the status of that Public Safety Committee meeting now that a resolution on the CEI is to be voted on tonight.

But he was hoping for this meeting as an opportunity to learn more about and to think more about our Police Department during this time of national conversation about how police departments are structured. In fact, he was hoping for the kind of invitation for the public to ask questions beforehand — like was done by the Mayor for the online coronavirus sessions — that would then be answered at the meeting.

What questions would you want to ask? What are the kinds of things you’d like to know  about our Police Department now that we and many others around the country are putting these departments under some scrutiny?

Gadfly shotguns here some things he would like to know.

History: Gadfly’s a historian, and he’d like a little history to frame the present discussion. There is an interesting “Department History” section on the City web site. But Gadfly is thinking of something different. What have been the past “philosophies” of the department? What type, what brand of policing characterized the department under, say, the chiefs before Chief DiLuzio? Go back 3-4 chiefs: Schiffer, Bedics, Miller, Donchez, etc. What philosophies were in play? Was there any change with Chief DiLuzio? How did the department get where it is now? Why is the department doing what it does now?

Community policing: Gadfly is confused. The Department describes itself now as following a Community Policing philosophy. When and why did that occur? But he has heard resident Lisa Rosa in particular at City Council meetings bemoan the loss of community policing. And just recently in the post-GeorgeFloyd conversations others have called for a return to community policing. Which is it? Do we have it or not? Or are there different forms of community policing? What is the definition of community policing anyway? What other kinds of policing are there? How does community policing differ from them?

Citizen complaints/officer discipline: There is an “Issue with an Officer” page on the City web site that speaks of an “Employee Misconduct Allegation form” that can be filled out at headquarters. (Let’s not forget that there is a “Commend an Officer” page as well that we hope gets a lot of action.) Shouldn’t this “Issue” page be online rather than requiring perhaps awkward and perhaps intimidating interaction with an officer downstairs at City Hall? Let’s go back, say, 5 years — how many issues have there been each year? Are the issues coded or classified by type so that we can better understand their nature? If so, what are they? Are there categories for improper use of force, profiling, disrespect, intimidation, etc.? How and by whom are these complaints handled — the Chief? the Standards division?  What are the outcomes (guilty/not guilty, warning, a lecture, letter in the file, disciplinary action, dismissal) and give statistics over the past 5 years? How many of the current officer force have had a citizen complaint? How many have had multiple complaints? How many complaints have the top 5 officers in number of complaints had? What role does the FOP have in investigation of the complaints? Has the Department fired or tried to fire an officer for such complaints? What role does the FOP play in a firing? What is the process to fire an officer? We could use a case study of handling a complaint — what happened in this case that was reported to Gadfly? Give 2-3 other examples of how complaints were resolved. Are complainants made aware of the disposition of their complaints?

Racial composition of the department: If Gadfly remembers correctly, he has heard the Chief recently say that the department is racially mixed, even one Asian if memory serves. But what are the exact numbers? How many white, how many Latino, etc? Does the racial composition of the force mirror the racial composition of the City? How many minority officers are in leadership positions?

Cameras: body cameras came in 2019, and, if Gadfly memory serves again, he heard the Chief say recently that every officer has one. However, what are the rules for use? Gadfly has heard of two cases settled definitively by camera evidence. Was there camera evidence in the case above? Have the cameras changed officer behavior? Is there any evidence that the use of body cameras has changed the number and kind of citizen complaints?

Handcuffing: Gadfly, no doubt naively, has always been curious about this. What is the policy on handcuffing? Gadfly is thinking of the Rayshard Brooks case recently where the interaction of Brooks and the officer seemed fine until the cuffing. Cuffing is both humiliating and emasculating. Lack of control. Resistance is natural. None of us would like it. Especially if feeling innocent of wrongdoing or if the offense or suspected offense is minor. Must handcuffing be done for every arrest? (We’ve seen very young kids in cuffs.)

Citizen rights: Ha! Maybe the police are not the ones to ask this question of. But Gadfly has often heard the advice to just go along with an officer, not to question, not to resist, even if you know you have done nothing wrong. And that’s probably what he would do. But what can you do? What “resistance” is allowable? Do you have a right to know what you are being arrested for? What happens if you deny a request to search your car? Gadfly is thinking that information on allowable citizen behavior and what citizen rights are when detained or arrested would be good, perhaps through role playing of example situations .

Police response: We heard recently that the City is divided up into 8 sectors. And we heard that the area around 6th and Hayes is in the worst crime area in the city. Gadfly would like to see the ranking of those 8 areas. But what is the department response to a high crime area? Is the response to station more manpower there? More heavily armed manpower? To exercise more surveillance? To implement more force? Or is there any attempt to understand the reasons/causes for that high crime and to establish programs or to work with other departments in the city to establish programs that might hack away at the root of the problem? What specific policies has the department implemented to stem crime in the past several years in the top two crime areas in the city and have those plans been successful. Show data.

Past CEI-type activities: There was a CEI-type event in 2016 with the local NAACP called “Black Lives Also Matter.” The newspaper said troublesome stories reported by residents “all came as news” to Chief DiLuzio, “but he agreed police training hasn’t kept up with the times, noting a recruit goes through 600 hours at the academy compared to the 1,500 hours it takes to become a cosmetologist. Raised on technology, a new officer might come on duty lacking the interpersonal skills, the ability to read body language that the job requires, he said. . . . ‘All this technology, great: Get the new iPhone 974, great, whatever it’s up to now. But it can’t replace a human,’ DiLuzio said. ‘The training is, I don’t think, up to snuff for 2016. I’ll probably get criticized for it. I’m in this job for 36 years. I have a right to say it’.” Were there any changes instituted as a result of this forum? Was there any follow-up contact with the NAACP to determine the outcome of the forum? The Mayor is quoted as saying this was the “fourth such forum on race relations,” but Gadfly hasn’t been able to find info on the others. What prompted the Mayor to institute this series, if it was he who did it? What can we learn from the success or failure of this forum (or series of forums) that bears on the one being proposed now? Were there other such CEI-type activities in recent memory that we also should know about as we contemplate a new one now? In other words and simply, do CEI’s do any good?

Educating the public: Here’s a wild idea. Looking at use of force directives is one thing. Seeing them in concrete situations another. Gadfly imagines there must be training videos of situations involving police interactions with the public showing right and wrong police behavior. How about the police sharing them with the public? How about educating the public about the police viewpoint in regard to specific situations where force is applied? How about open conversation between police and community members around not just “directives” but “real life” — showing how an officer properly or improperly processes his or her training? For instance, Gadfly posted this “A Case Study in the use of force by police.” Gadfly can see a great conversation around that video. As starkly horrible as that video can feel, Gadfly, having just come off reading the use of force directive, thought a case could be made that the officer was acting properly.

Whew! Well, there’s Gadfly’s shotgun blast of questions as the countdown toward posting time has expired.

What are you thinking? What would you like to ask the police?

Remember, good conversation builds community.

“Liberty is what we’re longing for . . . Liberty despite distance and closed doors”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

Gadfly proposes that we think of this song as a kind of anthem for the Lehigh Valley
and that we start every morning with it.

“Lehigh Valley be Free” is the work of the Lehigh Valley Song Project that premiered at Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event on July 24.

———-

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

Reflecting on the discussion at Allentown City Council July 29

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

The reason for spending 4-5 posts on last Wednesday’s Allentown City Council meeting was to see what we could glean from it to inform our thinking and our practice as we head toward the August 11 Bethlehem Public Safety Committee meeting that will discuss the Bethlehem police use of force policy and the Community Engagement Initiative.

Here are Gadfly’s rambling reflections on that meeting.

As usual, your responses invited, especially if contrary to the Gadfly’s.

The more perspectives the better.

1} We don’t want to see the breakdown that yesterday’s posts show within the Allentown City Council. Difference of opinion, yes, ok, but not a breakdown in civility or respect or cooperation. Please.

2) We have not had a recent police incident like the Allentown Sacred Heart incident to flare passions and to foster stand-taking. Gadfly wonders if our Bethlehem discussion of police policy and practice therefore will have only an “academic” feel to it. Where will deep motivation for change in Bethlehem — if, in fact, change is desired — come from? Can tragic cases elsewhere — nationally — do that? Can fear of tragic cases here do that? Or is there a history of troublesome incidents in Bethlehem of which the public is not generally aware?

3) Bethlehem proponents of specific changes in police policies and practices are liable to find, as Allentown did, that either what they want is already “on the books” or is controlled by state law or Human Resources/personnel policies or Union collective bargaining contracts. Quick change in specific policies and practices — maybe even any change — in many cases is not possible. Gadfly felt that such reality severely deflated the Allentown reform position as parts of the resolution were taken up by the Allentown Council and dismissed. It almost felt sometimes that not enough homework was done.

4) We need someone to compare the “8 Can’t Wait” list with our police department regs. A match or not?

5) The Allentown Chief entertained the possibility of a citizen “advisory” group — interestingly, we may have just gotten one in the Community Advisory Board in which we participate with the NAACP. Its specific role still needs more explanation. Gadfly is not sure that reform voices from such groups as Black Lives Matter or Lehigh Valley Stands Up are on that Board, though. And, if not, how useful will that Board be? That Board has to hear challenging views.

6) For Big Picture discussion, “defunding the police” is an unfortunate phrase for the general public. Gadfly, of course, is not the first to say that.

7) For Big Picture discussion, “systemic racism” is an unfortunately vague term for the general public. Gadfly, of course, is not the first to say that either.

8) But it’s easy to see the result of that lack of understanding in the incredulity about both terms by many voices on the Next Door blog, using that blog as a snapshot of mainstream resident thinking.

9) Proponents of change in Bethlehem such as the ones who personally attended our July 7 Council meeting and who probably will be present August 11 assume an understanding of “defunding the police” and “systemic racism” that the voices on the Next Door blog, for instance, pretty much totally lack — and the proponents of change sometimes unfortunately if understandably speak in terms of “demands.” Which feels rhetorically and strategically unwise to Gadfly.

10) Proponents of change in Bethlehem who want (need) general public support have a big hill to climb, much groundwork to lay, a significant good-faith educational task to perform. Again, representative mainstream resident voices on the Next Door blog either didn’t understand what defunding the police means or immediately saw it as disastrous. They could not “picture” it.

11) It’s up to the proponents of change in Bethlehem to patiently help mainstream residents “picture” it.

12) 2/3’s or more of the Allentown population are People of Color. They don’t need the terms explained. Systemic racism is their felt reality. They were pounding on the outside walls of Council chambers while inside the Allentown Council deflated the resolution as if they and that practice didn’t exist. We don’t have the pressure from those numbers here. In Bethlehem, less than 10% of the population is Black (for historical reasons as Councilman Reynolds has interestingly explained) and the roughly 30% Latino population (as suggested by Councilwoman Negron last Council meeting) are quiet (silenced?) perhaps because they fear reprisal. The 60% white population has no felt reality to associate with the terms and thus needs to be educated.

13) When it came to the major, overarching issue of defunding or divesting the police, Gadfly feels the Allentown proponents of change got completely steamrolled. They did not even try to respond (maybe they were consciously being quiet??? Gadfly is no strategist). They did not have an answer for basic objections to defunding/divestment and for commonsense questions about defunding/divestment. Gadfly himself could not have voted to further examine the possibility of defunding the police on the basis of anything they said. No case was made.

14) Who will write the answer to the Allentown Chief who says his budget has been cut, but he is still operating underbudget, in a fiscally responsible way; who says his force is down 20% or whatever from a few years ago, yet they are out there 24/7 during a pandemic risking their lives for us; who says that to cut the force even more at this moment would negate recent hard-gotten gains in minority recruiting; who says that domestic violence calls are among the most dangerous of all and no place for a social worker; and who says that it would make no sense to sacrifice training to the budget knife. Who does the math and tells the Chief what we’re going to cut from his budget and then where we’re putting that money — and, most importantly, how public safety will be thereby improved? Nobody has yet shown that defunding is, indeed, reasonably possible. Needs to happen.

15) Gadfly knows many of you follow Bernie O’Hare’s Lehigh Valley Ramblings blog, and Bernie had an “Allentown’s Real Heroes” post there yesterday morning that’s on point here. Nobody yet that Gadfly sees is writing the response to the kind of tack Bernie takes there. And that is what’s needed if the defunding reform gains any traction.

16) Gadfly perked up at this statement by the Allentown Chief. He said, if we are going to make changes, let’s do it right, let’s take time, let’s partner with somebody to do research, let’s find a model plan right for Allentown. Plans specifically at Eugene, Oregon, and St. Petersburg, Florida, were mentioned, but perhaps as inapplicable to Allentown. But if one is trying to gain support for defunding, for shaping new visions of public safety, why are some concrete examples of explorations and experiments elsewhere not brought forward to help break the death grip of the status quo. People on and off the Head Table need a “picture” . . . need a vision. Leadership creates visions. (The pending research report on local policing by Lehigh’s Prof Holona Ochs promises to be relevant here.)

17) Gadfly still doesn’t have a good answer to such questions he has been posing lately like do “we” have a beef with the department? Has trust between police and community broken down in Bethlehem or in some parts of Bethlehem? Is reform urgently needed here? It seems like the Minneapolis police department of the Floyd case has a history of trouble and controversy. That department needs to be fixed. Allentown may have that kind of history too. Are we in that position? Or are we thinking that this cultural moment of national conversation presents us with a valuable opportunity to rethink how we do the public safety business and explore other options?

Gentlemen, gentle ladies, start your engines.

Find anything here on which to chew?

“We’re all connected . . . Everybody needs freedom”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Arts in Bethlehem logo

“Lehigh Valley be Free,” original song and music video that premiered July 24th as part of Touchstone Theatre’s “Songs of Hope & Resistance” event.

Gadfly’s sobbing with the vision.

touchstone 2

DONATE NOW to support the musicians, artists, and producers who made the
Lehigh Valley Song Project possible!

https://bit.ly/LVsongdonate

What does Bethlehem City Council need?

Latest in a series of posts about responses to the George Floyd killing

Not what’s happening to the Allentown City Council.

Divisiveness spreads as quickly as the coronavirus.

And divisiveness kills like it too.

What does Bethlehem City Council need right now?

The qualities of all good elected officials.

The patience of Job.

The wisdom of Solomon.

And, if needed, last resort, the right hand of Muhammad Ali.

Gadfly is looking for Job and Solomon right now.

What fresh hell is this? Part 1

logo Latest in a series of posts about responses to the George Floyd killing logo

from Andrew Scott and Jon Harris, “Three Allentown council members call for Gerlach and Siegel to be censured for joining Black Lives Matter protests.” Morning Call, August 2, 2020.

Three Allentown City Council members say they support a resolution demanding a censure and no-confidence vote against council members Ce-Ce Gerlach and Joshua Siegel, urging them to resign and alleging conflicts of interest in their participation in Black Lives Matter protests.

The resolution, which was drafted by council member Ed Zucal and could be presented at Wednesday’s meeting, claims Gerlach and Siegel betrayed the oath of office and “are unfit and not worthy to hold the position of councilperson.” Council President Daryl Hendricks and member Candida Affa said Saturday they support the resolution, agreeing that Gerlach and Siegel’s demonstrating raises questions about their objectivity in matters pertaining to the Allentown Police Department.

Gerlach and Siegel defended their actions, saying that standing with citizens does not pose a conflict of interest. It’s unclear whether they will be censured, with Hendricks and Affa noting the resolution will need four yes votes to pass. That means the resolution hinges on votes from council Vice President Julio Guridy and member Cynthia Mota.

Guridy didn’t return a call about his vote. Mota didn’t wish to discuss her vote, but said she was disgusted and saddened by the situation. ”I was elected to do the right thing by the people. I didn’t sign up for nonsense,” Mota said. “I really would like to tell people that we have to be united, this is not the time to be divided. It just pains me when I see all the negativity going around.”

Gerlach and Siegel recently proposed reforms to police department policy, such as a requirement that officers intervene when they see force being used inappropriately, that a citizen’s board review allegations of excessive force, and that some of the department’s funding be reallocated to nonprofits providing mental health and addiction services. Council will discuss the measures at its Aug. 12 meeting.

The resolution alleges Gerlach and Siegel:

    • used social media to make derogatory remarks against other council members and the police department.
    • violated the city charter by joining protesters who “attempted to question the police and ask for defunding the police” after a July 11 incident outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart in which an officer used his knee to restrain Edward Borrero Jr.
    • were both seen carrying signs that said “Defund the police”; and Siegel was heard saying “F— the police.”
    • put pedestrians at risk with their involvement in protests, which blocked intersections, causing drivers to go the wrong way down streets.
    • undermined the police department by publicly apologizing to Borrero after the July 15 council meeting, where a number of citizens angry at Borrero’s arrest urged council to reform the police department and protested outside.
    • In addition, Siegel gave the mayor’s cellphone number to “an already angry group of protesters,” which the resolution calls a moral and ethical violation that led to him being harassed.

Their actions, the resolution alleges, placed the city in “a position of future litigation” and showed they can no longer be objective about the police department or trusted by citizens.

Gerlach and Siegel took issue with the allegations, saying they were protesting systemic racism. They noted that other council members, including Hendricks, Zucal and Affa, joined Allentown’s first Black Lives Matter protest just days after a white police officer in Minneapolis pressed his knee on the neck of George Floyd, killing him, during a May 25 arrest.

“And I’m glad my fellow council members were there, but does this mean there was a conflict of interest in that protest as well?” Gerlach asked.

“No,” Zucal said. “We were not there to protest. We were there to support.”

Gerlach said she never carried a “defund the police” sign, yelled anything offensive at the police or posted disparaging remarks about council online.

“I’d like to see those posts they’re claiming I put out on social media,” she said.

“Conflict of interest is really being misconstrued here,” Siegel said. “I can argue it’s a conflict of interest for council members Zucal and Hendricks, both former police officers themselves, to vote with the rest of council on any matters involving our local police department.”

Siegel said he has apologized to Mayor Ray O’Connell for giving out his phone number, adding he did so in the heat of the moment.

The reforms he and Gerlach have proposed, Siegel said, aren’t anti-police but a reexamination of public safety issues and the money the city spends on them. He said it wasn’t council’s place to determine if he and Gerlach were worthy of holding office, that that’s up to the voters.

“What they’re really censuring is the Black Lives Matter movement, which is bigger than me and Councilwoman Gerlach,” he said. “They’re making it real clear what their stance is.”

This is only part 1. Buckle up!

High Noon at the Emmaus Triangle: “I love you” . . . “I love you, too”

logo Latest in a series of posts about responses to the George Floyd killing logo

From Kayla Dwyer, “Black Lives Matter activists silently protest at ‘pro-Trump/Back the Blue’ rally in Emmaus, where tensions rose but settled.” Morning Call, August 1, 2020.

Not long after the two groups assembled in the center of Emmaus at high noon Saturday, one occupying most of the Triangle and the other a corner of it, they came face to face.

Those who gathered in the Emmaus Triangle for a pro-Trump/Back the Blue/pro-Second Amendment event turned their attention toward Black Lives Matter activists staging a silent protest. At the height of the tension, the Trump supporters, many of them visibly armed and maskless, stood within a few feet of the Black Lives Matter protesters and lobbed insults at them: “stupid kids,” “Marxists,” “move to another country.”

Apart from one or two activists who shouted back, most stood in silence behind signs that read “No Justice No Peace,” “Hate has no home here,” and “Are we Great yet? Black Lives Matter.”

As the scene played out, Jerone Darden of Bethlehem performed a Native American smudging ceremony, burning sage to purge the air of negative energy and bring forth the positive.

At least 200 people filled the Triangle, the pro-Trump crowd double the size of the Black Lives Matter group. Never did the tension boil over. That was how organizers of both groups wanted it.

Before the event, they agreed to keep the peace. Brendan Schoepflin, who organized the Trump supporters, said he carried a rifle there, as he did to a pro-police rally outside Allentown City Hall Wednesday, for protection in case things erupted.

When Ed DeGrace, donning a Black Lives Matter T-shirt, asked Garrett Boyer, who was wearing a military helmet, why he brought a gun to a peaceful protest, Boyer said he was in the Army and, “I needed this weapon two months ago when I was stationed in Philadelphia getting Molotov cocktails thrown at me.”

Ron Sell, a lifelong Emmaus resident, attended the pro-Trump rally. He has a permit to carry a concealed weapon but said he’s never used a gun and hopes not to.

“I have no hate toward them,” he said, referring to the Black Lives Matter protesters. “If they had guns, I wouldn’t mind.”

As the rallies wound down, individuals from opposing groups splintered off into civil one-on-one conversations.

Alex O’Neill, a recent Emmaus High School graduate from the Black Lives Matter group, and Ron Paul Jr., sporting a Trump T-Shirt, spoke at length about corporations controlling politics, extremists on both ends of the political spectrum and the need to weed them out.

“Hey, I love you,” Paul told O’Neill as he left. O’Neill chuckled and said, “I love you, too.”

 

Testimony (2)

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

In an effort to gauge the state of trust between the community and the police department, Gadfly seeks first-person testimony of interactions — good and bad — with police. All communication will be confidential, all posting anonymous. Contact through the blog or at ejg1@lehigh.edu. 

Transcription of July 23 phone conversation

Gadfly:

My daughter ran upstairs to tell me the police were outside. The police were right outside.  There was a very visible presence. There were 2 police cars, a motorcycle, and 5 policemen. I went out on the front porch to observe. There was this young Black man who looked like he was exercising in the neighborhood. He had on exercise gear. He wasn’t carrying anything with him. He had sneakers and athletic gear on. At first they were just questioning him. I was on high alert. Five cops and one very young-looking man – he didn’t look older than 20. He looked like a high school kid. So they were questioning him, questioning him, questioning him for a long time. Nothing violent happened. That was my worst fear. Fortunately, nothing of that sort happened. But there were a few reasons why I was concerned, One, they were aggressively questioning him, and then they arrested him. And the cop that was doing a lot of the questioning and who actually patted him down, went through his pockets – he was in very close physical proximity – had no mask on at all. And he was in this guy’s face. And it seemed to me given the global pandemic, that the police, closer than 6 feet, unable to social distance, should be setting the example and they should be the example of safety because regardless of whether this guy was a criminal or not he doesn’t deserve to be exposed to the virus by this cop. He could be innocent for all we know. And even if he’s not innocent, he still doesn’t deserve to be exposed possibly. So that was very concerning because they weren’t wearing masks. At least the cop who came very close to him wasn’t. A couple of the other ones were. The other thing that just bothers me is that I’m on the neighborhood blog and I see the emails people send and people are very racist. People say all the time like I saw this suspicious person outside with dark skin and blah-blah-blah and I’ve never seen this person in the neighborhood before, and it’s really suspicious activity and so I feel that people in my neighborhood are racially profiling. And it gets very frustrating because, again, I know nothing about the criminality of this young man, he could well have been engaged in criminal activity, but it just keeps bothering me very much that I see this type of racial profiling happening in my neighborhood whether it’s my neighbors doing it or the police doing it. One of my neighbors said that the police had been in the store at the corner of the street looking for some homeless guy. And I said this kid was clearly not homeless. He did not look like a homeless person. So who knows what the truth is there. It’s just very frustrating that every time you hear these stories, every time somebody is doing suspicious activity it’s always a Black person. It feels very unfair, and I don’t understand why this keeps happening. It felt like they were questioning him for a very long time. They were going back and forth and then all of a sudden they arrested him. At first I thought they were going to give him a ticket or something because he took out this notebook and a piece of paper and started writing something on it. Before they left I asked the cop as a concerned citizen what was going on in my neighborhood, and he said he was suspected of criminal activity elsewhere. Some earlier crime that happened elsewhere. Prompted by frustration in this national moment and just sadness, so at that point I called the police to inquire because if there was some criminal activity in my neighborhood I wanted to know about it. If not, I wanted to know if my neighbors were racially profiling. And also to point out to the officer that it’s a sign of basic respect to wear a mask and that the officers should be held accountable. These are mandates from the governor, you know. So why is it ok for a cop to get right in front of somebody’s face without a mask on, it just doesn’t seem right. The person I spoke with was very indignant that the cop did nothing wrong and wouldn’t give me any information whatsoever and told me that it was basically up to the police whether they wanted to wear a mask, which I thought was absurd. And the other frustrating thing was that I talked with this person on the phone for a while and explained everything that happened and afterwards he was like if you want to file a complaint you have to come down to City Hall to file a complaint. And I said well I thought I was filing a complaint by speaking to you on the phone and he said, no, you have to file a complaint, and I said in the middle of a global pandemic you want me to come inside the police station and file a report? like it just doesn’t seem right, they make it as difficult a possible to file a report. So I can call this number and tell you what happened and this doesn’t count as filing a report – it’s very annoying. So that person I spoke with was very dismissive on the phone when I expressed my concerns as a member of the community. He looked like he was a jogger. I took a photo and sent it to all my friends in a text chain and asked if anybody knows this kid and nobody knew him but several people said that they’ve seen him exercising in the neighborhood before. Sounds to me like he’s somebody who lives in the neighborhood. It was hard to hear everything that was exactly being said but he was calmly talking to them. He was very, very calm, he complied with everything the officers told him. They questioned him for a good 25 minutes or so. That’s pretty much what happened.

———–

See Testimony (1)

Allentown Councilman Siegel: “We can both praise the cops for doing good work and also re-imagine public safety”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Allentown City Council meeting July 29, 2020, video
mins. 3:10:05 – 3:16:00

Gadfly reminds you that we’ve been following the Allentown discussion on police matters triggered by the murder of George Floyd. His purpose, as always, is to lay out all the voices on an issue to aid us in making up our own minds.

We end here with the spirited conclusion to the meeting by Councilman Siegel, the co-sponsor with Councilwoman Gerlach of the Allentown resolution, the most spirited segment of the meeting.

Gadfly invites you to reflect on what you saw, on what we can learn from the Allentown proceedings. What issues, what arguments, what “styles” caught your attention?

Councilman Siegel:

This is unfortunate in our country that we constantly refer to ourselves . . . immediately revert to the ideological ways of framing our world . You’re anti-cop, you’re pro-cop, liberal, you’re a Republican, you’re progressive, you’re not, it’s all frankly BS, and it’s a way to just structure the world in a way that pits us against each other. I’ve been called a hypocrite in previous weeks, and frankly it’s a crock of crap. I’m not a hypocrite. I think we can both praise the police department for the good work you do when you guys catch criminals, when you take drug gangs off the streets, when you take drugs and guns off Siegel 2the streets, that is keeping us safe and you deserve every bit of praise for doing it. But don’t think that that insulates institutions and organizations from criticism for things that they do wrong. You can do both. We can both praise the cops for doing good work and also re-imagine public safety in this country and look for ways in which we can spend our money better. Maybe that means making sure when you think you’re having a mental health crisis or you’re going through a social issue or a substance abuse issue that the cops aren’t the first freakin’ call, the first person on the scene. And, by the way, there are models in this country that work, are models that we can apply to Allentown. Yes that we need to adjust. Yes we must adjust to the fact that there might be language barriers or racial discrepancies but when Eugene, Oregon, can do Cahoots [?], when they can take care of 17% of their call line for 2% of their police budget and last year there were 24,000 Cahoots calls and only 150 of them required police back up, I’m sick and tired of people mischaracterizing these incidents as devolving into violence and chaos. We heard some of these letters tonight, I just hear the vitriol and the racism and the freaking backwards thinking that comes through. To insinuate that I want to divest money or redirect money . . . that I am in favor of rape and murder and gangs, are you kidding me? What kind of deranged, delusional, paranoid mindset does that emanate from? That’s not healthy, that’s not contributing to the conversation. I’ve had many people email me over the last few weeks, called me names, called me derogatory things. You know what, I emailed them back and had honest, frank, and genuine conversation trying to find consensus with them . You know, with a lot of the people we found common ground. Everybody in this country deserves respect, and I’m not going to draw a false equivalency between the racist and vitriolic statements that we have gotten . . . spray the protestors down with hoses . . . they said they’re all on welfare. Absolutely freakin’ not. I’m not going to draw a comparison between that and people who have faced 400 years of structural oppression and death and violence and say that’s the same thing as their yelling at the cops and these people are calling them animals. It’s not the same freakin’ thing, we should not draw that false equivalency. We should not cast them in the same way as people who show up with American flags with crosses on them, we know what that means, we know what they’re getting at, we know they are white supremacists who try to infiltrate that, we know where one side is coming from. Ok, we want to have an honest conversation in the city, I’m more than ready, and Chief I’m prepared to work with you in any way I can. I want you to be a partner in this, I want you to be an ally. I don’t hate you, I respect you, I think we can be friends, I’ve never said anything bad about you. I want you and I to be partners and friends but at the same time recognize that change and real leadership is about confronting institutions, it’s about having uncomfortable conversations, change is not doing what we all agree on, change is not saying these are the things that don’t offend any of us so that’s what we’re going to do. That’s not change, that’s the illusion of change., that’s symbolic justice, that’s us flying the Pride flag but behind the scenes saying transphobic stuff, that’s companies in America tweeting Black Lives Matter but then not fully paying their taxes to fully fund our schools. We’re done with symbolic justice in this country, we’re done with symbolic gestures, we’re going to actually put our money where our mouth is as a city because the world is watching, the country is watching, and you’d better believe the citizens of Allentown are watching, and they’re gonna have their voices heard. And I’m more than prepared to keep an open mind. As we talked tonight I realized there are things that I put on this list that we thought might have been possible and they have a state dynamic. I’m more than willing to understand that I was wrong about how we could do some of these things. I thought there was a local dynamic, clearly there isn’t. I am an open-minded individual, I evolve, and I change, and I respect that I’m not always right. I was wrong about some of these things, we adapted and adjusted, and now we’re going to do a state-wide approach, but the things we can do at the local level, you better darn well believe we are going to. I have 4 years, I may only get 4 years, the people of Allentown may keep me from doing what I’m doing, but I’m going to do what I think is right. And I’m going to work in every capacity that I can from this day and the day I may be removed from office but I’m going to do what’s right. And I want to say to everybody on this stage that you might not like me, you might not like what I stand for, I respect you as my colleagues, I respect you as professionals that I will work with, but, believe me, I’m going to hold you individually accountable, when I disagree where we are ideologically. That’s all I’m going to say. I will never call people names. I will never besmirch your personal character, but I will call you out when we are ideologically different, and I will push you to be on the right side of what I think the issue is, and I hope you can understand that. That’s the nature of politics, that’s the nature of elected leaders, that the nature of being leaders. We will butt heads because we have strong values and convictions. And I just want to make that clear that now is the time for real action and that’s going to make people feel uncomfortable and I’m sorry. It’s easy to run for office  . . . the hard part comes when you have to start making the changes . . . I apologize to you for the email, for what I did it was wrong . . . should not have released  your phone number, I fucked up, shouldn’t have done that, that was my fault, it’s on me, I own that mistake, shouldn’t have done it . . . me being a man, I screwed up, I violated your trust. That reflects poorly on me, I get that. But at the end of the day we all have a job to do. I’m gonna close with this. John F. Kennedy said we should not seek the Republican answer or the Democratic answer, let us find the right answer. Let us not blame the past but all collectively accept responsibility for the future. And that’s what we have to do. This is not about partisanship, not about who we are but finding the right answer, that means putting aside our emotions and our egos and following the facts like you said Chief, what works, what’s evidence based. And that’s it.

Councilman Siegel’s rapid delivery presented a challenge here and there for transcription. Gadfly apologizes for any errors.

Allentown Councilwoman Gerlach: “this needed to come up . . . we could not do nothing”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Allentown City Council meeting July 29, 2020, video
mins. 3:04:08 – 3:09:05

After a lengthy procedural discussion about the next step — looks like another special meeting August 12 — both Councilpeople Gerlach and Siegel made concluding statements — and things got more fiery.

We’ll take Councilwoman Gerlach first.

Gadfly always suggests that you go to the primary sources. Hear the voices for yourself.

Councilwoman Gerlach:

I just want to thank everyone. If there are still folks alive outside on both sides, Back the Blue people, the Black Lives Matter folks, I haven’t read anything, anything went down, so it’s great to see that two sides can come, do their thing, advocate, make your voice heard, and then go home and hopefully relax. And I would like to thank my fellow members of Council for entertaining this for discussing this, and thank the Chief, thank the Mayor, the Solicitor, thank everyone because we couldn’t be silenced.  Even thoughGerlach 1 this may have caused a lot of division, this needed to come up. We cannot during this time of national outrage, when buildings are burning, rubber bullets are flying, riot gear is in full force, we could not do nothing. So that’s why this came about. And what passes is what passes. But at least we’re having the conversation. And I’m hoping that at some point we can get beyond this divisive you’re either anti-cop if you want reform, or you are a hard-core KKK member if you don’t want reform. There’s gotta be a way that we can start having these conversations in a civil way without pigeon-holing people. Calling people scumbags, saying that we need hoses placed on us. Ridiculous, ridiculous. That doesn’t get us anywhere. We’ve got to be able to have comfortable, direct conversations about tough topics without resorting to disrespectful name-calling, threats, towards either Black Lives Matter, protestors, calling people thugs, that’s a racist term, to call someone a thug. We’ve got to stop that, it breaks down conversations when you start using those terminologies. And I just hope that as we continue to dive into these bullet points, these issues, that we can do some internal soul-searching. I have biases, we all do, we have to start thinking how my world view, how I grew up, makes the skin I’m in, how it affects how I view these situations, because it is easy for some folks to say that it’s not my problem but maybe someone with a different life-path, a different skin tone, a different sexuality, maybe for them it is. Thank you for having this tough conversation. It’s going to get tougher when we actually have to pass things. But I needed to say that, and I don’t know who is still out there at this point, but we gotta stop using racist language. There has been racist language used toward people of color in this town and towards me, and I’m sick of it. If you want to back the blue, back the blue, go all out, buy a big flag, do what you gotta do, but there is no room for racism. There is no room, not in Allentown, that crosses the line. So that’s it. Thank you . . . . Never said that. . . . Well, I didn’t make those remarks, so please don’t accuse me of doing that.

Councilman Siegel’s response next . . .

Allentown Council discusses the resolution regarding the police department (2): divestment and defunding

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Allentown City Council meeting July 29, 2020, video
Mins. 2:24:40 – 2:40:20

Now we get to the heart of the matter.

Councilpeople Gerlach and Siegel are the ones behind the resolution.

No one else on Council supported the divestment and defunding proposed in the last clause of the resolution.

No one.

The Mayor said the City “needs help” from the county in regard to some of the services to which the “defunders” would like to see money reallocated. The county must “step up to the plate.”

Social workers aren’t going to respond to the call of a man barricaded with a gun.

No way hospital personnel were going to respond to the man, given the state he was in, in the recent Sacred Heart Hospital episode.

There was a recent major fire in Allentown — the police responded first.

Fire fighters say they depend on the police for their very lives and plead that the police not be cut.

The Police are out there disregarding their own safety during this pandemic.

“Our lives depend on the police department.”

Defunding “is going to turn into a disaster.”

Domestic violence calls are among the most dangerous calls there are — and not for social workers.

The police department had 242 officers in 2003, 216 now. It is not now adequately staffed.

“Our city is not shrinking,” we need more police not less.

Social service agencies already exist, with lots of money.

What we should do if we are going to do it right, is do research, partner with someone and study what’s right for our community. Such models as Eugene, Oregon, and St. Petersburg not transferable.

Need data-driven approach.

To cut the department now would be to cut (seniority basis) the most diverse part of the department — would make no sense.

What can’t the police department do without? Training. You wouldn’t want to cut that.

The department budget has been cut but even so it is now running under even the diminished budget. We’re running a good ship. Good stewards of our resources.

I support Black Lives Matter, and I support the Police Department.

Nobody supported divestment or defunding.

Say again, nobody supported divestment or defunding.

How did the proposers of the resolution respond? See next.