Gadfly election exercise

logo 2nd in a series of new posts on candidates for election logo

Election Day Tuesday November 5!

You know how Gadfly feels about participation — BE THERE!

But, frankly, Gadfly, whose focus is narrowly on Bethlehem, is not the whirling dervish he was for the primary in May.

No mayoral election. No “real” Council election. No competition for these seats. No localĀ  choices there to be made.

Yep, yep, other important races — my phone is blowing up, my mail box stuffed with flyers, my front door a bulletin board for canvassing candidates.

But Gadfly just doesn’t feel all that engaged.

What to do?

Gadfly reminds you that Council is a likely pool for mayoral candidates in the next election, and, in any event, current Council members are likely to want to keep going on in their positions.

So we should always be paying attention, always gathering information.

Let’s remember that the soon-to-be-automatically-elected Council members did a very remarkable thing for the primary (that “very” is redundant, dammit, you should know better, Gadfly).

Successful candidates Colon, Reynolds, Van Wirt, and Crampsie Smith wrote 8 mini-essays — one each week — in response to Gadfly prompts in the run-up to the election.

Well, unsuccessful candidates Carpenter and Saltzer — Gadfly hopes you remember them and their energetic efforts — did that same very remarkable thing too. Tip o’ the hat to them, for sure.

Gadfly is still humbled by that amazing totally voluntary cooperation.

The goal was to get beyond stump speeches and sound bites and to help voters be much better informed about candidate positions when it came time to vote.

And feedback indicated to Gadfly that followers appreciated the effort that the candidates put in.

So let’s remember those probably sweated-over mini-essays.

But let’s go a step further.

Let’s literally refresh ourselves on their words, see how we feel about them now, and let’s hold those successful City Council candidates to those words.

Say it. Mean it.

No coasting down Victory Lane.

So here’s what Gadfly is suggesting for an election exercise.

He will compile and re-publish the 8 mini-essays for each soon-to-be-elected running unopposed City Council candidate one at a time over the next 4 days, beginning today.

You have the recent 5-month context as a point of reference for these three incumbents re-elected: Colon, Reynolds, Van Wirt.

Followers know that the Gadfly blog has much information on these three incumbents from their activity on Council, and Gadfly has been urging you to pay attention.

You are not obliged to vote for all three on Tuesday.

If you like what an individual’s been doing, vote twice for him or her (just k-i-d-d-i-n-g!).

If you have some reservation on one or more, withhold your vote accordingly.

You are not obliged to vote for all three.

I’m sure the candidates will be looking at total numbers as well as numbers from specific wards and comparing them to projections in this “off” year.

You might be able to use your vote to send a message.

Either I like what you’re doing. Or — ha! — you’d better shape up.

Get the idea.

Make your vote or lack thereof count.

Make this “dead” local Council election interesting for you.

Re-assess.

Mentally make the candidates still earn your vote.

Scrutinize again what they presented on Gadfly during primary time.

Alphabetical order.

Michael Colon coming up!

Vote!
Election Day
Tuesday November 5

Thinking about the (next) election

logo1st in a series of new posts on candidates for electionlogo

So there’s an election coming up in two weeks.

It’s an important one — judge, district attorney, controller, school board, etc., etc.

And Gadfly hopes you will make sure to vote.

012

But Gadfly’s not real excited about this one.

He focuses on Bethlehem, and there’s no opposition for City Council slots.

No way his energy and enthusiasm will match the 70+ posts you will remember he did on the primary.

Gadfly’s looking ahead already to the May 2021 primary.

The Hizzoner or Heroner (we haven’t had a woman) position of Mayor will be open.

And three Council slots (we haven’t had all women).

Gadfly wants the best possible candidates. Plural. Choice.

Candidates probably have to formally declare by February or March 2021.

15-16 months away.

They will be thinking about it earlier. Maybe even now.

Gadfly knows that his followers are intelligent, thoughtful, concerned, connected — and ever-growing in number.

He would like to suggest that the gadfly blog is a good place for potential candidates to start sharing ideas and visions.

Pass the word.

City Council meeting tomorrow night Tuesday October 15

Our next City Council meeting — the ā€œfaceā€ of Bethlehem City government — occurs tomorrow night Tuesday, October 15, Town Hall, at 7PM.

This meeting is video-recorded and can be viewed LIVE or later at your convenience on the City’s website after the meeting at http://www.bethlehem-pa.gov > Quick Links > City Council Meeting Agendas and Documents.

The YouTube channel for live viewing is ā€œCity of Bethlehem Council.ā€

The City web site is inactive because the new version is still being aborn’d.

So find the agenda here: City Council Agenda 10 15 2019

Of interest to Gadfly followers will be a resolution to support plastic bag regulation. A post on this will follow.

As always, as long as he has flutter in his wings, Gadfly urges attending City Council live or virtually — one way or the other.

Why is it so difficult to get more trees put in along our streets?

ref: “At least a tree with each new build”

Kate:

We need someone to weigh in here who understands the ordinances about where and how trees can be planted near sidewalks, roads, and buildings in Bethlehem. As I was told by one local revitalization expert, there are pretty restrictive ordinances when it comes to trees (perhaps because of sidewalk heaving? Sewer lines? Other??). Are there any readers here who are familiar with these issues, who might help us understand perhaps why it is so difficult to get more trees put in along our streets in Bethlehem?

Kim Carrell-Smith

The City continues to install outmoded and dangerous curb ramps

Peter Crownfield is officially retired but spends most of his time working with students in his role as internship coordinator for theĀ Alliance for Sustainable Communities–Lehigh Valley.

Gadfly,

Last year the city contracted with someone to do new curb ramps on several 4th street intersections. Since then they’ve done lots of them on the north side.

Many of them (both on the north side and here on SouthSide) are the style that was common 30 years ago, where the ramps aim out into the intersection at a 45° angle. The preferred designs maintain a straight line of travel for people walking down the sidewalk or in a wheelchair. Steve Schmitt had called the problem to the city’s attention over 10 years ago and even gone out to specific intersections to show the right way. Last year, I contacted both the city and Senator Boscola’s office; Senator Boscola’s office even supplied PennDOT publications that pointed out the danger.

They are only supposed to depart from these designs when a physical obstacle makes it impossible. The 45° design is the least-preferred design, because it is more dangerous — not only does it make it more likely for a person in a wheelchair to roll into traffic, but it also allows people to flatten their turn and and run over the end of the ramp.

That’s the short version of why the Federal Highway Administration and PennDOT both point out the increased danger.

Why does the City continue to install these outmoded and dangerous curb ramps. Does the city that likes to think it’s “walkable” care so little about safety for pedestrians and people with disabilities? Apparently, they are incapable of learning from their mistakes.

Peter

Past climate change due to natural feedbacks

(The latest in a series of posts relating to the environment, Bethlehem’s Climate Action Plan, and Bethlehem’s Environmental Advisory Council)

Benjamin Felzer is an associate professor at Lehigh University in the Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences. Ben has expertise in climate and terrestrial ecosystem modeling, and his research focuses on biogeochemical cycling of carbon, nitrogen, and other substances between the land and atmosphere.

Gadfly:

The reason why the terminology changed from ā€œglobal warmingā€ to ā€œclimate changeā€ has nothing to do with the science. Rather, Republican pollster Frank Luntz, based on focus groups, determined that ā€œclimate changeā€ was less threatening politically than ā€œglobal warming.” What we are experiencing now is, in fact, global warming. That does not mean there is warming at every location on the earth or that every year is warmer than the preceding year (as there is interannual variability due to things like ENSO), but that on average, global temperatures over climatic timescales of 15-30 years or so continue to increase.

What past climate change tells us is that almost every major climate change in earth’s history is either caused by or amplified by changing levels of greenhouse gases (carbon dioxide or methane). When greenhouse gas levels go up, the world warms; when they go down, the world cools. Glacial/interglacial cycles were amplified by changing CO2 levels, the warm Eocene (55 million years ago) saw an outburst of methane, the warm Cretaceous (100 million years ago) had high CO2 levels, snowball earth was caused by fluctuating CO2, and even the early earth, when the sun was less bright than today, was warmed by high CO2 and methane levels. Obviously, in these cases, the elevated greenhouse gases were not caused by humans but by natural feedbacks. But we know what effect adding greenhouse gases has on the climate!Ā  And today it is humans who are adding these greenhouse gases to the atmosphere.

CO2 levels have fluctuated between 200 and 280 ppm between glacial/interglacial cycles over the last million years. In the year 1860, they were at 280 ppm. Today, they are at 400 ppm, and still rising. There is no question as to why they have risen – it is due to human activity that began with the Industrial Revolution – burning of fossil fuels (as well as cement production). There is also no question that based on current socioeconomic trends, CO2 levels will continue to increase, with reasonable projections above 700 ppm by the year 2100. So, we have not yet even doubled CO2 concentrations since 1860, but will surely do so in coming decades. Global temperatures have already risen 1oC, but with even greater increases in atmospheric CO2, they will rise even further (projected another 2-4oC by 2100).

It is so important to understand attribution – why climate changes at different times.Ā  The Little Ice age was a relatively minor cooling event that probably was due to an extended 80-year period without sunspots, known as the Maunder Minimum, as well as relatively larger number of volcanic eruptions. Changes in sunspots normally have very little effect on the climate as there is an 11-year sunspot cycle, so only when sunspots shut off for a century or so would they have a discernible effect on the climate. That is not the case now.Ā  Differences in radiation between maximum and minimum sunspots in the cycle are simply too small to account for the warming we have witnessed. In fact, while the lower part of the atmosphere, the troposphere, has warmed, the stratosphere has cooled. That is a unique greenhouse warming signature that would not have occurred if the warming were due to the sun, as greenhouse gases are essentially keeping the heat near the surface.

So, yes, climate has changed in the past.Ā  But we have a pretty good understanding of why past climate change occurred, and the larger ones all involved changing greenhouse gases due to natural feedbacks. Climate is changing now, and humans are the primary culprit. We know what we need to do in order to slow it down – reduce the amount of greenhouse gases we put into the atmosphere. How, or if, we choose to do so is up to us.

Ben

It’s Friday, September 27, do you know where your local Climate Action Plan is?

Festival UnBound
Ten days of original theatre, dance, music, art and conversation designed to celebrate and imagine our future together!
October 4-13

Required reading

Gadfly’s been off his game, off his beat the last day or two or three.

Maybe you’ve noticed.

Finding it almost impossible to focus on his little town of Bethlehem, his Norman Rockwell small town.

National doings of a momentous sort.

Like a toxic dust cloud approaching.

Perhaps — retired as he is — it’s harder for Gadfly to resist being locked in to the evolving news cycle than many of you.

Putting other life aside.

Gadfly has tried to avoid divisive national politics, focusing instead in these pages on local concerns where good conversation among people who, in a sense, know each other might help build community.

Focusing where we have more control, more ability to do tangible good of benefit to us all.

But we can’t ignore the toxic dust cloud approaching.

Gadfly sees his followers as thoughtful people who pay attention and make up their own minds.

And in Gadville we always go to the primary sources:

Trump-Ukraine Call Transcript

Whistleblower Complaint

Inspector General letter 1

Inspector General letter 2

Trump slams whistleblower at private event

Gadfly hopes you will take the time . . .

Non-profits vie for Wind Creek $$,$$$

Festival UnBound
Ten days of original theatre, dance, music, art and conversation designed to celebrate and imagine our future together!
October 4-13

(Latest posts in a series about Wind Creek Casino)

I may be wrong, but, if you wait a day in-between, it looks like you can vote more than once . . .

Jessica Johnson, “Vote now to pick which local nonprofit gets $25,000 in Wind Creek Bethlehem contest.” Morning Call, September 23, 2019.

Wind Creek Bethlehem is giving $25,000 to a local nonprofit organization as part of its grand opening ceremonies in October. The recipient will be chosen by a public vote today through Sept. 30, according to a news release from Wind Creek.The 10 organizations were picked based on previous partnerships and community relationships built over the last decade. They are:

ArtsQuest

Hispanic Center Lehigh Valley

Hogar Crea – Women’s Center

Junior League of the Lehigh Valley

St. Luke’s University Health Network

The Foundation For The Bethlehem Area School District

Turning Point Lehigh Valley

Via of the Lehigh Valley

Victory House of Lehigh Valley

YWCA Bethlehem

These local organizations were asked to submit a 30- to 60-second video showcasing their organization, who they are, what they do and how they would spend the money. Each video was posted in random order on Wind Creek Bethlehem’s official Facebook page Sept. 13-22.

The winner will be announced Oct. 10 during Wind Creek Bethlehem’s grand opening ceremonies.

To learn more, go to www.windcreekbethlehem.com/about-us/Giving-Back.html, or go to bit.ly/WCBCharityContest to view all the submissions and vote.

Wind Creek Bethlehem actively builds mutually beneficial partnerships with service organizations, non-profits, educational organizations, and similar groups within our service areas. We will consider ongoing funding as well as requests for projects and events that address people, community, and the earth in the community that we call home.

Festival UnBound

Festival Unbound is e-v-e-r-y-w-h-e-r-e!

(5th in a series of posts on Touchstone Theatre)

Who are we now that the Steel is gone?

Festival UnBound
Ten days of original theatre, dance, music, art and conversation designed to celebrate and imagine our future together!
October 4-13

Take a video tour of just a few of the festival sites!

But see below, you’ll find the Festival events all over town.

A few time slots still available.
Contact Gadfly if you want to book something for your front yard.

National Museum of Industrial History

The Greenway

Touchstone

BAPL

Charter Arts

Zoellner

Single Sisters’ House

PBS

Cafe the Lodge

Ice House

Sigal Museum

Miller Symphony Hall

Godfrey Daniels

Color Me Mine

Payrow Plaza

Festival UnBound

Keep the “flavor” of locally-focused retail

Festival UnBound
Ten days of original theatre, dance, music, art and conversation designed to celebrate and imagine our future together!
October 4-13

Although she’s lived in Bethlehem for almost 20 years, Carol Burns’ new career as a freelance marketer is giving her an opportunity to ā€œdiscoverā€ her hometown. She volunteers for several arts-related organizations, and her newest adventure is dipping her toe into local politics and community organizations.

Gadfly:

And these numbers just reflect the resident side — how about all the proposed new retail spots? Will they be affordable for local businesses — or will we see an influx of “name brand” companies that can afford the rent? To me — no pun intended — the “flavor” of Bethlehem retail is that it is so locally-focused. I’d hate to lose that.

Carol

Yes, note that the local “Factory” is planned for first-floor retail at the Polker.

 

Gadfly turns 1!

Born September 16, 2018, just at this time — 2PM

 

Definition of gadfly
1: any of various flies that annoy livestock

2: a person who stimulates other people especially by persistent criticism
3: someone who challenges people in positions of power

———–

1,032 posts and 365 days later.

The ceremonial time to touch base with the beginning, with the original purpose, with the original spirit.

A time to take stock.

What is Gadfly about?

That introduction is pretty pompous, pretty idealistic, but I still subscribe to its essence.

And won’t rewrite. In fact, you can’t rewrite what is in effect the creating moment.

At that creating moment you aren’t really in control, and you can’t re-live it.

I still believe that the fantasies we have shape the lives we lead.

Mine is a Norman Rockwell fantasy of Bethlehem as the small town embodied in the “Freedom of Speech” painting and Rockwell’s other works.

A place of good will, a place of mutual respect, a place where residents care and participate, a place where leaders listen as they lead.

I try to run Gadfly as an example of democracy in action, a place for healthy dialog about issues that concern our city.

I love your voices, as I have tried to show you time after time.

I’m not sure I’ll change anything of substance in the upcoming year.

But I would like to see some changes:

  • more original posts from you, the followers — not just comments on my posts or the posts of others, but thoughtful, original, chain-starting posts

 

  • and this might be a bridge too far in the trust that can be built in just a year, but posts from our elected officials and city administrators providing facts, trying out ideas, sharing visions, correcting misconceptions, combating ignorance — trusting the value of what we can never have too much of, good communication, good conversation

“Good conversation builds community.”

Ron Yoshida reports . . .

(7th in a series of posts on Ron Yoshida’s pilgrimage)

https://88-photos.com/

Yoshida 5

We followed Ron on his henro, now let’s hear him–

Ron library 1

Gadfly still has a “Ganbi” stickie on his bathroom mirror: keep trying.

ā€œPlease wear the clothes of the Buddha’s great compassion.ā€

Kukai (Kobo Daishi)

Buddha: ā€œI am the awakened one.ā€

Ā Ā https://88-photos.com/

Gadfly’s birthday list

In 10 days Gadfly will celebrate his first birthday.

Some of you may be scratching your heads or butts over an appropriate present.

At last Tuesday’s City Council meeting, Councilwoman Van Wirt spake sweet words that sounded to Gadfly’s ears like Marilyn Monroe singing “Happy Birthday, Mr. President” to JFKĀ and suggested the perfect gift.

Now you know what Gadfly wants for his birthday.

Gadfly, a simple man

The Community Action Development Corporation of Bethlehem (CADCB): Part 3

(Latest in a series of posts about Neighborhoods and the Southside)

Community Action Development Corporation of Bethlehem
409 East 4th Street, Bethlehem, PA 18015
Anna Smith, Director
http://cadcb.caclv.org/

ā€œEmpowering people and transforming South Bethlehemā€

Time for Gadfly to wrap up his reporting on the visit to Anna Smith to find out more about the little office on 4th St. with the big name of The Community Action Development Corporation of Bethlehem.

Sadly, as he told you earlier, he waited too long to begin posting, and the notes he took that day have gone cold.

But you can find a lot of information browsing through the CADCB web site.

For instance, the link to a 2017 Morning Call article by Nicole Radzievich contains specific examples of the kind of work with housing and specifically affordable housing that we have been concerned about in recent months here on Gadfly.

“How Bethlehem’s Hayes Street was rediscovered”

For instance, one man’s perspective:

The lively, blue-collar neighborhood that Raymond Richter remembers as a child is showing subtle signs of a return along south Bethlehem’s Hayes Street.

Preening alongside the tired brick facades of his hillside neighborhood are the strategic restorations of some early 20th century homes.

Asphalt siding on one twin has been stripped down to the original wood. Chipped gray paint on another brick home has been covered in a warm, red color, and flowers flow from boxes affixed underneath black-trimmed windows.

A festive mural sprawls on the side of a row home. On the corner, benches and trees fill what had been an empty corner lot, drawing residents out of their homes for breathtaking views of the architecturally lit blast furnaces below.

The recent improvements there recall the days when steelworkers would while away the evening on their porches, watching the headlights flicker up South Mountain. Neighborhood nuns and children would go toe-to-toe on the basketball court, and two shoemakers would compete for the soles of the Hungarian, Polish and Italian families who lived there.

After Bethlehem Steel’s decline and the passing of some old-timers, Richter said, many of the homes became rentals. Backyard grapevines and vegetable gardens gave way to weeds, and aging homes went unrepaired.

While redevelopment of the Bethlehem Steel plant has monopolized the city’s attention for decades, he said, it’s heart-warming to watch as his neighborhood also gets rediscovered.

Think of this the next time you ride up or down Hayes Street.

The Community Action Development Corporation of Bethlehem — an organization doing great work for “us.”

CADCB: ā€œEmpowering people and transforming South Bethlehemā€

An example of good Zoning Board action

(The latest in a series of posts on City government)

Al Bernotas is a 36-year resident of Bethlehem, somewhat of a law and order zoning wonk, with many years fighting a ruling by the Zoning Hearing Board, only to find out that they had discretion to do whatever they want to do. So said the Commonwealth Court, with the Supreme Court of the State of Pennsylvania turning down a request to hear the case. Now he just spends much of his time mowing his lawn, while watching tractor-trailers mosey on down the residential street whereupon he lives, Johnston Drive. In his spare time he is a Medicare Advisor, Census Bureau Enumerator, and Landscape Specialist, and All-around Handyman. Or, some other folks would call him a know-it-all.

Gadfly:

My experience with the zoning hearing board shows me that, in the past, they would stretch every zoning ordinance, and word within, to accommodate the appellant, often to the detriment of a neighborhood or a neighbor. Below, is a summary of a zoning case which I feel sets a good example of how to work with the zoning code. Hopefully, Bethlehem’s current Zoning Hearing Board is more inclined to work within the letter and spirit of the law.

***
NY Appellate Court Upholds Zoning Board’s Denial of Application to Change Nonconforming Use to Another Nonconforming Use and for Area Variance
by Patricia Salkin

Petitioner purchased real property in December 2013 on which a gas station and auto repair shop were operated as a legal nonconforming use. In May 2015, the petitioner sought approval to renovate the gas station and convert the auto repair shop to a convenience store. The application was denied and petitioner applied to the Board of Appeals for permission to change the preexisting nonconforming use to another nonconforming use. The petitioner also sought an area variance in connection with the placement of the convenience store’s solid waste disposal unit. Following a hearing the Board denied the application. The petitioner appealed and the Supreme Court granted the petition, annulled the determination, and, in effect, directed the Board to grant the petitioner’s application. The Board appealed.

The appellate court reversed, noting that ā€œbecause nonconforming uses are viewed as detrimental to a zoning scheme, the overriding public policy is aimed at their reasonable restriction and eventual elimination…courts will enforce a municipality’s reasonable circumscription of the right to expand the volume or intensity of a prior nonconforming use.ā€ The Court explained that the City code provides that a nonconforming use ā€œmay be changed to another nonconforming use … based upon a finding that the proposed use is more consistent with the character of the surrounding neighborhood and having less adverse impacts.ā€ Here the Board determined that the change from a gas station and auto repair shop to a gas station and convenience store would have an adverse impact upon traffic. The Appelllate Court said that the Board’s determination was not irrational and was supported by evidence in the record, and that the denial of the petitioner’s application for the change of nonconforming use rendered the petitioner’s application for an area variance academic.

Nabe v Sosis, 2019 WL 3679336 (NYAD 2 Dept. 8/7/2019)

Al

Grace Crampsie Smith: One step closer

(The latest in a series of posts on City government)

Grace Crampsie Smith 2

Morning Call photo

Smith is on the verge! Let’s welcome her. If you browse through “candidates for election” under Topics on the Gadfly sidebar, you will find abundant statements by her. One of Gadfly’s goals is to help you know your Councilpersons.

Nicole Radzievich, “Bethlehem City Council picks unopposed candidate Grace Crampsie Smith to fill vacant seat.” Morning Call, August 20, 2019.

Democrat Grace Crampsie Smith, who is running unopposed this fall for Bethlehem City Council, will be sworn into her seat on council early.

She was unanimously picked Tuesday by City Council to fill out the final four months of the term of freshman Councilman Shawn Martell, a Democrat who resigned this month for personal reasons. She is unopposed on the November ballot for a two-year term, which would start in January.

Smith is expected to be sworn into office next month.

After Tuesday’s vote, Smith said in an interview that she was honored and humbled by the support she received during the campaign and by council’s appointment. She said she appreciated the ability to join council in time to be part of vetting Mayor Robert Donchez’s budget proposal for next year.

Smith, a school counselor, holds a master’s degree in education and school counseling from Lehigh University and a bachelor’s degree in sociology and social welfare from Bloomsburg University.

She was a member of the adjunct faculty at Lehigh Carbon Community College and also worked as an addictions counselor and coordinator of community and early intervention services for the office of Lehigh County Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities. She completed the Bethlehem Police Citizens Academy. And has participated in several political groups including the Northampton County Democratic Committee, Lehigh Valley Democratic Progressive Coalition, Lehigh Valley ROAR and Lehigh Valley for All.

Charter schools: “The system must be changed”

(26th in a series on Education and Charter Schools)

Another good article in the string of thought-provoking pieces on charter schools, which we have been following because of their impact not only on the quality of education for our kids but also the budget strain from what seems to be an unfair system.

Pressure on legislators is needed.

See that great community organization BASD Proud Parents on this issue too.

Paul Muschick, “Why we should blow up Pennsylvania charter school system and start over.” Morning Call, August 18, 2019.

The proposal from Gov. Tom Wolf on Tuesday to overhaul the state’s charter school system is aggressive, welcome and long overdue.

The current system is unsustainable. School districts are paying too much money — $1.8 billion statewide last year — and those figures are only going to increase. Allentown’s costs have doubled to $60 million, 20% of its budget, in just five years.

And that money is going to charter schools that are public schools in name only, in many ways.

They don’t have the same level of accountability and transparency as school districts. It’s hard to consider them truly public if they aren’t held to the same standards, such as publicly bidding major expenses, releasing details of every dollar spent and answering to a local, publicly elected school board.

Wolf’s heart is in the right place. But I fear this may be just another example of him banging his head against the Republican wall in the Legislature, similar to his attempts to levy a severance tax on natural gas mining.

His administration can impose some changes on charter schools. But the biggest need — changing funding formulas — requires legislative action. And Republicans are the party of school choice.

Democratic Auditor General Eugene DePasquale has been calling for changes to the charter school law for years and the Legislature hasn’t listened. Let’s see if the governor has any more pull.

Those discussions should start with revising the faulty thinking of a student’s per capita funding ā€œfollowing themā€ from their school district to a charter school.

It doesn’t always cost charter schools, especially cyber charters, that much to educate the same student. And districts don’t see an accompanying dollar-for-dollar reduction in their costs.

Unless an entire classroom of students at the same grade level moves to a charter, a district can’t cut the expenses, including the teacher’s salary, that go with that classroom. State officials need to come up with a better formula.

Cyber charters especially make out under that formula now. They collect the same tuition rate as traditional charter schools but have substantially lower costs. Taxpayers are overpaying more than $250 million annually, according to a February study by Education Voters of Pennsylvania, a project of the left-leaning Keystone Research Center.

I have a few suggestions in addition to Wolf’s recommendations:

* Reimburse districts for some charter tuition costs.

* Don’t require school districts to pay tuition for private school students or home-schooled students who move to charter schools.

There is a place for charter schools. But if they are going to be publicly funded, they must operate under the same rules as traditional public schools, and be funded realistically.

The system must be changed to make that happen.

City Council meeting tomorrow Tuesday August 20

Our next City Council meeting, the “face” of Bethlehem City government, occurs Tuesday, August 20, Town Hall. at 7PM.

This meeting is video-recorded and can be viewed LIVE or at your convenience on the City’s website after the meeting at http://www.bethlehem-pa.gov > Quick Links > City Council Meeting Agendas and Documents.

Gadfly urges attending, one way or the other.

You can find the meeting agenda here: https://www.bethlehem-pa.gov/citycouncil/meetings/archive/2019/Background/20190820/00%20Agenda%2008202019.pdf

Of interest:

  • looks like appt of Grace Crampsie Smith to fill the vacancy on City Council
  • two Zoning Board members are up for appt, and you know how important these positions are (Gadfly will be posting on one of the appts tomorrow).
  • It’s possible the Parking Authority will be present for Polk Street Garage discussionĀ  and the fine structure decision.

Be involved, quoth the Gadfly.

Other residents testifying against Bethlehem Manor

(Latest in a series of posts on Bethlehem Manor and Neighborhoods)

In addition to Brian Nicas, three other residents testified against the Bethlehem Manor proposal.

They represent an interesting range of approaches.

022Elaine Torres — whose house is in the Manor’s “backyard” — carrying the dog of her deceased mother — not in the best of health — brought an emotional storm to the proceedings, chastising the Bethlehem Manor team for unresolved operational issues — like mosquitoes from the “rain gardens” that made it hard to work in her yard — literally, vigorously calling out the architect. She had to be soft-gaveled back to decorum twice or thrice by the chair. Gadfly would not recommend a heavy diet of such resident testimony at proceedings such as this, but, on the other hand, he must admit that this spectacle of raw anger and anxiety — so different from the conduct of the other proposal critics — starkly reminded him that these proceedings were not just a paper exercise performed by slickly dressed lawyers.

Bill Scheirer — better known as Gadfly #2 — spoke with his 029
signature compelling softness, and spoke directly to the Board, making a meaningful distinction aimed at the wonks on the Board. Adaptive reuse of a surplus school is one thing, said this cool customer, but the Bethlehem Manor proposal is entirely different. It is expansion not adaptive re-use. Leave it to Gadfly-deuce to make sure the argument was framed properly.

It was Anne Lendzinski whom Gadfly thought asked the two most pertinent and incisive questions of the night:

  • “You were already the Administrator at Saucon Valley and at Whitehall, so I don’t understand how can you not project the need for private rooms if you were already building on your other building for private room demand.”
  • “This is a huge expanse. There are already engineering issues that have not been resolved, so why this expansion when those existing issues are not fixed yet?”

010In her first question, Anne struck deep at the heart of a damning inconsistency. How could an accomplished and experienced personal care home Administrator not have been thinking about the move to private rooms from the get-go? The question undercut the narrative — the origin myth, if you will — that Bethlehem Manor was positing.

To her credit, the Administrator had a good come-back — she was working, she said, from the pervasive model in this Rosemont neighborhood exemplified, for instance in Holy Family Manor — but for Gadfly the question itself was telling in his own decision-making.

The second question — tapping the network of troublesome details of the Bethlehem Manor operation — just seemed to call attention to the fact that Bethlehem Manor was not the squeaky clean good neighbor it proclaimed itself to be and thus had not earned this vote of confidence from the neighborhood.

Gadfly looks back on the short Anne-Administrator dialogue here as a turning point for him.

Sharing your reading: inclusionary zoning

(Latest in a series of posts about affordable housing)
(also 3rd in a series about sharing your reading)

Jeff Speck, “Pass a mandatory Inclusionary Zoning ordinance”
(Walkable City Rules, 2018)

Gadfly had never heard the term “inclusionary zoning” before reading Speck. Maybe we already have it. He doesn’t know. But the term felt new and got him thinking about this subject of affordable housing that we have been following lately.

(Speck, by the way, gifted Gadfly another new term worth incorporating into your wordbank: “attainable housing.” For Gadfly, it adds a layer of meaning to “affordable.” Try it on.)

Gadfly probably doesn’t have to tell you that he can be a drama king. If you need a reminder, go to his “A Plea for Affordable Housing,” the post that started this thread back in June.

At least take 70 seconds and listen again to the guy who somberly ended the parade of resident speakers at the Nitschmann meeting on the Martin Tower demolition.

Gadfly will never forget that quiet, unassuming guy and his moving simplicity. Pleas for help like this — and the South Bethlehem Historical Society letter — are like those sticky wall balls thrown at Gadfly’s mind.

Here’s Gadfly in full drama mode:

Let’s keep that muffled elderly voice and the vigorous chorus of audience support in mind as we think about what the City can do to remedy the lack of affordable housing.

There is a problem, and ā€œweā€ know in our guts something has to be done about it.

Martin Tower, 548 apartments proposed (or is it 528? or 598? The mind boggles). The Boyd Theater, 120. Skyline West, 50.

How many of these housing units will be affordable, attainable?

Enter “inclusionary zoning.”

Speck:

What are you reading these days? How about sharing with us? Gadfly invites you to share a few clips of your readingĀ  — with or without comment — or a few thoughts from your reading pertinent to the Gadfly project of the good conversation about Bethlehem that builds community.

Bethlehem’s Climate Action Plan on the move

(The latest in a series of posts relating to the environment, Bethlehem’s Climate Action Plan, and Bethlehem’s Environmental Advisory Council)

ā€œThere is no reason why good cannot triumph as often as evil.
The triumph of anything is a matter of organization.ā€
(Kurt Vonnegut)

Councilman Reynolds has been the main driver in the formation of a local Climate Action Plan, dating back to his “Bethlehem 2017” report, which can be found linked on the Gadfly sidebar.

Here we are two years later, and Gadfly was pleased to attend the Environmental Advisory Council (EAC) meeting last night at Illick’s Mill at which members discussed proposals from four organizations to write a plan for the City.

The EAC is chaired by Lynn Rothman, and the members are Elizabeth Behrend, Elisabeth Cichonski, Kathy Fox, Brian Hillard, Brian Nicas, and Mike Topping. Nine other members of the public were also present.

As explained by chair Rothman, the EAC had input into the call for proposals and now was invited to make recommendations before the City made the final decision and awarded a contract to one of the bidders. The City has allocated funds for the project to begin this year, and it sounded to Gadfly that the project would take about a year to complete.

Next year we could have a Climate Action Plan!

Each of the four proposals was lengthy and densely packed with information. EAC members reviewed them beforehand and discussed them one-by-one at the meeting.

Gadfly is always proudly pleased to show our non-tax dollars profitably at work. Here to give you a taste of the meeting is the final section in which Council members ranked the proposals for their recommendation to the City. Most interesting in the later portion of this clip is a discussion of attention to underserved populations.

Nicely done!

It’s Friday, August 9, do you know where your local Climate Action Plan is?

Early time for City Council meeting tomorrow Tuesday August 6

Our City Council meeting, the “face” of Bethlehem City government, occurs Tuesday, August 6, Town Hall. at 5:30PM.

An earlier time because of Musikfest.

This meeting is video-recorded and can be viewed LIVE or at your convenience on the City’s website after the meeting at http://www.bethlehem-pa.gov > Quick Links > City Council Meeting Agendas and Documents.

Gadfly urges attending.

You can find the agenda here: https://www.bethlehem-pa.gov/citycouncil/meetings/archive/2019/Agenda/00%20Agenda%2008062019.pdf

Agendas never tell the full story.

It looks like Council will discuss replacing Councilman Shawn Martell who is resigning as of August 19.

And we should be looking for the Parking Authority to come back either this meeting or the next to finalize a new Polk Street Garage.

Be involved, quoth the Gadfly.