Chief DiLuzio: “Right now there is a message to be heard”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

DiLuzio 1photo by Kurt Bresswein, lehighvalleylive.com

from Tony Rhodin, “Local police chief on protests: ’Our community wants to be heard. It was important for us to be there’.” lehighvalleylive.com, June 3, 2020.

Bethlehem police Chief Mark DiLuzio said President Trump wasn’t thinking about cities like these when he insisted on violence being crushed by military intervention.

Protests happen during the day, DiLuzio said. Riots and looting happen at night, he said.

“It’s a day-night thing,” he said, adding that Bethlehem’s protest was during the day.

His city often faces protests during Musikfest and other big events. They are mostly nonviolent and people “get their message out,” DiLuzio said.

But if they were do ever go sideways, city police are prepared, he said.

“If any violence does occur, we would squash that immediately,” he said.

But none of the past week’s events had to happen, he said.

DiLuzio was “horrified” when he first saw the video of Derek Chauvin with his knee of Floyd’s neck.

“You know what I see there?” DiLuzio said of the video. “Four police officers with no direction or training.”

It often happens in departments with financial constrains, he said. The first thing to get cut is training, he said.

“They were not following training, policies or doing what they’re supposed to do,” DiLuzio said.

“… Police have done a lot of great things in this country. This just put us back 25 years. It makes us look like prehistoric Neanderthals out there.”

“He could have done a very simple thing,” DiLuzio said of Chauvin. “When the guy said he couldn’t breathe, he takes his knee off of him.”

That one little, monumental thing and there’s no rioting. “That would have ended it right there,” DiLuzio said.

But Chauvin continued as Floyd died, authorities say. And that in no way absolves the other three officers there, DiLuzio said, calling their inaction an act of omission.

“Not doing anything is a crime too,” DiLuzio said. “I wouldn’t blame the AG’s office for charging them. I think it would be appropriate.”

But, as with Grantiz [the Allentown chief], Diluzio said the protests were a chance to listen.

“Right now there is a message to be heard and it’s shouldn’t be forgotten,” he said. “We need to update our systems, our training, the way police operate. It’s something that hasn’t been done” across the country.

The Mayor’s statement in the Morning Call

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

Donchez 1photo Donna Fisher, Morning Call

Robert Donchez, “Your View by Bethlehem’s mayor: ‘This isn’t a race issue, this is a human issue’.” Morning Call, June 3, 2020.

The Mayor’s statement on the George Floyd killing posted on the City web site a few days ago appeared in the Morning Call and on WFMZ today.

Today’s statement is the same as the original on the web site except that a quote from John F. Kennedy replaces one from Ben Franklin toward the end of the essay:

“John F. Kennedy once said, ‘The hottest places in hell are reserved for those who in times of great moral crisis, maintain their neutrality.’ This is indeed a time of great moral crisis, and we can no longer say it doesn’t affect me — because it does.”

Questioning the Mayor’s statement

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

John Rothschild is a family law attorney residing in Bethlehem who graduated from Lehigh.

Breena,

I am embarrassed that I did not comment sooner. I agree with everything you mentioned, although I think even less of the Mayor’s “powerful statement.” “That all men are created equal?” Women, people of different colors, and more? What about them? Grieving as a nation and standing together? Whom are you kidding?

And Mayor Donchez’s reference to a past south Bethlehem somewhere in Nirvana without racism, bigotry, or intolerance. What?? And speaking of Allen High School, when was Transgender even recognized?

And the George Floyd is just a race issue that includes a police issue where some police seem to have no fear of reprisal. One does not need to ignore the human issue, but make no mistake, this is a race issue.

Why does the Mayor quote someone who dares to believe what Jesus would teach if He could teach only one thing? And the Mayor’s preface, “This is not the time . . .” Just when is the time?

Just reread Breena Holland’s post. She was very eloquent.

“Racism exists because it is enabled by white silence”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

Michele Downing is a Social Worker and RN, a grandmother of two, interested in social and environmental justice, a resident of the Lehigh Valley for fifteen years, the last six years a resident of West Bethlehem.

Thank you [Breena Holland] for this thoughtful reply which echoes most of my same concerns with the Mayor’s letter.

It continues to be normalized in city government to drown out black and brown voices and centering only the white experiences.

We have an obligation to black and brown neighbors to learn the skills to avoid doing that.

A strong example in leadership would be helpful, and there are a number of community leaders who would willingly step up and do that if we got out of the way.

Racism exists because it is enabled by white silence.

Michele Downing

The current crisis presents the Mayor and Police Chief with a great opportunity to do more

logoLatest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

Peter Crownfield is officially retired but spends most of his time working with students in his role as internship coordinator for the Alliance for Sustainable Communities–Lehigh Valley.

Very well put, Breena!

I am very glad that the Bethlehem Police Department modeled a calm attitude and, for the most part, ensured that protesters could have their say. However, that is not enough.

The current crisis presented a great opportunity for both the Mayor and the Police Chief to note that Bethlehem does have some racial problems and that they are not new — and to describe what they have done to improve policing and city efforts. Both the Mayor and the Police Chief could have referred to the incidents you mentioned and earlier incidents described back in 2018, when Bethlehem held a forum on racial justice. After the pleasant, reassuring words from the panelists, several members of the audience described several incidents of racial profiling and worse. At that time, both the mayor and the police chief seemed very surprised to learn this was going on. (‘Bethlehem forum on race calls for training, respect’, Express-Times, 23 August 2018).

If you want a ‘powerful statement’, I recommend Tamika Mallory’s statement in Minneapolis! The following link begins with her statement and also includes a deeper interview. [www.youtube.com/watch?v=VI7uvc8-e7g]

Peter

Hard questions for the Mayor and Chief of Police — need for actions not just words

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

Breena Holland is an Associate Professor at Lehigh University in the Department of Political Science and the Environmental Initiative. She is a past director of Lehigh University’s South Side Initiative.

Gadfly,

With all due respect to Mayor Donchez, I do not share your enthusiasm for his “powerful statement.” Powerful words are easy to come by this week, as many leaders are speaking out about racial justice and police violence. The mayor did not use these particular words, which reflect that the relevant problem is bigger than just some cops behaving badly. But even so, the words the mayor did use are not that meaningful unless they get turned into action that goes beyond condemning a single instance of police violence. So my question for the mayor is: What does it mean for a mayor and the people he oversees to not “turn our backs on racism,” to not “accept innocent lives being taken from us,” to not “think that you can’t be part of the solution and the change needed for this to stop”? Surely it must mean more than merely saying we should not do these things.

I believe the mayor can do a bit more. For example, the mayor can start by admitting that the problem is not out there, in some universe other than Bethlehem. Just earlier this year we had an incidence of racial bias in policing, which was raised by two local judges who went public with the information after receiving no response from the chief of police. In his response, the mayor demonstrated he neither understood nor had an interest in doing something about the problem. I recall his statement at city council, which asserted he had investigated the issue and found no problematic behavior, so he would not be commenting on it further—case closed.

Does the mayor really think there are no problems with how our police department is dealing with people of color? What is he doing to stop the double standard that allows Lehigh University students to benefit from the local marijuana ordinance while his police department pretends the ordinance does not exist for others who are found with marijuana? What is he doing to make sure that the police department is not operating and acting on the assumption that black and brown people are likely to be criminals? Is he aware of obvious racial bias in the ways that city police officers respond to and interact with people of color whom they suspect are breaking the law?

The Bethlehem police may not be killing people, but that does not mean that they treat black and brown people the same way they treat white people. Racism that is not overt and does not result in a person’s death is still racism. The mayor and police chief can pretend it does not exist locally and condemn what happened to George Floyd for the brutal inhumanity it displayed, but if that is all they do, then they are part of the problem.

Leadership requires hearing what people are saying about double standards and unequal treatment that operate through our own political institutions at the local level to undermine the experience, well-being, and security of people of color. Once this is understood, leadership then involves doing something about it. If the mayor and police chief can’t even see the structural nature of the problem and its pervasiveness right here at home, then they are the wrong leaders for this time.

Breena

Protest participant: “To be a part of the future, you need to be a part of the solution”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

“We are one”
See the Mayor’s powerful statement about community.

protest 10

photo by Tom Shortell, Morning Call

from Tom Shortell, “Voices from the weekend’s protests: Hundreds in Lehigh Valley speak up against police brutality.” Morning Call, May 31, 2020.

Two enormous crowds marched through Allentown and Bethlehem Saturday afternoon, joining a growing list of cities where citizens demonstrated their outrage against police brutality and the death of Minneapolis man George Floyd.

The Lehigh Valley’s protests drew a diverse group — locals and people from out of state, ranging in age from toddlers to senior citizens. Racial identities were widespread as well; a majority of protesters in Bethlehem appeared to be white while Allentown’s was predominantly people of color.

The roof of the champagne-colored BMW buckled but held as Jerome Wilson danced on it in front of Bethlehem’s Payrow Plaza. He and his friends had driven the car from Newark and leaned on the horn as they escorted a river of protesters between Rose Garden Park and City Hall. Wilson previously lived in Bethlehem for a year, but he hadn’t seen it like this.

“Everybody’s here,” he said between jubilant fist bumps with protesters. “White people. Black people. Hispanics. Chinese. Muslims.”

Wilson said people are protesting after growing tired of a corrupt system. Too many black people are set up to fail in the justice system, he said, noting he first found himself in front of a judge in seventh grade. He’s lost count of how many friends are in prison. But while he fed off the energy of the crowd’s chanting vulgarities about police, it did nothing to settle his raw emotions.

“For every one of ours they’ve taken, I want to take two of theirs,” he said.

Moments later, a protester fell to the ground after being hit by a slow-moving vehicle trying to pass through the throngs. Wilson and some friends charged toward the driver, but others jumped in between. It was an honest accident; The driver stopped and apologized, witnesses said. Wilson bounded away, back into the crowd.

Joanne Garcia walked along the fringes of the crowd at Rose Garden Park. As protesters chanted “No justice, no peace,” her 2-year-old son casually eyed the swarm of humanity from his stroller.

As a Latina, Garcia said, interactions with police are a concern routinely weighing on the back of her mind even though she’s never had any problems. But although she’s watched news cycles of minorities dying in police custody for years, she had not joined any protests before. She couldn’t explain why Floyd’s death compelled her when others had not but suspected it could be the little boy content to munch on graham crackers.

In a video of his final moments widely circulated online, the 46-year-old Floyd called out for his mother. She had died two years earlier.

“To be a part of the future, you need to be a part of the solution,” Garcia said as she pushed her baby buggy across Broad Street.

Chief DiLuzio: “That’s the way protests should be”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

“We are one”
See the Mayor’s powerful statement about community.

Protest 9

photo Amy Shortell, Morning Call
click on this photo in the article linked below for several dozen Bethlehem photos

from Jennifer Sheehan,”‘People felt like they were heard’: Why Lehigh Valley’s demonstrations remained peaceful.” Morning Call, May 31, 2020.

Despite more than 700 people taking to the streets of Allentown and Bethlehem on Saturday to protest the death of George Floyd, no one was arrested and no significant property damage was reported, police said.

Protests in the Lehigh Valley were different because they stayed focused on the death of George Floyd, Bethlehem police Chief Mark DiLuzio said. Floyd, who was black, died after being pinned for more than eight minutes with a white officer’s knee on his neck in Minnesota.

“The difference was I think the people here were trying to get to the issue at hand,” DiLuzio said. “In smaller cities, you have people who are truly interested in the death of George Floyd. In the bigger cities, you have that interest but you also have other people who come into the situation and look for free stuff through looting.”

DiLuzio estimated about 500 protesters marched through Bethlehem on Saturday afternoon although protesters had higher estimates.

“They got their message out there and that’s their constitutional right,” DiLuzio said. “We wanted to make sure they were able to do that.”

DiLuzio was on hand during the protest and said it was very orderly.

“That’s the way protests should be,” he said.

One of the local groups that organized Saturday’s rally in Bethlehem was Lehigh Valley Stands Up, a nonprofit pushing for progressive change. Ashleigh Strange, who heads the group, said Sunday that they worked hard to makes sure voices were heard and that the event was peaceful.

Another factor that helped, Strange said, was that Bethlehem police were not in riot gear.

“On their part, they did not escalate,” Strange said. “And we did not escalate because that was not the point.”

She also said they had people who put themselves between police and protesters who were shouting at officers.

“The march was there so people could be heard,” Strange said. “This was the place where they needed to express their anger. People were not there to destroy property. They were there to be heard. And because they felt like they were heard they didn’t need to destroy property.”

DiLuzio said he was horrified after learning of how Floyd died.

“No time in the 40 years I’ve been a police officer have I ever been trained to, or heard of kneeling on someone’s throat as proper police procedure,” DiLuzio said. “The first thing I said when I saw the video was, ‘This is horrible and this is wrong.’ I don’t know any cops who have said that that cop was justified. This is something that the police and protesters can agree on. That picture is a bad image for American law enforcement.”

Mayor Donchez: “We in Bethlehem must condemn acts of violence and hatred”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

“My comments on Minneapolis”
Sunday, May 31, 2020


Almost 250 years ago, Thomas Jefferson, declared, “That all men are created equal.” Our nation has had a long and difficult history dealing with those simple and profound words. Since 1776 it has taken numerous conflicts and much bloodshed for us to live up to those words. And yet, have we? Once again, we are grieving as a nation and standing together to condemn the shocking violence in Minneapolis and the innocent loss of life, and those simple words of Thomas Jefferson, somehow got lost in translation or understanding.

I grew up in South Bethlehem. The words “all men are created equal” were words to live by in my neighborhood and in my world. We were a melting pot, a cauldron of hope where there was no room for racism, bigotry, and intolerance. We had our differences – culturally, linguistically, racially and religiously, and yet we were a community. When we had to, we locked arms across the many lines and boundaries of our differences and dedicated ourselves to unity. Because of that, we were able to achieve some early measure of social and economic justice and equality for many in our community.

Those lessons of social and economic justice and equality traveled with me and were a daily part of my 35 years as a teacher at Allen High School in Allentown. I made sure my students were tolerant of all who attended Allen High School – Black and White, Latino and Asian, Gay and Straight, Male, Female and Transgender, Rich and Poor, and all who made up the city, the Lehigh Valley and the country.

As the son of a police officer and as a Mayor, watching the images from Minneapolis have been tough. I have great respect and admiration for our police officers, so it was very emotional watching that Minneapolis police officer suffocate handcuffed George Floyd with a knee to his neck. I know that almost all police officers adhere to the law and would never hurt someone like that, and yet this behavior continues and it hurts – it hurts the police and it hurts every one of us.

The kind of behavior we have seen in Minneapolis has no place in America or anywhere in the world. We in Bethlehem must condemn acts of violence and hatred, and are deeply saddened by the loss of life of a fellow human being. This is not just a race issue, this is a human issue, and we are all connected by our shared human experience.

Max Lucado wrote, “If Jesus could teach us only one thing, it would be that a person has value simply because they are a person.”

This is not the time to pretend that there’s not a problem in America.

This is not the time to turn our backs on racism.

This is not the time to accept innocent lives being taken from us.

This is not the time to think this doesn’t affect you.

This is not the time to sit back and say nothing.

This is not the time to think that you can’t be part of the solution and the change needed for this to stop.

Benjamin Franklin said, “Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.”

This is a time for outrage, but it is not a time for violence. The hatred that comes with racism, bigotry, and intolerance will not be condoned or supported here in Bethlehem or anywhere else for that matter. We are one. Our anger and abhorrence must be converted to something more positive – to hope, to faith and to love.

To quote Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, “Darkness cannot drive out darkness, only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate, only love can do that.”

Mayor Bob Donchez

“I have been silent for too long”

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

Peter Crownfield is officially retired but spends most of his time working with students in his role as internship coordinator for the Alliance for Sustainable Communities–Lehigh Valley.

Gadfly — Jason Schiffer (former chief of Bethlehem city PD and now chief of Lehigh U PD) had an excellent commentary on what we’re seeing across the country:

I am so saddened and sickened by the murder of George Floyd at the hands of the police. This type of treatment of another human being can never be justified and can never be accepted. (1/x)

We cannot just go on with our lives now that the criminal responsible for his death has been arrested. That is not enough. As Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said in 1967, “a time comes when silence is betrayal.” (2/x)

I have been silent for too long. Either we take action against racist behavior, or we condone it. There can be no middle ground. (3/x)

The former officers who were on scene also had their knees on George’s neck. Every one of them bears the full responsibility of his death. (4/x)

They all had the power and the ability to do the right thing and they chose to condone his murder. It doesn’t matter that their police training taught all of them that restraining a person in that manner is both dangerous and against policy. (5/x)

It should not take a policy to teach the police to treat another human being with dignity and respect. If you are a police officer and have to be trained and taught to respect human life above all things, please turn in your badge. You are the problem. (6/x)

You are the reason for the civil unrest in this country. The people have had enough of being bullied, of being treated with disrespect,and of being murdered by the state. I am so sick of hearing “what about black on black crime?”. There is no comparison. (7/x)

When a police officer uses force against a citizen, that is the force of the state and the people must demand that the state not violate their rights. It is the very least that someone should demand from their government. (8/x)

I have taken some solace in the number of police officials who have been outspoken over the murder of George Floyd. We have been silent far too long. Our “silence has been betrayal.”

No more. (9/9)

Peter

Bethlehem Saturday demonstration peaceful but angry

logo Latest in a series of posts on the George Floyd killing logo

protest 2

photo by Dana Grubb

from Kurt Bresswein, “Hundreds pack together for Bethlehem protest against police brutality.” lehighvalleylive.com, May 30, 2020.

Chants of “Black lives matter” and “No justice, no peace” carried through Bethlehem streets Saturday as hundreds of people packed together in solidarity to protest police brutality against people of color.

The group gathered at 3 p.m. at the Bethlehem Rose Garden on the Lehigh County side of the city, then marched east on Broad Street to Payrow Plaza between City Hall and the public library.

Rallies at both ends bookended the march, which shut down intersections as it passed. At City Hall, protesters blocked New and Church streets so no traffic — a LANTA bus included for a time — could pass.

Eventually, city police who have their headquarters in the City Hall basement responded to block off intersections around the rally and help motorists stuck in the jam.

“I know this is really risky during a pandemic, but I’m willing to take that risk to put this important message and these important people out there because of what’s going on, because this has been going on for so long and it just has to stop,” organizer Matty Fall told lehighvalleylive.com. “I feel I have an obligation to step up and say something.”

Saturday’s protest came together in one day, after Fall woke up Friday and knew she had to take action, she said. Her friend Michael Henriquez created a flier that organizers posted around Bethlehem and shared on social media. Helping to spread the word were grassroots groups with local members, like POWER Lehigh Valley, Make the Road PA, Lehigh Valley Stands Up, Lehigh Valley Democratic Socialists of America and Lehigh Valley Anarchists.

Participants were urged to socially distance themselves and wear masks. Many, but not all, complied as they crammed elbow to elbow for the rallies and march. Some brought children, some brought dogs. Many carried protest signs decrying police brutality and urging remembrance of Floyd and a host others before him who have been killed.

“We’re not trying to do anything violent,” Fall said. “We’re not trying to invoke any kind of violence. We don’t condone it at all.”

“We’re really just trying to get the message across that this can’t keep happening,” she continued. “We don’t want this to happen here or anywhere for that matter.”

Fall is a 2017 graduate of Liberty High School who earned an associate’s degree in criminal justice from Northampton Community College and is now studying criminal justice management at John Jay College of Criminal Justice in New York City with plans to attend law school.

from Tom Shortell, “Bethlehem, Allentown protests against Minneapolis police killing of George Floyd draw hundreds of peaceful demonstrators.” Morning Call, May 30, 2020.

The spark that ignited outrage over the police killing of an unarmed black man in Minneapolis on Memorial Day reached the Lehigh Valley on Saturday, with demonstrators in Bethlehem’s Rose Garden and downtown Allentown demanding an end to police brutality.

Speakers called on the community to demand justice and changes in the way police interact with people of color. They also told the audience to use the ballot box to effect change.

“We don’t just want you to vote,” said one. “We want you to get angry and vote out all the people who don’t care about us.”

Rafia Sayed of Easton marveled at the turnout as she and friends marched across the Broad Street Bridge in Bethlehem in a crowd that stretched for three blocks. The protest was her first, but she felt compelled to attend after watching another high-profile video of a black man dying in police custody.

“It’s like all Bethlehem showed up,” she said.

The Bethlehem rally was organized by POWER Lehigh Valley, Make the Road PA, Lehigh Valley Stands Up, Lehigh Valley Democratic Socialists of America and Lehigh Valley Anarchists.

Around 4 p.m., the crowd entered Payrow Plaza by City Hall, to the sounds of cheers and honking horns. All along the way, police were out of sight, giving the protesters a wide berth. But at City Hall, police were present and silent, even as some hurled insults at them. Organizers lined up as a barricade between police and protesters, keeping the protest peaceful even as it was angry.