Thinking outside the box about a Public Safety Meeting

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

What’s the best way to have this meeting?
Councilman Colon, Chair of the Public Safety Committee

Councilman Colon, chair of the Public Safety Committee, spoke from inside a box at the July 7 City Council meeting.

George Floyd died May 25. Chief DiLuzio made his “George Floyd’s Death & Policing in America” statement to Council June 3.  The first local demonstration was held June 4. Councilman Reynolds and Councilwoman Crampsie Smith sent their “Use of Force Directives and Community Engagement Initiative” to Chief DiLuzio June 9. The Mayor responded to the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith memo June 16. Council discussed and passed the Reynolds/Crampsie Smith resolution July 7. We are now on the edge of the July 21 Council meeting. Two months from the murder. Time passes.

Chair Colon wanted a Public Safety Committee meeting by this time. But COVID-19 boxed him in.

From what we can deduce from his comments July 7, Chair Colon “favors doing things in person” and would like “to see a large crowd.” But Town Hall, the Liberty Auditorium, and even the Liberty Stadium are not workable within the state pandemic guidelines or logistical efficiency.

And so he asked, “What’s the best way to have this meeting and capture the comments by as many members of the community as possible?”

A few posts back, Gadfly asked if you followers would have some alternate ideas for the kind of large-scale in-person meeting that Chair Colon wants, a meeting that we badly need before momentum shifts away from the issue of police reform and systemic racism and before budget season gets too far along.

Crickets. So Gadfly guesses you want him to break the ice. And make a fool of himself.

Let’s see if we can stir some thought that gives Chair Colon what he wants or nearly so.

So let’s think a bit wild, a bit out of the box.

Instead of one meeting, several.

Let’s try for a meeting in each of the 8 police districts. Would have the feel of neighborhood meetings, perhaps making exchange of views easier, drawing out a balance of views (we aren’t really hearing from those believing in a status-quo yet), and encouraging views from across the entire city. Different districts no doubt have different views of the police.

Let’s try for a venue in each district that could hold 30 or so safely socially distanced — school? church?

Let the moderators of the individual 8 meetings be the 7 Council members plus the Mayor — the districts they moderate chosen by lot. This integrally involves all the key people and dramatically demonstrates their commitment to working together and to listening to community voices.

Let the 8 meetings happen simultaneously. You know, like it’s one big meeting. Create a PR buzz about it beforehand. Have a slogan. Do a media push. You know, “Tuesday night July 28 Bethlehem Speaks Out on Police Reform!”

Film the meetings and post immediately on the City or the Council YouTube channel.

It will be the job of each of the 8 moderators to prepare a bullet-point summary of their individual meetings (a 10-bullet maximum) that will circulate to the public and be delivered (within a 10-minute maximum) at the August 4 meeting at which there can be public discussion.

The Public Safety Committee (Colon, Negron, Crampsie Smith) then boils out an appropriate smaller number of issues and action items for full Council to deliberate.

Does that start to break the ice, bust the box, stir some other options?

Don’t leave Gadfly twisting out here all alone.

This is fun.

Have at it!

Again, where are we?

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

What’s the best way to have this meeting?
Councilman Colon, Chair of the Public Safety Committee

We are temporarily putting the Public Safety Committee meeting on hold
until we can find a work-around
President Waldron

Where are we? Gadfly asked three days ago.

About the Public Safety Committee meeting, he means.

The Community Engagement Initiative has been handed off to the City. Apparently it’s up to the City to initiate the Initiative.

But what about that Public Safety meeting?

Gadfly feels even more urgency about that meeting after watching and listening to the protestors pounding on walls of the building in which Allentown City Council was at that moment meeting last night.

Council spent almost 20 minutes last meeting July 7 explaining its paralysis.

Councilman Colon, Chair of the Public Safety Committee (there are technical issues with part of his comments): “It it weren’t for COVID-19 and the restrictions it’s put on Council . . . we’d have had this meeting already.  .  .  . We’re expecting a large crowd, and I’d like to see a large crowd, but I want to see everybody who wants to attend able to attend. . . . [state guidelines, 250 meeting max] Is it really a public meeting, who gets to control who comes into the meeting? . . . the possibility of a virtual public safety meeting, which I am in support of, but . . . digital divide. . . . I am someone who favors doing things in person. . . . I think the situation is unique, I’m open to feedback from members of Council. . . . I want this accessible to as many members of the community as possible. . . . I don’t want this to be something that we’re getting in to September. . . . What’s the best way to have this meeting and capture the comments by as many members of the community as possible?”

President Waldron: “There’s a lot that goes into a public meeting. . . . For something as important as these conversations, I’m hesitant to rely on that infrastructure if we go to another venue and won’t be able to guarantee the level of accessibility of folks who are online to listen in or make comment remotely. . . . Our restrictions really that we are hung up on is that 250 number. . . . There’s a lot lost in having a remote meeting versus an in-person meeting. . . . Whichever way we came to, people were going to be excluded. . . . We are temporarily putting the Public Safety Committee meeting on hold until we can find a work around. . . . It wasn’t safe or prudent to move forward with scheduling a meeting till we had more guidance from the state and the school district and a better vision of COVID-19. . . . By no means are we trying to avoid this meeting.”

Understood.

But Gadfly hears the drumbeat of protestor hands pounding on the wall — don’t you? Cup your ears and listen.

And Gadfly worries about the optics. The Public Safety Committee that Councilman Colon chairs did not take up or even comment on the 6th and Hayes traffic stop at their March 3 meeting. And to tell the truth Gadfly — being admittedly bitchily gadflyish here — has wondered about Chairman Colon’s sense of urgency. He has consistently over the past several meetings said this is a time to listen, to keep the dialog going. But Gadfly remembers feeling oddly struck by his comments at the June 3 Council meeting to the effect that “I truly believe that Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, we’re not going to be the ones to change the world, to change the country. I think we can continue beyond today as we have. Change is incremental . . . change takes time.” Gadfly remembers thinking then, no, that’s not right, we should be thinking that we are the ones to change the world, that we should be seeking to exercise active leadership. That’s what he was looking for his leaders to say. Now is the time for action. Councilman Colon sounded a bit too patient for Gadfly’s likin’.

Gadfly remembers now Councilman Reynolds saying, “It’s about creating real change . . . The structure is designed to create public pressure such as we’ve seen tonight to create change within the city and within our police department . . . I’m trying to create something here that will allow for permanent access for these conversation and actions that need change . . . What I am trying to do here is create a permanent structure that will change the face of that conversation going forward . . . This is an opportunity, an opportunity for all of us to create real change.” Gadfly remembers thinking that the Reynolds leaning forward with urgent tone was more to his liking.

So the optics are bad. President Waldron has said and explained why that Council is not trying to duck a Public Safety meeting. But the optics are bad.

Of course, the next Council meeting is within sight, and maybe the work-around has been found.

Maybe all is good.

But Gadfly will take a shot at a work-around in the next post.

Allentown protestors take a knee for the knee’d

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Last night Allentown City Council spent 3 hours reading the many citizen comments on this incident into the record. Interesting. Worthwhile. See video here, begin min. 3:10.

from Jacqueline Palochko, “For three hours, Allentown City Council read comments from the public about police video as protesters demanded reform outside City Hall.” July 25, 2020.

It took three hours for Allentown City Council to get through comments from the public that mostly called for defunding the police department while protesters gathered outside City Hall to also demand reforms, including that all the officers involved in a video that showed an Allentown officer kneeling on a man be fired.

Also at the meeting Wednesday night, councilwoman Ce-Ce Gerlach and councilman Joshua Siegel proposed a police oversight resolution that calls for a number of reforms, including requiring officer intervention to stop any excessive use of force, making body camera footage available to the public and removing any exceptions for chokeholds and neck restraints from the use of force policy. The resolution has been referred to the July 29 meeting. It’s not the first police reform proposal that Siegel has proposed.

Wednesday’s meeting came just days after the video, which went viral and sparked a few local protests. The majority of the comments read during three hours were from people who said they were “infuriated,” “saddened,” and “outraged” about the video. Many suggested police funding be reallocated elsewhere, such as to mental health services, education and affordable housing.

“I demand that you immediately begin removing funds from the Allentown Police Department,” Muhlenberg College student Sydney Baron said in a comment.

“In the video widely circulating around social media, it is painfully obvious that the APD’s use of force in this scenario was excessive and dangerous,” Anna Tjeltveit wrote.

As council members took turns reading the comments, a group of at least 100 outside City Hall chanted “defund the police,” “if we don’t get no justice, they don’t get no peace,” and “no power like the power of the people” during the meeting that lasted more than four hours. At times early on in the meeting, the protesters could be heard banging on the doors on the city’s live stream.

The protesters held signs that said, “make an apology” and “defund now.” A large black banner that read “Black lives matter” in gold was also set up.

Because meetings are held virtually since the coronavirus pandemic, public comments are emailed in and then read at the meeting. When the meeting first started, council debated whether it was going to read all the comments at the beginning or end of the meeting. Councilwoman Cynthia Mota said all the comments should be read in the beginning, following the normal rules of a council meeting.

“Just listen to the people out there,” Mota said, as protesters watching the livestream outside applauded. “I’m willing to stay as long as I need to stay to hear what people have to say.”

A few comments were in support of the police department and encouraged the city to invest in more money for officers.

“The Allentown Police Department is essential to the safety and security of the citizens of Allentown,” Donald L. Cease wrote. “What we should do is increase funding to help make the department better by increasing the number of officers on the streets, increase training, expand mental health counseling and social workers that work in the field.”

Among the list of demands by POWER Lehigh Valley and six other Lehigh Valley activist groups are:

    • Release all body camera and surveillance footage from the incident Saturday
    • Fire all officers involved in the video, release their names and make their career history public and under review
    • Have Mayor Ray O’Connell, police Chief Glen Granitz Jr. and City Council President Daryl Hendricks make a statement of wrongdoing of the police department and commit to holding the department accountable
    • Defund the police department by $25 million and reallocate those funds into the community
    • Reallocate the $50,000 being considered for equipment to community-based violence prevention.

Borrero was intoxicated and screaming obscenities and posed a danger to himself and others, according to an affidavit.

Comments on Wednesday night suggested officers could have done something instead of cuffing him. Danica Schofer, a Muhlenberg College student who grew up in the city, said Allentown officers often came to her house growing up because her grandmother had a violent form of dementia.“She yelled and spit and hit and was called “non compliant” many times,” Schoefer wrote. “But she never had a knee on her neck. She was a white woman.”

When the meeting ended, the protesters again started to bang on the doors of City Hall and chant “Black lives matter” and “defund the police.” Gerlach and Siegel joined the protesters, who applauded for them, after the meeting.

Speaking to the crowd, Siegel said Borrero needed help rather than to be cuffed last Saturday. A protester then told Siegel that Borrero was in attendance, according to Facebook Live videos posted by the group Lehigh Valley Stands Up.

Siegel turned to address Borrero and apologized for what happened to him.

Standing in front of Borrero, everyone in attendance then took a knee in solidarity with him.

Restorative and transformative justice system in Seattle

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Reprinted in today’s Morning Call. Apropos of Gadfly’s train of thought over the last several posts, thanks to Mr. Crownfield.

from Naomi Ishisaka, “Envision a criminal legal system that doesn’t throw people away.” Seattle Times, July 13, 2020.

Our existing system of criminalization and mass incarceration is not working, by any measure.

These poor outcomes are leading more and more people to look at community-based alternatives to the legal system and incarceration, such as restorative and transformative justice.

Restorative and transformative justice practices are not new. Indigenous cultures around the world have practiced some form of restorative justice for millennia, rooted in the belief that no matter what a person may have done, none are disposable. More recently, efforts to extract ourselves from our current failed system of punishment and retribution have led to more interest in how those principles could be more widely implemented.

In a nutshell, restorative justice looks at incidents and harm between people. It asks who was harmed and how to address and rectify the harm and requires participants to take accountability.

Transformative justice seeks accountability but also looks at underlying conditions and social structures that created the conditions for harmful behavior and works to change or transform them to prevent future harm.

How could transformative justice work in practice? Seattle’s Creative Justice program provides an example.

Creative Justice started in 2015 as an arts-based approach to end youth incarceration and the dramatic racial disproportionality in youth detention. Co-directed by attorney and community organizer Nikkita Oliver and lead engagement artist Aaron Counts, the program uses art as an alternative to incarceration.

Why? Because incarceration doesn’t help young people, Counts said, nor does it make communities safer.

With a majority of the city council now pledging to support defunding the Seattle police by 50%, we have an opportunity to invest in different solutions. We can take a transformative approach and tackle some of the root causes of crime, such as generational poverty, housing instability and unequal education, as we overhaul the legal system at the same time. In fact we must, because there is no “them,” there is only “us.”

BLM proposal to Allentown City Council includes Citizen Review Board

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

From the Black Lives Matter Lehigh Valley Facebook page: Below is a resolution that will be brought before Allentown City Council on Wednesday that addresses many of the specific demands we made at Monday’s protest.

Resolved by the Council of the City of Allentown, That

WHEREAS, Allentown City Council is committed to a dialogue that includes examining police operations, legislative and community oversight, requiring certain reporting requirements and establishing a policy on force; and

WHEREAS, Allentown City Council supports along with the Human Relations Commission the Eight Can’t Wait recommendations from the Obama administration related to the use of police force; and

WHEREAS, City Council will meet on Wednesday, July 29, 2020 at 6:00 PM to begin to take public comment and work on recommendations for policing in Allentown; and

NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of Allentown will foster a dialogue inclusive of but not limited to reviewing, discussing and adopting some of the following:

Making Body cam usage mandatory – if not used then face discipline including termination;

Require that Allentown Police Department (APD) inform council of any changes to the Civil Rights, discipline and use of force policies and that if any of those changes effect adherence to 8 Can’t Wait, and if there are any changes council must vote on the change;

Explicitly adopt of policy that no knock warrants are banned;

Remove any exceptions for chokehold and neck restraints from the use of force policy;

Explicitly state that stop and frisk is banned;

Explicitly state that officers have a duty to intervene in any excessive use of force and that there are discipline consequences including termination for not doing so;

Establish by legislation a Citizens Review Board that reviews among other things for cases of excessive force and when a weapon is discharged;

Require Bi-annual reports of use of force, discipline, positive interactions, policy changes and types of calls/responses that are disaggregated by race and gender to be given and discussed at Council’s Public Safety at a public meeting.

Provide that misuse of force situations are immediately given to the attorney general (3rd party);

Officers who are suspected of violating the use of force policy and are under investigation are immediately placed on suspension while the investigation is conducted, this should be automatic, so the public has peace of mind and officers have accountability;

A quarterly reporting requirement that contains a breakdown of the nature of calls in Allentown, i.e. reason for call: mental health, domestic disturbance, violent crime, traffic accident, and an annual report. The report should be made public immediately following their release;

Make body camera footage available to the public and easily accessible with no delays in its release;

Begin to draft a plan of divestment of resources currently allocated to the police department to other areas or sectors of the city such as mental health, housing, drug & alcohol treatment,social services, etc;

Mandatory community meetings following use of force incidents to contend with the psychological ramifications and fear that emerges from the use of lethal use of force and force community concerns to be fielded and responded to.

Be It Also Resolved that City Council Effectuate such recommendations through legislative action as possible through amending your code or asking legislators to change.

Be it Finally Resolved that these recommendations be considered and reviewed no later than three months after passage of this resolution.

Allentown incident “a reflection of a warrior model of policing”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

You can see the full 9-minute video here.

from Daniel Patrick Sheehan and Manuel Gamiz, Jr. “Did Allentown police do anything wrong in video that sparked protests?” Morning Call, July 14, 2020.

When Kutztown University criminal justice professor Arthur Garrison saw the video of Allentown police officers struggling to subdue a man Saturday outside a hospital, what caught his attention wasn’t an officer’s knee on the man’s head but the indifference the officers displayed toward a man who clearly needed help.

“It is clear the police were interested in control of the man, not providing medical aid as a primary goal,” he said. “So the use of force follows. It’s a reflection of a warrior model of policing where the first thing is domination and control.”

“They were at the entrance of the emergency room and they see a man vomit in the street and need help and they just stand there watching him,” Garrison said. “They did not immediately rush to provide aid. Their indifference was the first thing that struck me.”

According to court documents posted Tuesday, Edward Borrero Jr., 37, of Allentown, was charged with possession of drug paraphernalia and disorderly conduct, both misdemeanors, as well as a summary offense of public drunkenness. It does not appear that he was taken into custody.

The cellphone video brought an immediate response from protesters, who marched Saturday night to a police substation at 10th and Hamilton streets, demanding answers. On Monday night, they were joined by hundreds of others, who called for the officer’s arrest and the defunding of the department.

Emanuel Kapelsohn, an Allentown consultant who teaches firearm and use-of-force techniques to police and helps agencies craft use-of-force policies, said it was no surprise that the Allentown video, a distressing echo of the Floyd arrest, sparked outrage and protests.

Kapelsohn said he was as appalled as anyone at Floyd’s slow asphyxiation under the knee of a Minneapolis police officer. But what happened in Allentown was distinctly different, he said.

“I don’t see anything wrong,” he said, of the placement of the Allentown officer’s knee. Kapelsohn — an attorney and reserve deputy sheriff who has been an expert witness in state and federal use-of-force trials — said the positioning of the officer’s knee, which lasted about eight seconds, didn’t constitute a neck restraint, which is banned by Allentown’s use-of-force policy, and posed no risk of cutting off the man’s air supply or the blood flow to his brain.

The events leading to the struggle are important to consider in judging what happened, he added.“ This was someone obviously in some kind of distress,” Kapelsohn said. “The police and hospital personnel are coming to help and that’s for his benefit, not theirs.”

Garrison — the Kutztown professor whose book “Chained to the System: History and Politics of Black Incarceration in America” comes out next month — said he saw more issues before the officer placed a knee on the man’s head.

“He wasn’t threatening, and that’s the issue that you look at when you look at police use of force,” he said. “When the cops came at him, he got on his knees and was submissive and the first thing they did was reach for their handcuffs, not see what was wrong with him.

“There’s two ways police see the world, either a warrior model or a guardian model,” which he said is a policing mindset focused on protecting citizens.

Another thing Garrison found interesting about the video was seeing two hospital staff members wave away a car that was slowing down as it passed the encounter, blocking the view of the police restraining the man.

“The nurses first engage by protecting the police,” he said. “Only when he is handcuffed do the nurses provide any attention and place some kind of hood over his head. Then they finally walk him to the emergency room.”

Kapelsohn said the reaction to the video is understandable because of what he called hypersensitivity in the wake of the Floyd killing.

In that case, he said, “that officer seems to be torturing him.”

Garrison said that while the knee to the man’s head and neck was brief, “you would think in the post-Floyd world, the officer would not have done such a thing.”

“If you have your knee to somebody’s neck, on concrete, he’s not going anywhere and that’s the point of domination and control,” he said. “It’s this kind of attitude and approach that can lead to a man dead under the police knee.”

Community Advisory Board discusses police use of force policy

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

On the City Facebook page: “Last evening we kicked off the first monthly meeting of the Community Advisory Board — sponsored by the local NAACP and President Lee — with Mayor Donchez and 23 members of the community participating. The city’s Use of Force Policy and the responsibilities of the city’s professional standards unit were discussed.‬”

As of 8am this morning, there were two comments to the post: “Was this a secret???” and “Was this invite only?”

Exactly Gadfly’s sentiments.

Gadfly ventures to say that there’s a kind of hunger in the wider “community” for such a presentation and subsequent discussion.

Will there be a report on the meeting? Gadfly has been confused about how this group fits into the need for local public discourse responding to the George Floyd murder.

He hopes that the local press was there and that we’ll see an article on the meeting.

Who are the members of the “Community Advisory Board”? Below is a list.

At the very least, one wonders about representatives from Black Lives Matter on the Board. At the very least, one would hope that the activists who spoke at Council July 7 were present and participating last night.

Gadfly hopes that the police presentation will be repeated at the Community Engagement Initiative the Mayor may be forming per the City Council resolution and a Council Public Safety Committee meeting now in limbo because of COVID-19.

7/13/20 Community Advisory Board Membership

Robert Donchez, Mayor

Esther Lee, President Bethlehem Unit NAACP

City Council – Grace Crampsie-Smith, Michael Colon

Northampton County Executive – Lamont McClure

NAACP – Tomacene Nickens, Rabbi Levy,  Carl Nelson

Clergy – Rabbi Michael Singer, Canon Dale Grandfield

Education – Dr. Roy, Superintendent BASD

Health Department – Kristen Wenrich

Homeless – Bob Rapp, BES

Latino Advisor – Cesar Cordova, Vivian Robledo Shorey, Olga Negron,  Yadira Colon-Lopez

Youth (2) – Spencer Williams, Sydney Duffy

Police – Chief Mark DiLuzio

Police Union – Bill Audelo, President and (to be named)

Teacher’s Union – Laura Keding, President

Representative Steve Samuelson

Alex Karras, Chief of Staff

Voices from the Allentown protest

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

from Michelle Merlin and Andrew Scott, “More than 200 march, demand change following video showing officer kneeling on man.” Morning Call, July 13, 2020.

More than 200 protesters gathered Monday evening in downtown Allentown in response to a Saturday night video, taken outside outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart, showing a police officer kneeling on a man’s head, near his neck.

Carrying banners stating “Black Lives Matter” and chanting “Defund the police” and “No justice, no peace,” the racially diverse crowd gathered at the Allentown Civil War memorial in response to what the video showed.

“I’m tired of this …, ” protester Rodney Bushe said to the crowd. “I’m tired of witnessing brothers and sisters with knees on their necks. I can’t breathe.”

They demanded the officer’s name, suspension and arrest; that police be defunded; an external investigation; and that elected officials either do more to end police officers’ unnecessary use of force or vacate their seats.

“These politicians try to act like we are savages who can’t manage ourselves,” said Arthur Benson, a member of the Lehigh Valley Black Lives Matter group and Action Town Activists. “We haven’t been allowed to have a seat at the table.”

Speakers at the event decried that police were violent toward a man vomiting outside a hospital who was in need of medical attention, not police force. They called for the city to defund the police and put the money toward education, mental health services and social services instead.

Zahnia Richardson attended the protest and said she found the video of the man outside the hospital disheartening. She supports the idea of defunding the police.

“I feel like a lot of the issues you need police for stem from lack of education, lack of mental health support. You could take from police funding and put it toward [things like that],” she said.

Jimmeka Hernandez, who participated in the the protest, said the video upset her. She said her children saw it and asked if it was real life or a movie.

“We educate our kids that police aren’t the enemy, but there’s a lot of police officers that aren’t doing their jobs correctly,” she said.

The crowd took a knee when Chantel Jenkins, the mother of one of four teenagers charged with inciting a riot during a January basketball game at Whitehall High School spoke. She told protesters her “worst nightmare came true,” when she saw police arresting her son and taking him into custody.

The Allentown branch of the NAACP on Sunday night issued a statement saying the video was “concerning and disturbing.” They said that once the investigation into the incident is complete, they’ll have more discussions.

“As the Allentown Police Department works through their new police policy protocols, we want them to ensure us that they are acting in a manner of integrity that shows both respect and safety for its citizens,” they said in the statement. They did not attend the rally, Secretary Barbara Redmond said in an email.

Full video of Allentown knee incident

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Floyd 15

from Andrew Scott, “Nine-minute video shows man outside hospital before officers approach, police takedown, aftermath,” Morning Call, July 13, 2020.

Allentown police on Monday released a nine-minute video showing a man kneeling, then objecting when officers put their hands on him before they forcefully restrained him, with one officer kneeling on the man’s head, near his neck, Saturday outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart.

The video was posted on the police department’s website as the city tries to quickly investigate the encounter, 23 seconds of which were caught on a video posted on social media Saturday. That footage showed the officer kneeling on the man, in a hold similar to the one that killed George Floyd when he was arrested by Minneapolis police. The Saturday video sparked protests in Allentown.

The video released Monday, taken from across the street from the hospital, shows the man walking slowly, almost staggering, on the road in front of the hospital and experiencing what police said appears to be a mental health crisis or drug or alcohol impairment. The officers were at the hospital on another matter when they noticed him.

The video shows the man appearing to vomit several times as he comes onto the sidewalk, drop his cellphone and have trouble walking and standing. The police gesture toward the emergency room entrance, suggesting he should go inside.

The video shows the man straighten up after he finishes vomiting. He then staggers backward into the road and an approaching car swerves around him. He then starts walking away from the officers, in the direction from which he had come, but then turns back.

About four minutes into the silent video, the man seems to gesture to two officers with his arms outstretched as they approach. As they get close, he kneels down, with his hands clasped beneath his chin before continuing to gesture and point. He briefly starts to rise to his feet, then kneels again as they come closer. He also appears to be talking to several hospital staff outside. When the officers try to pull his hands behind him, he tries to pull away.

Almost five minutes into the video, one of the officers appears to trip the man to bring him to the ground. He falls to the ground and police quickly kneel at his side to restrain him.

Shortly thereafter comes the scene caught in the video that was posted to social media, where an officer kneels on the man’s head, near his neck, for about eight seconds.

The video continues afterward, showing a spit mask being placed over the man’s head. The final minutes of the video show police and hospital staff escorting the man into the hospital, where police said he was treated and then released.

Mayor’s Community Advisory Board meets tonight

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Town Hall, 6pm

About 25 members — socially distanced that will about fill the Rotunda.

(Who aren’t members? Doesn’t look like any of the young people who organized demonstrations or who spoke at Council Tuesday and are part of activist organizations.)

No notice to the general public by the City as far as Gadfly can see.

I guess we’re not invited.

Nor is there any indication of video.

No matter.

Nothing much of interest on the agenda.

Only a presentation on Police Reform by the Police Department.

Wouldn’t miss Jeopardy for that.

But hope the press is there.

Christina and Sara, depending on you.

Where are we?

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

We have an opportunity to do something truly momentous.
Anna Smith

Where are we?

Gadfly’s not sure.

After just spending a half-dozen posts or so on last week’s City Council meeting, Gadfly’s not sure.

When Gadfly was 20, he was an impatient man — time was so expansive, he didn’t want to waste any.

Now that Gadfly is 80, he is still an impatient man — time is so short he doesn’t want to waste any.

Councilman Reynolds forthrightly and forcefully argued that the rationale for the Community Engagement Initiative is “to start the conversation,” “to create public pressure,” “to create change within the city and within our police department,” “to create a permanent [organic] structure that will change the face of the conversation going forward.”

At 80 your mind skips a beat. Gadfly doesn’t get this. The resolution that passed urges the City to set up this structure. There is no guarantee that it will happen. And the Mayor has already set up a Community Advisory Board with the NAACP. So what will happen to the Council resolution? It’s fate seems out of their hands.

(At Council Councilwoman Van Wirt took note of the multiplicity of committees: “When I thought about all these different committees, it seemed like we were a bunch of brooms trying to do a good job of cleaning up and kicking stuff around and not really organizing enough to sweep it up.”)

Well, there was always the promise of a Council Public Safety Committee meeting. But COVID has shot that to hell.  Listen, if you will, to this almost 20 minutes of conversation at the July 7 Council meeting about why there can’t be a Public Safety Committee meeting. It can’t he held in Town Hall. It can’t be held at Liberty. It can’t be held in Liberty stadium. It can’t be held online.

So where are we?

From the news I’m listening to, I wouldn’t be confident that COVID restrictions are going to let up any time soon.

So where are we?

Here’s what it feels like to me. Which happened on my street about 10:30. A car alarm went off. Terrible clanging. Never ending. Soon neighbors gathered around the car looking stupidly at it and each other as if our wishes would make the terrible sound go away. Our wishes would not make the terrible sound — a sound that made any other thought impossible — go away.

That’s what Council feels like to me. Ringing an alarmed car, impotent to act. Nobody with a key.

Time is not particularly on our side.

Are there any suggestions from Gadfly followers as to what Council should do to advance the conversation that is so needed and so desired?

We have an opportunity to do something truly momentous.

If only we could figure out how to meet.

Pensées for a lunch-time stroll along the Monocacy

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

fragments of recent posts that swarm Gadfly’s head like bees around a hive
what are you thinking about?

One wonders, precisely at this moment, what Council’s response to the current moment would look like if Negron had been [elected president of Council].

We don’t need another task force. We need to listen to what’s going on already. We’re not listening.

I thought we matter’d . . . We don’t matter, Bro.

Do we want recruits who are all about SWAT teams? Walking in phalanxes through crowds?

The structure proposed in the resolution is basically useless until a genuinely inclusive process is created.

Have you consulted black people in the creation of this coalition?

We have an opportunity to do something truly momentous.

Council looks like it’s standing on dock waving to a boat leaving and hoping it will visit the destinations it has mentioned.

Engage a single, paid person to lead this initiative. . . .  And this person NEEDS to speak Spanish.

The optics look like same-old-same-old.

It seems that the entire message of these protests is lost on you.

Wouldn’t you rather hear from the individuals who know what it’s like to have obscenities screamed at you in a language you don’t understand by a police officer (an incident I witnessed)?

It is only a matter of time before we have our own George Floyd, or Joey Santos.

Cop-sponsored pizza parties aren’t going to appease us. That’s basically what this is.

We know what’s going on.

“The structure proposed in the resolution is basically useless until a genuinely inclusive process is created”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Breena Holland is an Associate Professor at Lehigh University in the Department of Political Science and the Environmental Initiative. She is a past director of Lehigh University’s South Side Initiative.

Gadfly,

I believe the Councilmembers Reynolds and Crampsie Smith have good intentions. However, their responses didn’t convey an understanding of some key points raised by the callers/speakers who opposed the resolution. Even if Councilmembers Reynolds and Crampsie Smith were only trying to institutionalize a structure to bring people together and can therefore convincingly claim that it is because of these meager goals that the resolution makes no substantive commitments, they still failed to address some important problems that the callers and speakers raised.

First, in the spirit of collaboration and recognition that their own perspectives on how to address issues of racial injustice might be limited, the Reynolds and Crampsie Smith really should have asked the LatinX members of council for some input prior to proposing a resolution. It was not long ago that both Reynolds and Crampsie Smith voted against Councilwoman Negron when she was nominated to be Council president, despite some thirty people showing up to a meeting to support her nomination. One wonders, precisely at this moment, what Council’s response to the current moment would look like if Negron had been affirmed in that vote. She seemed to reluctantly support the resolution only after significant changes. It’s nice (and rare) that Reynolds agreed to her changes, but this should have been done on the front end of the process, not the back end, after Negron’s refusal to support the resolution in a formal meeting forced Reynolds to accommodate her perspective. The hypocrisy of Reynolds proposing a process to address an important problem without first getting the support of key people on Council is evident if you simply recall the anger he expressed at Councilwoman Negron for proposing an ethics ordinance (that he declined to support) without first seeking out the input from every member of Council, the mayor, and his staff.

Second, when the message of a movement is that the problem of racial injustice is structural and needs to be addressed at a foundational level, people who are not the ones suffering from those injustices may want to pause before proposing to address the problem through the same institutional structures that have thus far failed to address the problem. As the speakers explained, they (the activists) are already meeting, they are already organizing. If councilmembers really couldn’t wait to do something, why not start by learning about the problem they’ve thus far failed to address from the activists who are doing something about it? Councilmembers could go to their meetings, they could ask them how they could be helpful in their positions as elected officials. They could stop assuming that the normal processes and venues they provide for addressing problems will work. They could take a minute to wonder about how they might build new tools, proceed in a different way, include more people whose voices are generally silenced, etc. The structure proposed in the resolution is basically useless until a genuinely inclusive process is created. So far any discussion about how to make the process inclusive has been rather shallow. For instance, one caller explained the need for a person to organize the forum who actually knows the people who Council apparently wants to join this discussion. This and many other good ideas were never mentioned in the efforts by Reynolds and Crampsie Smith to defend their resolution rather than actually hear what people were saying. Councilman Callahan had a remarkably astute night in recognizing the appropriateness of tabling the resolution and for explicitly asking Councilwoman Negron what she wanted to do.

What we ended up with is a resolution that essentially asks all those people who came to the meeting (and those who never will but who are nonetheless supposed to show up and talk to councilmembers about racial justice) to make their views relevant by showing up at a forum that Council creates. I hope the activists do come because I think our elected officials could learn a lot from them. But I’m not sure why they would show up. Maybe they want to spend their time helping members of Council do their jobs better. Or maybe they should just spend their time supporting candidates who better reflect their goals and concerns, or running for elected positions themselves. Beating one’s head against the wall to achieve what is likely to be mostly more of the same from the same people is probably not a winning strategy.

Sincerely, Breena

Councilwoman Negron: “I’m not the only one who is appalled”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

original resolution
“Resolution urging the creation of a Community Engagement Initiative
in the City of Bethlehem”

Councilwoman Negron’s impatience did have effect.

I’m not the only one who is appalled by [the 2nd and 3rd paragraph]. We want to try to make the Administration accountable and push an agenda that the community wants. [Paragraphs 2 and 3] must go

Councilman Reynolds made two amendments to the resolution.

I thank you Councilman Reynolds, that’s very honorable. . . . You are saying to all the people . . . that they are not invisible.

Amended resolution:

Adding this line (might not be exact wording): “The Administration should work with and incorporate recommendations by research experts including Lehigh University’s Core Grant team who recently conducted a large research project on policing in the Lehigh Valley.”

NOW THEREFORE BE IT:RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Bethlehem urges the Mayor and his Administration to collaborate with the City of Bethlehem Police Department to create a public space and forum for the long-term discussion of issues surrounding systemic racism, discrimination, race-based inequities, social justice, mental health, addiction, poverty eradication, inclusionary housing, education, and fair policing practices(“Community Engagement Initiative”). The Community Engagement Initiative might include and/or interface with any individuals or entities that the Mayor and his Administration think appropriate such as citizens, human service organizations, the medical community, school leaders, social justice organizations, police officers,and Police Department leaders. The Administration should work with and incorporate recommendations by research experts including Lehigh University’s Core Grant team who recently conducted a large research project on policing in the Lehigh Valley.

Amended resolution:

Deleting two paragraphs

WHEREAS, following the murder of George Floyd on May 25, 2020, and during a period of justified outrage and anger,people across the nation and around the world have engaged in massive and sustained protests against persistent patterns of racial injustice and inequity in the United States and other countries. In the United States, a primary focus of these protests hasbeen on policing practices affecting Black, Latinx, and other minority communities;

WHEREAS, Bethlehem City Council thanks our Police Department and its officers for facilitating and protecting peaceful protests and we recognize our Police Department’ successful efforts in protecting public safety and property while at the same time protecting the community’s vital right of free expression. Our community has come together to grieve, talk, mobilize, and peacefully protest racial injustice in cooperation with our Police Department and not as adversaries against our police;

WHEREAS, Bethlehem City Council commends the Mayor and our Police Department for being the first City in the Lehigh Valley to release its unredacted police use of force policy and further recognizes that our Police Department proactively incorporated many of the 8 Can’t Wait police use of force directives into their operations many years prior to George Floyd’s murder, as part of the Police Department’s accreditation process,and further recognizes that the Police Department has been receptive and responsive in recently making additional changes to strengthen the 8 Can’t Wait use of force directives in Bethlehem. Moreover, we recognize our Police Department’s current community engagement efforts. We also recognize the need for further re-evaluation and review of our Department’s use of force policy to achieve compliance with all federal and state guidelines, current case law and the best standards and practices available in alignment with 8 Can’t Wait;

WHEREAS,Bethlehem City Council believes we must and can do better as a city to build stronger bridges and trust between our Police Department and our community,and that working together, we can avail ourselves of this opportunity to work collaboratively and self-reflectively to improve the relationship between our Police Department and our diverse ethnic and racial communities,that together,make up the City we all love;

The resolution, as amended, passed 7-0.

Gadfly will introduce you in some depth to the research of Prof Ochs and the team at Lehigh University in upcoming posts.

Councilwoman Negron: “We don’t need another resolution. We need action”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Gadfly’s day job has slowed him down the past few days. He was working through the discussion of the “Resolution urging the creation of a Community Engagement Initiative in the City of Bethlehem” at the City Council meeting last Tuesday July 7.

Let’s recap: we looked at the in-person comments by people involved in demonstrations and activists in local organizations. We looked at by-phone commentary. Many of these commenters had specific lists of things needing to be done. There was impatience at more talk instead of immediate action. The newspaer characterized the commentary as “lukewarm at best.” Then we looked at rationales presented by the co-sponsors Councilman Reynolds and Councilwoman Crampsie Smith.

We are now ready to look at actual discussion of the resolution by Councilmembers.

The key voice in the discussion was Councilwoman Negron’s. Negron

Public commenters were impatient.

Councilwoman Negron was impatient.

There is incredible information that we need to consider. We don’t need another task force. We need to listen to what’s going on already. We’re not listening. The resolution needs more teeth. There’s research collected here [Prof Ochs, Lehigh University] in the Lehigh Valley. I can’t support window-dressing. We’re just creating another resolution that won’t do anything. We don’t need another resolution, we need action.

To what effect this impatience? See next–

Allentown Police Chief: “I will be on the right side of it, whatever it is”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Kayla Dwyer, “Protesters confront Allentown mayor, police Saturday night about video of officer kneeling on man’s neck.” Morning Call, July 12, 2020.

A large group gathered Saturday night in downtown Allentown to demand answers from the Allentown Police Department and Mayor Ray O’Connell about a video taken earlier in the day that showed an officer pressing his knee into a man’s neck during an arrest.

A video circulated Saturday night on social media showing officers arresting a man outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart on West Chew Street in Allentown.

The video, less than 30 seconds long and taken from an unknown person’s car, shows three officers arresting the man. One of the officers appears to put his shoulder and elbow on the man’s back before pressing his knee on his neck.

Both O’Connell and Allentown police Chief Glenn Granitz Jr. showed up to the protest to answer questions and acknowledged they had seen the video. Granitz said there will be an investigation.

Speaking to some of the protesters Saturday night, O’Connell called the video “disturbing,” but said, “I think we need to gather all the facts and information before we go forward.”

The group first gathered at Seventh and Hamilton streets around 11 p.m. Saturday, after Hasshan Batts, executive director of Promise Neighborhoods of the Lehigh Valley, issued a call to action in a live Facebook video.

“Where are we going to make it loud and clear that this is not OK?,” he said, en route to the meeting spot. “If this is not OK to you, meet me on Seventh and Hamilton, right now.”

They then marched to the police precinct at 10th and Hamilton, with chants such as “Say his name, George Floyd,” the Minneapolis man who was killed in May after an officer knelt for nearly nine minutes on his neck.

Some knocked repeatedly on the doors and windows of the precinct while others blocked the street out front, continuing chants like “Hands up, don’t shoot.”

Some also made phone calls to the precinct and to the mayor.

O’Connell arrived shortly before midnight, and Granitz soon after.

Protesters asked for the name of the officer who pressed his knee against the man and asked Granitz for his response to what he saw in the video.

“As a human being, a knee on the neck, is that OK?” asked Maegan Llerena, director of Make the Road Pennsylvania.

“We’re going to take a look at it. We’re going to go through everything. And we’re going to give you an update as soon as we can,” Granitz responded.

“I don’t have a 24-hour, 48-hour time table for you,” Granitz said when a resident asked how long an investigation would take.

The protest ended around 12:30 a.m. Batts took to the megaphone to urge a peaceful dispersal, saying two point people would be following up with police.

Granitz could not give many details about the video Saturday night.

“I just got here, and I’m here to look at it,” he told protesters gathered in a circle around him. “I’ve seen a short clip.”

“Just be on the right side of this,” a protester said to him.

“I will be on the right side of it, whatever it is,” Granitz responded.

Video: “I thought we mattered.” Schlossberg: “I can’t unhear his voice.”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

from Daniel Patrick Sheehan, “Video of Allentown police officer kneeling on man’s neck: Woman who took it says she was shocked, and George Floyd’s attorney weighs in.” Morning Call, July 12, 2020.

The woman who shot a video outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart in Allentown, Pa., that shows a police officer putting his knee on a man’s head and neck during an arrest said the man was screaming “Mira, mira!” — Spanish for ‘Look, look!‘”

“That means he knew what was going on and he was screaming for someone like me to see,” said the woman, an Allentown resident who doesn’t want her name made public and uses a pseudonym on Facebook.

Assistant Chief Bill Lake said the incident came under immediate review, in keeping with the department’s use-of-force policy.

“As soon as this came to light, we got the ball rolling,” he said. Lehigh County District Attorney Jim Martin said his office will review Allentown’s conclusions, adding he can’t comment on the case until that process is done.

The video, less than 30 seconds long, shows one of the officers putting his shoulder and elbow on the man’s back before pressing his knee on his head and neck.

The video is already garnering national attention — including from attorney Benjamin Crump, who represents Floyd’s family.

Mayor Ray O’Connell and Allentown police Chief Glenn Granitz Jr. showed up to the protest to answer questions. O’Connell called the video “disturbing,” but said, “I think we need to gather all the facts and information before we go forward.”

Granitz added that he couldn’t say when the investigation would be finished. “I don’t have a 24-hour, 48-hour time table for you,” he said.

Through its Facebook page, the local Black Lives Matter group said it is awaiting official statements from the city before deciding what to do next.

Meanwhile, the group has issued six demands: that the body camera footage of the arrest be released; that all officers involved be suspended pending an external investigation; that the mayor, police chief and city council president make a public statement; that the man’s name and medical condition be released; that a criminal justice review board be put in place to oversee Allentown, Bethlehem and Easton; and that Allentown reallocate funds from the police department “into the community.”

On Twitter, Allentown Councilman Joshua Siegel, who was at the protest, said he was “disgusted and outraged” and made similar demands, including the officers’ suspension and the release of names and body camera footage.

Siegel’s council colleague, Ce-Ce Gerlach, who also attended the protest, posted a video to Facebook in which she said she felt “raw” over the incident.

“That’s why I went down [to the protest] last night,” she said. “Not as a City Council member but as a resident that wants to see justice here in Allentown.”

Democratic U.S. Rep. Susan Wild issued a statement Sunday calling the video “sickening” and “yet another instance of unwarranted force against a Black man.” She pointed to the George Floyd Justice in Policing Act recently passed by the House, which would prohibit the use of this kind of force across the country, among other reforms.

“We cannot continue to allow the lethal combination of systemic racism and excessive use of force to rot our system of justice,” she wrote.

Also on Twitter, state Rep. Mike Schlossberg, who represents Allentown, said he was horrified when he saw the video and stressed the importance of a thorough investigation.

“The protestors last night were chanting ‘Black Lives Matter’ for a reason,” he wrote. “You’d have to be heartless to not hear the pain and anger in their voices, or the trauma in the voice of the man in the video saying, ‘I thought we mattered.’ I can’t unhear his voice.”

BASD to review African American history in the curriculum

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

from Jacqueline Palochko, “Black Lives Matter movement prods Bethlehem and other districts to review how history is taught.” Morning Call, July 12, 2020.

Jared Dowling was surfing the internet three years ago in June when he noticed a Google Doodle paying tribute to Juneteenth. Having no idea what the event was, Dowling, a 2020 Freedom High School graduate heading to Syracuse University, spent all day reading about how it originated in Texas on June 19, 1865, when slaves learned of their freedom — two years after the Emancipation Proclamation was signed.

In four years of high school, Dowling, who is Black, never learned about Juneteenth in classes. But that didn’t surprise him. “There was never going to be a heavy focus on things of that nature in history class,” Dowling said.

Schools do not honestly and accurately teach the struggles and history of African Americans, Bethlehem Area School District Superintendent Joseph Roy acknowledged. That’s why he is proposing that the district spend the next year reforming middle and high school history courses.

“Going way back, American history was to teach how great the country is,” Roy said. “And we are a great country, and I think we’re great enough that we can look at our failures and the progress we’ve made.”

By state law, Pennsylvania public schools must teach ethnic and racial relations, which could include segregation and racial profiling. By third grade, students are taught about the “treatment of minority groups in history.” But the state doesn’t mandate specific courses. Districts build their own curriculum, with approval from school boards.

Roy would like Bethlehem’s history classes to go into more moments that deeply affected African American communities. While the civil rights movement is taught, for example, it’s often quickly done at the end of the school year and not given enough time. Roy would also like classes to delve into historical policies that heavily contributed to income disparities facing African Americans today.

About 11% of Bethlehem’s 13,600 students are Black.

“We know about slavery and we know it’s bad, but then we jump through Reconstruction, Jim Crow, civil rights,” Roy said. “We don’t do enough to understand the long-term structural impacts.”

The lack of teaching of African American history is not a knock on teachers, Roy said. As a former social studies teacher, he only recently learned about Juneteenth himself and knows other events were left out of his lessons. It also goes back to what teachers were taught when it comes to race relations. That’s why he wants to make sure the district finds the right resources and offers the necessary instruction to teachers before reforming history courses.

“We have to have teachers learn more and be given the materials,” Roy said.

School board President Michael Faccinetto expects the board to support a review of the history curriculum.

“I think it’s important to teach an honest account of history, not a comfortable one,” Faccinetto said, adding that history classes should teach more about the struggles of African Americans between the Civil War and the civil rights movement.

A review of the history curriculum is a step in the right direction, Dowling, the soon-to-be Syracuse student, said. But the disparities in white and Black communities shouldn’t just come up in history classes, he said.

During his four years at Freedom, Dowling observed that he was the only Black student in his high school honors classes, the only Black student who ran for student council and the only one on the debate team.

There have been times in class, such as when slavery comes up, when Dowling has felt his white classmates’ eyes drift toward him in an uncomfortable way. But there isn’t anything wrong in feeling uncomfortable, Dowling said.

“We need to have those uncomfortable conversations so people know this is not OK,” he said. “Even if the class is overwhelmingly white, people should be educated on the plights the Black community has faced.”

Touchstone: Songs of Hope and Resistance July 23

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

SONGS OF HOPE AND RESISTANCE

Touchstone 4

In a time of unrest, uncertainty, and difficult changes, join Touchstone for a celebration of community and connectedness with a social-distance safe outdoor party in the Touchstone parking lot.

July 23, 7pm

SONGS OF HOPE AND RESISTANCE

The resolution an extension of Crampsie Smith’s long career of advocacy

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Co-sponsor of the “Resolution urging the creation of a Community Engagement Initiative in the City of Bethlehem” Councilwoman Crampsie Smith followed, highlighting her extensive enlightening experience and ending with a strong pledge for life-long advocacy.

  • Some misconception about the purpose of this resolution.
  • I also attended [like Mr. Reynolds] all the marches and rallies.
  • We need to give citizens of this city a voice beyond the rallies.
  • It’s a mechanism for the citizens of this city.Grace Crampsie Smith 2
  • They are the ones who are going to navigate this process.
  • I’m hoping we can have a virtual meeting at some point.
  • I have almost 40 years of experience working in mental health . . . [etc.] . . . and the majority of the people and students I have worked with are people of color.
  • I’ve learned a great deal from them . . . I have tried to open my mind . . .
  • This [resolution] is a vehicle by which the citizens can come and express their concerns, and we can work together to try to make changes . . . in all areas.
  • Even though I do have white privilege, I have, and I will continue to advocate for people of color, people living in poverty, people who have mental illness, addictions, you name it, I will continue to advocate till the day I die.

Reynolds rationale for the resolution

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Gadfly is moving chronologically covering the July 7 City Council meeting and the “Resolution urging the creation of a Community Engagement Initiative in the City of Bethlehem” sponsored by Councilpersons Reynolds and Crampsie Smith.

Gadfly has brought you the in-person and by-phone public comment, which, as the newspaper characterized it, was “lukewarm at best.”

Give Councilman Reynolds credit. He was “in the room” (the other Council members except president Waldron participated online) directly facing and speaking to the activists.

His rationale for the resolution was clear and strong.

  • I agree with a lot of what’s been said.
  •  . . . the most learning goes on where there is the most amount of discomfort . . .
  • What is in front of us here is really a concept
  • I attended and I marched in every one of the rallies that have gone on in Bethlehem during the last several weeks.
  • The energy there was unbelievable, and the people in this room deserve a lot of credit for that.
  • What I am trying to do here . . . is find a public, open structure by which that energy is able to continue.
  • This is not about me saying I have the solution. This is not about me saying we should do A, B, and C.
  • I kept the resolution vague for that reason.
  • Trying to work out having a public space meeting during a pandemic . . . has been  impossible.
  • Unacceptable to me to do nothing till August or September.
  • I had an hour and a half conversation with [Prof Ochs] at Lehigh . . . [the kind of research] that needs to be at the center of what we’re looking for going forward.
  • I disagree that anything I’ve been involved with has been a band-aid, I think that me record of public service shows that I don’t usually get involved in things that I don’t think will lead to real change.
  • It’s about creating real change. Reynolds 3
  • The energy we have about making change . . . extends beyond the police department.
  • The reason I came up with this idea now is to start the conversation.
  • The structure is designed to create public pressure such as we’ve seen tonight to create change within the city and within our police department.
  • I’m trying to create something here that will allow for permanent access for these conversation and actions that need change.
  • What I wanted to do here is create an organic structure that does not have a lot of direction . . . no votes, no official members, but it’s about transparency and accountability.
  • We need to look like a department that understands that not every call needs to be answered by a police officer.
  • . . . opportunity to hear from our police department about what we currently do . . .
  • We need to allow conversation from all different corners of the city.
  • I was just trying to create a space, not an agenda, in which for one month we are hearing from [anybody /everybody] that wants to.
  • People deserve to have a voice, and it’s important that the right people are in that room to hear about those topics, and it’s not just us.
  • What I am trying to do here is create a permanent structure that will change the face of that conversation going forward.
  • We need to draw the lines [from what happened in the past] to what’s going on today.
  • What this was to me was just the opportunity to create that space.
  • [vague] designed that way.
  • It was never about we need to do this, this, and this. I felt that would be disrespectful to those who have other ideas.
  • The best that we can do is to give people who have ideas about what we need to do access to power and a voice in being able to have these conversations.
  • This is an opportunity, an opportunity for all of us to create real change.
  • But it only happens if we get buy-in from the city and buy-in from the community.
  • The only way this piece of paper means anything is if we’ve made progress a month from now . . . year . . . two years.