What fresh hell is this? Part 1

logo Latest in a series of posts about responses to the George Floyd killing logo

from Andrew Scott and Jon Harris, “Three Allentown council members call for Gerlach and Siegel to be censured for joining Black Lives Matter protests.” Morning Call, August 2, 2020.

Three Allentown City Council members say they support a resolution demanding a censure and no-confidence vote against council members Ce-Ce Gerlach and Joshua Siegel, urging them to resign and alleging conflicts of interest in their participation in Black Lives Matter protests.

The resolution, which was drafted by council member Ed Zucal and could be presented at Wednesday’s meeting, claims Gerlach and Siegel betrayed the oath of office and “are unfit and not worthy to hold the position of councilperson.” Council President Daryl Hendricks and member Candida Affa said Saturday they support the resolution, agreeing that Gerlach and Siegel’s demonstrating raises questions about their objectivity in matters pertaining to the Allentown Police Department.

Gerlach and Siegel defended their actions, saying that standing with citizens does not pose a conflict of interest. It’s unclear whether they will be censured, with Hendricks and Affa noting the resolution will need four yes votes to pass. That means the resolution hinges on votes from council Vice President Julio Guridy and member Cynthia Mota.

Guridy didn’t return a call about his vote. Mota didn’t wish to discuss her vote, but said she was disgusted and saddened by the situation. ”I was elected to do the right thing by the people. I didn’t sign up for nonsense,” Mota said. “I really would like to tell people that we have to be united, this is not the time to be divided. It just pains me when I see all the negativity going around.”

Gerlach and Siegel recently proposed reforms to police department policy, such as a requirement that officers intervene when they see force being used inappropriately, that a citizen’s board review allegations of excessive force, and that some of the department’s funding be reallocated to nonprofits providing mental health and addiction services. Council will discuss the measures at its Aug. 12 meeting.

The resolution alleges Gerlach and Siegel:

    • used social media to make derogatory remarks against other council members and the police department.
    • violated the city charter by joining protesters who “attempted to question the police and ask for defunding the police” after a July 11 incident outside St. Luke’s Hospital-Sacred Heart in which an officer used his knee to restrain Edward Borrero Jr.
    • were both seen carrying signs that said “Defund the police”; and Siegel was heard saying “F— the police.”
    • put pedestrians at risk with their involvement in protests, which blocked intersections, causing drivers to go the wrong way down streets.
    • undermined the police department by publicly apologizing to Borrero after the July 15 council meeting, where a number of citizens angry at Borrero’s arrest urged council to reform the police department and protested outside.
    • In addition, Siegel gave the mayor’s cellphone number to “an already angry group of protesters,” which the resolution calls a moral and ethical violation that led to him being harassed.

Their actions, the resolution alleges, placed the city in “a position of future litigation” and showed they can no longer be objective about the police department or trusted by citizens.

Gerlach and Siegel took issue with the allegations, saying they were protesting systemic racism. They noted that other council members, including Hendricks, Zucal and Affa, joined Allentown’s first Black Lives Matter protest just days after a white police officer in Minneapolis pressed his knee on the neck of George Floyd, killing him, during a May 25 arrest.

“And I’m glad my fellow council members were there, but does this mean there was a conflict of interest in that protest as well?” Gerlach asked.

“No,” Zucal said. “We were not there to protest. We were there to support.”

Gerlach said she never carried a “defund the police” sign, yelled anything offensive at the police or posted disparaging remarks about council online.

“I’d like to see those posts they’re claiming I put out on social media,” she said.

“Conflict of interest is really being misconstrued here,” Siegel said. “I can argue it’s a conflict of interest for council members Zucal and Hendricks, both former police officers themselves, to vote with the rest of council on any matters involving our local police department.”

Siegel said he has apologized to Mayor Ray O’Connell for giving out his phone number, adding he did so in the heat of the moment.

The reforms he and Gerlach have proposed, Siegel said, aren’t anti-police but a reexamination of public safety issues and the money the city spends on them. He said it wasn’t council’s place to determine if he and Gerlach were worthy of holding office, that that’s up to the voters.

“What they’re really censuring is the Black Lives Matter movement, which is bigger than me and Councilwoman Gerlach,” he said. “They’re making it real clear what their stance is.”

This is only part 1. Buckle up!

Greenway farmer’s market opened last Friday

logo Latest in a series of posts on the Southside logo

Gadfly apologizes for the late notice but hopes you will take note and patronize this great addition along the Greenway.

Tip o’ the hat to all involved!

Greenway

A new farmer’s market is coming to Bethlehem starting this Friday [July 31] from 2 p.m. to 5 p.m. The market will be at the South Bethlehem Greenway’s Polk Street entrance. There is no official street address. The Greenway at Polk is located between Mechanic and Fourth Streets. (April Gamiz/The Morning Call)

from Christina Tatu, “New farmers market to debut Friday at South Bethlehem Greenway.” Morning Call, July 29, 2020.

Starting Friday [July 31] south Bethlehem’s Greenway will host a new farmers market that will feature food and merchandise from South Side business owners.

The concept was cultivated in the midst of the pandemic, when the Community Action Development Corp. of Bethlehem was looking for ways to promote South Side businesses, said corporation Director Yadira Colon-Lopez.

“We wanted businesses to be able to get out and sell their products, sell their food and really help sustain themselves and be a little bit more creative during this time,” Colon-Lopez said.

The city’s rail trail park, the Greenway, is a nearly 2-mile rail trail the follows the former Norfolk Southern line through the city’s South Side neighborhoods. It begins just north of Lehigh University and ends just outside Saucon Park.

The market will be held at the Polk Street entrance of the Greenway from 2 to 6 p.m. Friday and will continue every Friday through Sept. 25.

The Community Action Development Corp. has been around for 25 years with the mission of revitalizing the city’s formerly industrialized South Side. This is the first time the group is organizing a farmers market on the Greenway, which will continue next year, Colon-Lopez said. There will be five vendors to start on Friday, with more anticipated in the coming weeks.

There are also plans to bring in family-oriented entertainment later this summer, such as singalongs and puppet shows.

William Seixas, who runs the Couchpota-doh Food Truck with his wife, Marylou Seixas, is excited for the new market.“It’s something we’ve been advocating for in the area,” William Seixas said. He lives about three blocks from the Greenway Farmers Market. While the Lehigh University market has been popular, Seixas believes the Greenway location will encourage people to walk around and explore other areas of the city. He and his wife have been operating their food truck for five years, making Ecuadorian food from family recipes that have been passed down over the years. Their specialties include oversized empanadas and fried mashed potatoes topped with a fried egg and a red onion salad.

Jill Matthews, co-owner of Dinky’s Ice Cream on East Third Street, hopes the market provides the push her business needs. She and her husband, Norman Matthews, also own a location in Bangor. They opened the Bethlehem store about six weeks ago, but because of the pandemic, things have been slower than expected. “The farmers market is literally going to be in our backyard. I hope this lets people know we are here and what we have,” she said.

Shannon Van Wert, owner of the Bananarama food truck, said her sales are at a third of what they were last year, since the big festivals she normally attends — such as Mayfair at Cedar Crest College and Blues Brews and Allentown’s Blues Brews and Barbecue Festival — have been canceled. Van Wert, who makes dairy-free sundaes out of whipped, frozen bananas, won’t be at the Greenway this Friday, but plans to be there starting next week. “I’m definitely excited to be on the South Side of Bethlehem. It’s not easy for us to find places to vend in the city and it’s really nice of them to be thinking of vendors who don’t have an outlet,” she said.

The new farmers market is made possible by Southside Vision 20/20, a six-year revitalization program of the Community Action Development Corp. of Bethlehem and the city. Last week, city officials approved a roughly four-block area from Webster Street to Pierce Street for the market. Colon-Lopez anticipates eventually having up to five vendors per block.

High Noon at the Emmaus Triangle: “I love you” . . . “I love you, too”

logo Latest in a series of posts about responses to the George Floyd killing logo

From Kayla Dwyer, “Black Lives Matter activists silently protest at ‘pro-Trump/Back the Blue’ rally in Emmaus, where tensions rose but settled.” Morning Call, August 1, 2020.

Not long after the two groups assembled in the center of Emmaus at high noon Saturday, one occupying most of the Triangle and the other a corner of it, they came face to face.

Those who gathered in the Emmaus Triangle for a pro-Trump/Back the Blue/pro-Second Amendment event turned their attention toward Black Lives Matter activists staging a silent protest. At the height of the tension, the Trump supporters, many of them visibly armed and maskless, stood within a few feet of the Black Lives Matter protesters and lobbed insults at them: “stupid kids,” “Marxists,” “move to another country.”

Apart from one or two activists who shouted back, most stood in silence behind signs that read “No Justice No Peace,” “Hate has no home here,” and “Are we Great yet? Black Lives Matter.”

As the scene played out, Jerone Darden of Bethlehem performed a Native American smudging ceremony, burning sage to purge the air of negative energy and bring forth the positive.

At least 200 people filled the Triangle, the pro-Trump crowd double the size of the Black Lives Matter group. Never did the tension boil over. That was how organizers of both groups wanted it.

Before the event, they agreed to keep the peace. Brendan Schoepflin, who organized the Trump supporters, said he carried a rifle there, as he did to a pro-police rally outside Allentown City Hall Wednesday, for protection in case things erupted.

When Ed DeGrace, donning a Black Lives Matter T-shirt, asked Garrett Boyer, who was wearing a military helmet, why he brought a gun to a peaceful protest, Boyer said he was in the Army and, “I needed this weapon two months ago when I was stationed in Philadelphia getting Molotov cocktails thrown at me.”

Ron Sell, a lifelong Emmaus resident, attended the pro-Trump rally. He has a permit to carry a concealed weapon but said he’s never used a gun and hopes not to.

“I have no hate toward them,” he said, referring to the Black Lives Matter protesters. “If they had guns, I wouldn’t mind.”

As the rallies wound down, individuals from opposing groups splintered off into civil one-on-one conversations.

Alex O’Neill, a recent Emmaus High School graduate from the Black Lives Matter group, and Ron Paul Jr., sporting a Trump T-Shirt, spoke at length about corporations controlling politics, extremists on both ends of the political spectrum and the need to weed them out.

“Hey, I love you,” Paul told O’Neill as he left. O’Neill chuckled and said, “I love you, too.”

 

Testimony (2)

logo Latest in a series of posts about the Bethlehem Police logo

In an effort to gauge the state of trust between the community and the police department, Gadfly seeks first-person testimony of interactions — good and bad — with police. All communication will be confidential, all posting anonymous. Contact through the blog or at ejg1@lehigh.edu. 

Transcription of July 23 phone conversation

Gadfly:

My daughter ran upstairs to tell me the police were outside. The police were right outside.  There was a very visible presence. There were 2 police cars, a motorcycle, and 5 policemen. I went out on the front porch to observe. There was this young Black man who looked like he was exercising in the neighborhood. He had on exercise gear. He wasn’t carrying anything with him. He had sneakers and athletic gear on. At first they were just questioning him. I was on high alert. Five cops and one very young-looking man – he didn’t look older than 20. He looked like a high school kid. So they were questioning him, questioning him, questioning him for a long time. Nothing violent happened. That was my worst fear. Fortunately, nothing of that sort happened. But there were a few reasons why I was concerned, One, they were aggressively questioning him, and then they arrested him. And the cop that was doing a lot of the questioning and who actually patted him down, went through his pockets – he was in very close physical proximity – had no mask on at all. And he was in this guy’s face. And it seemed to me given the global pandemic, that the police, closer than 6 feet, unable to social distance, should be setting the example and they should be the example of safety because regardless of whether this guy was a criminal or not he doesn’t deserve to be exposed to the virus by this cop. He could be innocent for all we know. And even if he’s not innocent, he still doesn’t deserve to be exposed possibly. So that was very concerning because they weren’t wearing masks. At least the cop who came very close to him wasn’t. A couple of the other ones were. The other thing that just bothers me is that I’m on the neighborhood blog and I see the emails people send and people are very racist. People say all the time like I saw this suspicious person outside with dark skin and blah-blah-blah and I’ve never seen this person in the neighborhood before, and it’s really suspicious activity and so I feel that people in my neighborhood are racially profiling. And it gets very frustrating because, again, I know nothing about the criminality of this young man, he could well have been engaged in criminal activity, but it just keeps bothering me very much that I see this type of racial profiling happening in my neighborhood whether it’s my neighbors doing it or the police doing it. One of my neighbors said that the police had been in the store at the corner of the street looking for some homeless guy. And I said this kid was clearly not homeless. He did not look like a homeless person. So who knows what the truth is there. It’s just very frustrating that every time you hear these stories, every time somebody is doing suspicious activity it’s always a Black person. It feels very unfair, and I don’t understand why this keeps happening. It felt like they were questioning him for a very long time. They were going back and forth and then all of a sudden they arrested him. At first I thought they were going to give him a ticket or something because he took out this notebook and a piece of paper and started writing something on it. Before they left I asked the cop as a concerned citizen what was going on in my neighborhood, and he said he was suspected of criminal activity elsewhere. Some earlier crime that happened elsewhere. Prompted by frustration in this national moment and just sadness, so at that point I called the police to inquire because if there was some criminal activity in my neighborhood I wanted to know about it. If not, I wanted to know if my neighbors were racially profiling. And also to point out to the officer that it’s a sign of basic respect to wear a mask and that the officers should be held accountable. These are mandates from the governor, you know. So why is it ok for a cop to get right in front of somebody’s face without a mask on, it just doesn’t seem right. The person I spoke with was very indignant that the cop did nothing wrong and wouldn’t give me any information whatsoever and told me that it was basically up to the police whether they wanted to wear a mask, which I thought was absurd. And the other frustrating thing was that I talked with this person on the phone for a while and explained everything that happened and afterwards he was like if you want to file a complaint you have to come down to City Hall to file a complaint. And I said well I thought I was filing a complaint by speaking to you on the phone and he said, no, you have to file a complaint, and I said in the middle of a global pandemic you want me to come inside the police station and file a report? like it just doesn’t seem right, they make it as difficult a possible to file a report. So I can call this number and tell you what happened and this doesn’t count as filing a report – it’s very annoying. So that person I spoke with was very dismissive on the phone when I expressed my concerns as a member of the community. He looked like he was a jogger. I took a photo and sent it to all my friends in a text chain and asked if anybody knows this kid and nobody knew him but several people said that they’ve seen him exercising in the neighborhood before. Sounds to me like he’s somebody who lives in the neighborhood. It was hard to hear everything that was exactly being said but he was calmly talking to them. He was very, very calm, he complied with everything the officers told him. They questioned him for a good 25 minutes or so. That’s pretty much what happened.

———–

See Testimony (1)

Allentown Councilman Siegel: “We can both praise the cops for doing good work and also re-imagine public safety”

logo Latest in a series of posts responding to the George Floyd killing logo

Allentown City Council meeting July 29, 2020, video
mins. 3:10:05 – 3:16:00

Gadfly reminds you that we’ve been following the Allentown discussion on police matters triggered by the murder of George Floyd. His purpose, as always, is to lay out all the voices on an issue to aid us in making up our own minds.

We end here with the spirited conclusion to the meeting by Councilman Siegel, the co-sponsor with Councilwoman Gerlach of the Allentown resolution, the most spirited segment of the meeting.

Gadfly invites you to reflect on what you saw, on what we can learn from the Allentown proceedings. What issues, what arguments, what “styles” caught your attention?

Councilman Siegel:

This is unfortunate in our country that we constantly refer to ourselves . . . immediately revert to the ideological ways of framing our world . You’re anti-cop, you’re pro-cop, liberal, you’re a Republican, you’re progressive, you’re not, it’s all frankly BS, and it’s a way to just structure the world in a way that pits us against each other. I’ve been called a hypocrite in previous weeks, and frankly it’s a crock of crap. I’m not a hypocrite. I think we can both praise the police department for the good work you do when you guys catch criminals, when you take drug gangs off the streets, when you take drugs and guns off Siegel 2the streets, that is keeping us safe and you deserve every bit of praise for doing it. But don’t think that that insulates institutions and organizations from criticism for things that they do wrong. You can do both. We can both praise the cops for doing good work and also re-imagine public safety in this country and look for ways in which we can spend our money better. Maybe that means making sure when you think you’re having a mental health crisis or you’re going through a social issue or a substance abuse issue that the cops aren’t the first freakin’ call, the first person on the scene. And, by the way, there are models in this country that work, are models that we can apply to Allentown. Yes that we need to adjust. Yes we must adjust to the fact that there might be language barriers or racial discrepancies but when Eugene, Oregon, can do Cahoots [?], when they can take care of 17% of their call line for 2% of their police budget and last year there were 24,000 Cahoots calls and only 150 of them required police back up, I’m sick and tired of people mischaracterizing these incidents as devolving into violence and chaos. We heard some of these letters tonight, I just hear the vitriol and the racism and the freaking backwards thinking that comes through. To insinuate that I want to divest money or redirect money . . . that I am in favor of rape and murder and gangs, are you kidding me? What kind of deranged, delusional, paranoid mindset does that emanate from? That’s not healthy, that’s not contributing to the conversation. I’ve had many people email me over the last few weeks, called me names, called me derogatory things. You know what, I emailed them back and had honest, frank, and genuine conversation trying to find consensus with them . You know, with a lot of the people we found common ground. Everybody in this country deserves respect, and I’m not going to draw a false equivalency between the racist and vitriolic statements that we have gotten . . . spray the protestors down with hoses . . . they said they’re all on welfare. Absolutely freakin’ not. I’m not going to draw a comparison between that and people who have faced 400 years of structural oppression and death and violence and say that’s the same thing as their yelling at the cops and these people are calling them animals. It’s not the same freakin’ thing, we should not draw that false equivalency. We should not cast them in the same way as people who show up with American flags with crosses on them, we know what that means, we know what they’re getting at, we know they are white supremacists who try to infiltrate that, we know where one side is coming from. Ok, we want to have an honest conversation in the city, I’m more than ready, and Chief I’m prepared to work with you in any way I can. I want you to be a partner in this, I want you to be an ally. I don’t hate you, I respect you, I think we can be friends, I’ve never said anything bad about you. I want you and I to be partners and friends but at the same time recognize that change and real leadership is about confronting institutions, it’s about having uncomfortable conversations, change is not doing what we all agree on, change is not saying these are the things that don’t offend any of us so that’s what we’re going to do. That’s not change, that’s the illusion of change., that’s symbolic justice, that’s us flying the Pride flag but behind the scenes saying transphobic stuff, that’s companies in America tweeting Black Lives Matter but then not fully paying their taxes to fully fund our schools. We’re done with symbolic justice in this country, we’re done with symbolic gestures, we’re going to actually put our money where our mouth is as a city because the world is watching, the country is watching, and you’d better believe the citizens of Allentown are watching, and they’re gonna have their voices heard. And I’m more than prepared to keep an open mind. As we talked tonight I realized there are things that I put on this list that we thought might have been possible and they have a state dynamic. I’m more than willing to understand that I was wrong about how we could do some of these things. I thought there was a local dynamic, clearly there isn’t. I am an open-minded individual, I evolve, and I change, and I respect that I’m not always right. I was wrong about some of these things, we adapted and adjusted, and now we’re going to do a state-wide approach, but the things we can do at the local level, you better darn well believe we are going to. I have 4 years, I may only get 4 years, the people of Allentown may keep me from doing what I’m doing, but I’m going to do what I think is right. And I’m going to work in every capacity that I can from this day and the day I may be removed from office but I’m going to do what’s right. And I want to say to everybody on this stage that you might not like me, you might not like what I stand for, I respect you as my colleagues, I respect you as professionals that I will work with, but, believe me, I’m going to hold you individually accountable, when I disagree where we are ideologically. That’s all I’m going to say. I will never call people names. I will never besmirch your personal character, but I will call you out when we are ideologically different, and I will push you to be on the right side of what I think the issue is, and I hope you can understand that. That’s the nature of politics, that’s the nature of elected leaders, that the nature of being leaders. We will butt heads because we have strong values and convictions. And I just want to make that clear that now is the time for real action and that’s going to make people feel uncomfortable and I’m sorry. It’s easy to run for office  . . . the hard part comes when you have to start making the changes . . . I apologize to you for the email, for what I did it was wrong . . . should not have released  your phone number, I fucked up, shouldn’t have done that, that was my fault, it’s on me, I own that mistake, shouldn’t have done it . . . me being a man, I screwed up, I violated your trust. That reflects poorly on me, I get that. But at the end of the day we all have a job to do. I’m gonna close with this. John F. Kennedy said we should not seek the Republican answer or the Democratic answer, let us find the right answer. Let us not blame the past but all collectively accept responsibility for the future. And that’s what we have to do. This is not about partisanship, not about who we are but finding the right answer, that means putting aside our emotions and our egos and following the facts like you said Chief, what works, what’s evidence based. And that’s it.

Councilman Siegel’s rapid delivery presented a challenge here and there for transcription. Gadfly apologizes for any errors.